Tuesday, August 24, 2021

Offbeat Humor

 

Sail Away (Sail Away)

Sail Away (Sail Away)
Song by Noël Coward

When a sailor goes to sea
Though he leaves his love behind
Time and tide will set him free
From the grief inside him
Sea and sky will ease his heart
Regulate his troubled mind
Every sailor has a chart
And a star to guide him home

When the storm clouds are riding through a winter sky
Sail away, sail away
When the love light is fading in your sweetheart's eye
Sail away, sail away
When you feel your song
Is orchestrated wrong
Why should you prolong your stay?
When the wind and the weather blow your dreams sky high
Sail away, sail away, sail away

Love is meat to make us glad
Love can make the world go round
Love can drive you raving mad
Torment and upset you
Love can give your heart a jolt
But philosophers have found
That it's wise to do a bolt
When it starts to get you down

When your life seems too difficult to rise above
Sail away, sail away
When your heart feels as dreary as a worn-out glove
Sail away, sail away
But when soon or late
You recognize your fate
That will be your great, great day
On the wings of the morning with your own true love
Sail away, sail away, sail away


Data Talks

 

Old Dutch Building, Fishkill, New York, 1916 by Childe Hassam

Old Dutch Building, Fishkill, New York, 1916 by Childe Hassam















Click to enlarge.

Monday, August 23, 2021

Masks, effective transmission reduction strategy or performance theater?

One of the challenges of an environment in which there is a discrepancy between what government institutions want the evidence to be versus what independent researchers find the evidence to be is simply keeping track of the evidence over time as studies come out in dribs and drabs.

Inevitably, unless the issue is central to your existence or to your business, you end up with a running total in your mind, subject to faulty memory and confusion as the mainstream media often end up describing the results from the same study in dramatically different ways.

My impression of the effectiveness of mask wearing as prophylactic to disease spread was that it had low to negligible effect, much depending on the mask, the circumstances and the fashion of wear.  This impression was reflected in the standard protocols pre-Covid-19 which dismissed ordinary masks as ineffective.  The impression was further bolstered at the beginning of the pandemic when various health authorities sought actively to discourage people from mask wearing as an ineffective measure.

Then the mask bandwagon began to build and some, but not all, health authorities began encouraging mask wearing despite standard epidemic protocols, despite their own earlier recommendations against mask wearing and despite the absence of any rigorous studies supporting the effectiveness of mask wearing.

From the outside, it felt as if health authorities simply wanted to be seen to be doing something in the face of an unknown and frustratingly mysterious novel virus.  

As time went by, I began seeing more and more studies emerge from researchers around the world, some indicating support for the effectiveness of mask wearing and others indicating non-effectiveness.  I began keeping a running mental sum of the outcomes.

A further challenge was that the quality of the studies varied enormously, ranging from worthless to occasionally very rigorous.  Ideally what you are looking for are large population sample sizes adhering to randomly controlled trials, preferably with pre-registration of methodology and with open access to resulting data.  These were few and far between.  

My sense was that the stronger and more rigorous the study, the more likely it was to find that masks had little or no effect.

This is consistent with many of the case studies in Scientific Fictions: How Fraud, Bias, Negligence, and Hype Undermine the Search for Truth by Stuart Ritchie.  Some exciting finding is claimed (often in the field of sociology or psychology), there is tremendous media attention and pundit jabbering, essays are written, interviews given.  Over months and then years, efforts are made to replicate the exciting finding.  Eventually it is discovered that the findings fails to replicate and that the more rigorous the replication effort, the less likely it is to find the original results.  And despite all that, the original, un-replicated paper ends up keeping being cited in a positive fashion.  Think of the Implicit Attitude test, or claims about micro-aggressions or similar such nonsense.

The twitter account https://twitter.com/ianmSC, IM routinely posts charts showing the time of mask implementations and the case volumes over time.  Visually it is a striking argument against the effectiveness of masks even though RCTs are the better evidence.  See below:

So masks, effective transmission reduction strategy or performance theater?

My conclusion for several months, on the balance of evidence, has been that it is performance theater.  It will still be some time before we really know, but Do Masks Work?  A review of the evidence by Jeffrey H. Anderson is a useful and reassuring confirmation that my running tally was broadly correct.  He discusses the issues around study design, RCTs as the gold standard for causal research, the cherry picking of weak studies which seems to have been a public health authority habit, and the results from the fourteen strongest designed studies conducted so far.

In sum, of the 14 RCTs that have tested the effectiveness of masks in preventing the transmission of respiratory viruses, three suggest, but do not provide any statistically significant evidence in intention-to-treat analysis, that masks might be useful. The other eleven suggest that masks are either useless—whether compared with no masks or because they appear not to add to good hand hygiene alone—or actually counterproductive. Of the three studies that provided statistically significant evidence in intention-to-treat analysis that was not contradicted within the same study, one found that the combination of surgical masks and hand hygiene was less effective than hand hygiene alone, one found that the combination of surgical masks and hand hygiene was less effective than nothing, and one found that cloth masks were less effective than surgical masks.

It is a  still hotly debated field, many further research efforts of increasing strength may overturn these findings, but I suspect we are getting onto firmer ground.  As a population strategy for reducing transmission, ordinary cloth masks (single or double masked) do not work.  


After five months of dragnet arrests nationwide, a few reporters have noted that no one was actually charged with insurrection or sedition.

This is a very good piece.  From The FBI comes up empty-handed in its search for a Jan. 6 plot by Jonathan Turley.  It echoes the observations I made in a post a few days ago but his argument is clearer and more robust than mine.  

This was a demonstration, not an insurrection.  The insistence on calling it an insurrection is a legal and political power play with no empirical merit.  Politicians are distorting the law by applying different standards for the same actions.  

More than 570 people have been arrested, but only 40 face conspiracy charges. Those charges are often based on prior discussions about trying to enter Congress or bringing material to use in the riot; some clearly came prepared for rioting with ropes, chemical irritants and other materials. Those cases, however, are a small group among the hundreds charged and an even smaller percentage among the tens of thousands of protesters on that day.

After five months of dragnet arrests nationwide, a few reporters have noted that no one was actually charged with insurrection or sedition. The vast majority of people face charges such as simple trespass. For example, the latest guilty plea is from San Francisco real estate broker Jennifer Leigh Ryan, who posted an account on social media of how "we're gonna go down and storm the capitol." She pleaded guilty this week to "parading, demonstrating, or picketing in a Capitol building" and faces a maximum sentence of six months in prison and a fine of $5,000.

Yet the characterization of the “insurrection” has continued as a virtual article of faith for those reporting on or writing about Jan. 6. Moreover, the treatment of many has remained severe, if not draconian by design. Justice official Michael Sherwin proudly declared in a television interview that “our office wanted to ensure that there was shock and awe. ... It worked because we saw through media posts that people were afraid to come back to D.C. because they’re like, ‘If we go there, we're gonna get charged.’ ... We wanted to take out those individuals that essentially were thumbing their noses at the public for what they did.”

That “shock and awe” included holding people without bail and imposing “restrictive housing” for no obvious reason. That includes some of the most notable figures from that day, such as Jacob Chansley (aka Jake Angeli), better known as “Chewbacca man” or the “QAnon shaman” for the distinctive horned headdress he wore during the riot. Angeli, 33, is not accused of attacking anyone while parading around the Senate floor in his bear skin. He always insisted he was not trying to overthrow the nation with his decorative outfit and spear-topped flagpole. While the government did not find that he engaged in sedition, it did learn that he has an array of mental illnesses, including transient schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression and anxiety. Yet he has been held since the riot and is charged with six crimes, including violent entry, trespass and parading, which collectively could yield up to 28 years in prison.

The rebuilding of citizen trust in government depends on members of government demonstrating greater philosophical consistency and trustworthiness than they appear willing to do. 


History

 

An Insight

From T.S. Eliot, The Cocktail Party from 1949.   

Half of the harm that is done in this world
Is due to people who want to feel important.
They don't mean to do harm—but the harm does not interest them. 
Or they do not see it, or they justify it 
Because they are absorbed in the endless struggle 
To think well of themselves.

 Think, Social Justice Theory devotees and Critical Race Theory hustlers.


What is it with Rachel?

Spam calls are the social gnat of modern society.  An annoying nuisance about which all complain but in the scheme of things trivial.  An annoyance, not a wound.

One of the minimal blessings of the Covid-19 shutdown was a seeming hiatus in spam calls.  I don't know if it happened to everyone but certainly my experience has been pleasant.  Days and even weeks at a stretch without the mindless and fruitless interruption of spam calls.

And now they seem back.  As is Rachel.

Rachel was the unfortunate eponym of one such common spam call.

Hello.  This is Rachel from cardholder services . . . 

I don't remember whether she was selling credit ratings or scamming.  It was a call which after you received two or three, you forever after ignored and hung up immediately.

I just received a spam call and Rachel has been repurposed.

Hello.  This is Rachel.  Your car registration just crossed my desk and . . . 

Did she change jobs?  Take on a new assignment?  Get moved into a different product division?

Is she perhaps suffering some sort of existential dread.  After so many years as Rachel from cardholder services, it can't be easy to now be the same cheery Rachel of car registrations.  

All questions to which we probably can't know an answer.  Poor old Rachel.


Turning from the bitter task of repenting our own sins to the congenial one of bewailing—but, first, of denouncing—the conduct of others.

Fascinating.  From God in the Dock, a collection of C.S. Lewis essays collected and published in 1970.  In it, there is an essay, Dangers of National Repentance, which neatly encapsulates the misplaced moral fervor of today's adherents to Critical Race Theory and Social Justice Theory.  The essay was first published in 1940, somewhat more than a year into World War II.  There was a stirring among young Christians in Britain to blame the war on the sins of Britain rather than the abominations of Germany's Hitler, Italy's Mussolini or Japan's military Junta. 

In other words, it was the same childish logical inversion of responsibility, initially for shock value and later from stubborn intransigence, which we see today among CRT/SJT adherents.  An inversion despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.  

CRT/SJT adherents wish us to condemn the very history, values and philosophies which ended slavery, emancipated the poor and women, and granted full rights to everyone to be equally protected under the law.  The values which established the systems of self-actualization which have yielded our historically unprecedented wealth, prosperity, and freedoms so widely shared today.  

Instead, CRT/SJT adherents wish to ignore those achievements and instead hold everyone today, save themselves, accountable not so much for past failures (though those were present) but rather condemn the past for not bringing the astonishing present to fruition sooner.  It is childishness without the innocence of a child.  

The invocation of White Guilt and charge of accountability for the actions of others in the past is merely a modern form of racism married to the desire for painless penitence described by Lewis.  It is also a form of very real class oppression as those desiring national repentance (CRT/SJT) are overwhelmingly among the most financially privileged in the nation.  They have attended the best schools and inherited the best money and now indulge themselves in a belief system which allows them not only to condemn others but to condemn those classes whom they consider lower and less enlightened.  Classes who are really merely less privileged.  And a condemnation which is closely married to destructive hatred and real social punishments from which the national repentance (CRT/SJT) adherents are held safe.  

From the essay, emphasis added.  

The idea of national repentance seems at first sight to provide such an edifying contrast to that national self-righteousness of which England is so often accused and with which she entered (or is said to have entered) the last war, that a Christian naturally turns to it with hope.  Young Christians especially—last-year undergraduates and first-year curates—are turning to it in large numbers.  They are ready to believe that England bears part of the guilt for the present war, and ready to admit their own share in the guilt of England.  What that share is, I do not find it easy to determine.  Most of these young men were children, and none of them had a vote or the experience which would enable them to use a vote wisely, when England made many of those decisions to which the present disorders could plausibly be traced.  Are they, perhaps, repenting what they have in no sense done?

If they are, it might be supposed that their error is very harmless: men fail so often to repent their real sins that the occasional repentance of an imaginary sin might appear almost desirable.  But what actually happens (I have watched it happening) to the youthful national penitent is a little more complicated than that.  England is not a natural agent, but a civil society.  When we speak of England’s actions we mean the actions of the British Government.  The young man “who is called upon to repent of England’s foreign policy is really being called upon to repent the acts of his neighbour; for a Foreign Secretary or a Cabinet Minister is certainly a neighbour.  And repentance presupposes condemnation.  The first and fatal charm of national repentance is, therefore, the encouragement it gives us to turn from the bitter task of repenting our own sins to the congenial one of bewailing—but, first, of denouncing—the conduct of others.  If it were clear to the young that this is what he is doing, no doubt he would remember the law of charity.   Unfortunately the very terms in which national repentance is recommended to him conceal its true nature.  By a dangerous figure of speech, he calls the Government not ‘they’ but ‘we’.  And since, as penitents, we are not encouraged to be charitable to our own sins, nor to give ourselves the benefit of any doubt, a Government “which is called ‘we’ is ipso facto placed beyond the sphere of charity or even of justice.  You can say anything you please about it.  You can indulge in the popular vice of detraction without restraint, and yet feel all the time that you are practising contrition.  A group of such young penitents will say, ‘Let us repent our national sins’; what they mean is, ‘Let us attribute to our neighbour (even our Christian neighbour) in the Cabinet, whenever we disagree with him, every abominable motive that Satan can suggest to our fancy.’

Such an escape from personal repentance into that tempting region

Where passions have the privilege to work
And never hear the sound of their own names,1

would be welcome to the moral cowardice of anyone.  But it is doubly attractive to the young intellectual.  When a man over forty tries to repent the sins of England and to love her enemies, he is attempting something costly; for he was brought up to certain patriotic sentiments which cannot be mortified without a struggle.  But an educated man who is now in his twenties usually has no such sentiment to mortify.  In art, in literature, in politics, he has been, ever since he can remember, one of an angry and restless minority; he has drunk in almost with his mother’s milk a distrust of English statesmen and a contempt for the manners, pleasures, and enthusiasms of his less-educated fellow countrymen.  All Christians know that they must forgive their enemies.  But ‘my enemy’ primarily means the man whom I am really tempted to hate and traduce.  If you listen to young Christian intellectuals talking, you will soon find out who their real enemy is.  He seems to have two names—Colonel Blimp and ‘the business-man’.  I suspect that the latter usually means the speaker’s father, but that is speculation.  What is certain is that in asking such people to forgive the Germans and Russians and to open their eyes to the sins of England, you are asking them, not to mortify, but to indulge, their ruling passion.  I do not mean that what you are asking them is not right and necessary in itself; we must forgive all our enemies or be damned.  But it is emphatically not the exhortation which your audience needs.  The communal sins which they should be told to repent are those of their own age and class—its contempt for the uneducated, its readiness to suspect evil, its self-righteous provocations of public obloquy, its breaches of the Fifth Commandment.2  Of these sins I have heard nothing among them.  Till I do, I must think their candour towards the national enemy a rather inexpensive virtue.  If a man cannot forgive the Colonel Blimp next door whom he has seen, how shall he forgive the Dictators whom he hath not seen?

Is it not, then, the duty of the Church to preach national repentance?  I think it is.  But the office—like many others—can be profitably discharged only by those who discharge it with reluctance.  We know that a man may have to ‘hate’ his mother for the Lord’s sake.3  The sight of a Christian rebuking his mother, though tragic, may be edifying; but only if we are quite sure that he has been a good son and that, in his rebuke, spiritual zeal is triumphing, not without agony, over strong natural affection.  The moment there is reason to suspect that he enjoys rebuking her—that he believes himself to be rising above the natural level while he is still, in reality, grovelling below it in the unnatural—the spectacle becomes merely disgusting.  The hard sayings of our Lord are wholesome to those only who find them hard.  There is a terrible chapter in M. Mauriac’s Vie de Jésus.  When the Lord spoke of brother and child against parent, the other disciples were horrified.  Not so Judas.  He took to it as a duck takes to water: ‘Pourquoi cetter stupeur?, se demande Judas. . . . Il aime dans le Christ cette vue simple, ce regard de Dieu sur l’horreur humaine.’4  For there are two states of mind which face the Dominical paradoxes without flinching.  God guard us from one of them.

 _____________________________________

1 Wordsworth, The Prelude, bk. XI, Line 230.
2 ‘Honour thy father and thy mother; that thy days may be long in the land which the Lord thy God giveth thee.’ Exodus xx. 12.
3 Luke xiv. 26: ‘If any man come to me, and hate not his father, and mother, and wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own life also, he cannot be my disciple.’
4 François Mauriac, Vie de Jésus (Paris, 1936), ch. ix. ‘ “Why this stupefaction?” asked Judas . . . He loved in Christ his simple view of things, his divine glance at human depravity.'