Saturday, March 14, 2026

History

 

An Insight

 

I see wonderful things

 

Offbeat Humor

 

Data Talks

 

Stormy Sea off Alexandria, 1923 by Ernst Karl Eugen Koerner

Stormy Sea off Alexandria, 1923 by Ernst Karl Eugen Koerner (Poland/Germany, 1846-1927)

















Click to enlarge.

We don’t know what we believe until we’re asked

Heh.  I have a post somewhere way back towards the beginning of Thingfinder in 2007 expressing this precise sentiment - writing in order to test my thinking.  
I also had the additional objective to create a record for myself to see how my thinking and understanding of things evolved over time.   

Theories of economic development

From NOTE TO SELF: All of the Currently Live Theories of the Causes of the "European Miracle"
by Brad DeLong.  The subheading is & was the “European Miracle” 800-1914, 1492-1914, 1689-1914, or 1776-1914?...

As he notes, "of course, highly overlapping"

Local geography & resources (coal, land, disease environment):
Jared Diamond, Kenneth Pomeranz, Robert Allen, Paul Bairoch, Fernand Braudel, Mark Koyama & Jared Rubin, Eric Jones, Leonid Grinin & Andrey Korotayev

Institutions, property rights & representative government:
Douglass North & Robert Thomas, Daron Acemoglu–Simon Johnson–James Robinson, Avner Greif, Joel Mokyr, Gary Cox, DeLong & Shleifer, Robert Brenner, Chris Isett, Eric Jones

Political fragmentation, competition & “market for ideas”:
Jared Diamond, Joel Mokyr, Niall Ferguson, Eric Jones, James Belich, Mark Koyama, Tuan-Hwee Sng, De la Croix–Doepke–Mokyr (guilds/journeymen)

Culture, religion & “WEIRD” psychology / Protestant ethic:
Max Weber, David Landes, Deirdre McCloskey, Joseph Henrich, Larry Siedentop, Nathan Rosenberg & L.E. Birdzell, Timur Kuran (for Islamic-world contrast), Justin Yifu Lin, Yasheng Huang, Eric Jones

High-wage economy & inducement mechanisms (wages, prices, factor prices):
Robert Allen, Gregory Clark, Jan Luiten van Zanden, Stephen Broadberry, Bishnupriya Gupta, Allen–Bassino–Ma–Moll-Murata–van Zanden

New World, coal, & “accidents” (California school/contingency):
Kenneth Pomeranz, Prasannan Parthasarathi, Jack Goldstone, Andre Gunder Frank, John Hobson, Jeffrey Williamson, Diego Comin, Acemoglu–Zilibotti (risk/diversification)

Colonialism, slavery, & deindustrialization at the periphery:
Eric Williams, Paul Bairoch, Amiya Kumar Bagchi, Prasannan Parthasarathi, Jeffrey Williamson, Tirthankar Roy (partly revisionist), Daron Acemoglu et al. (institutional twist), James Walvin

Human capital, knowledge transmission, & guilds:
De la Croix–Doepke–Mokyr (guilds/journeymanship), Bas van Bavel & coauthors (capital goods diffusion), Timur Kuran (Islamic legal forms
& firms), Mark Dincecco (state capacity & public finance)

Demography, Black Death, & Malthusian-escape dynamics:
James Belich, Oded Galor, Mark Koyama & coauthors, David Weir, Allen/Bairoch/van Zanden on wages, demography,
& living standards

Globalization, trade structure & core–periphery dynamics (19th c. “Big Bang”):
Kevin O’Rourke, Jeffrey Williamson, Guillaume Daudin, Leandro Prados de la Escosura, Paul Bairoch, Leonid Grinin & Andrey Korotayev

Friday, March 13, 2026

Aristocrats by Keith Douglas

From The Complete Poems of Keith Douglas, edited by Desmond Graham.  

Aristocrats
by Keith Douglas

The noble horse with courage in his eye, 
clean in the bone, looks up at a shellburst: 
away fly the images of the shires
but he puts the pipe back in his mouth.

Peter was unfortunately killed by an 88
it took his leg away, he died in the ambulance.
I saw him crawling on the sand, he said 
It’s most unfair, they’ve shot my foot off.

How can I live among this gentle
obsolescent breed of heroes, and not weep ?
Unicorns, almost,
for they are fading into two legends
in which their stupidity and chivalry
are celebrated. Each, fool and hero, will be an immortal.

These plains were their cricket pitch
and in the mountains the tremendous drop fences 
brought down some of the runners. Here then 
under the stones and earth they dispose themselves, 
I think with their famous unconcern.
It is not gunfire I hear, but a hunting horn.

Tunisia
1943


The poem from which this stanza is taken, originally entitled `Aristocrats', was written by Keith Douglas in Tunisia in 1943. It was occasioned by the death, on active service, of Lt. Col. J. D. Player, who left £3,000 to the Beaufort Hunt, and also directed that the incumbent of the living in his gift should be 'a man who approves of hunting, shooting, and all manly sports, which are the backbone of the nation.' (Desmond Graham (ed.), Keith Douglas: Complete Poems (1978), p. 139.) 

Remember to be humble about how small a portion is known compared to what could be known.

Well, good grief!  There is always something new to be learned.
His is an interesting observation on the origins of a couple of idioms.

That is not what has shaken me.

Marble Arch is the present day site of the old Tyburn Gallows, London's primary execution spot from 1196 until 1783?

I have lived in England on four occasions totaling six years from the mid 1960's onwards.  I have family there, including in London.  I have spent hundreds, if not thousands of days in London on business and leisure.  My sister had an apartment for a couple of years on Edgware Road not five or ten minutes from Marble Arch.  I have walked, ridden, and driven by Marble Arch thousands of times.  And yes, with tremendous trepidation, I have bicycled the roundabout around Marble Arch on more than one occasion as a teen courier.  

How on earth did I not know that it used to be Tyburn Gallows?

I read voluminously.  Maybe it just got crowded out.

I am no longer a youth.  Maybe I just forgot it.

Both seem unlikely.

My suspicion is that I knew that Marble Arch was the location of executions when I was anywhere up to my late teens but that the name Tyburn did not then have significance to me.  

My knowledge of the historical salience of Tyburn only came later with much deeper reading of English history.  I suspect that at different times I have known that Marble Arch was the site of executions and I must have even known that it used to be Tyburn Gallows but that by the time I focused on Tyburn Gallows from an historical reading perspective, I had forgotten the Marble Arch connection and never reconnected the two facts.  

It is a tissue thin rationale but I'll go with it.  And remember to be humble about how small a portion is known compared to what could be known.