Wednesday, September 14, 2016

The Affordable Beer Act

I usually agree with Megan McArdle but I think, in this instance, she is off mark. From Don't Make Colleges Pay for Student-Loan Defaults by Megan McArdle.
Incentives matter. This is a fundamental tenet of economics: People respond to their incentives. If something in a market seems to be going wrong, it’s because the incentives have gotten screwed up.

Looking at the market for education, it’s hard not to think that there’s something wrong with the incentives. Tuition keeps going up and so does debt. The percentage of people who are not paying off that debt — either because they are in default, deferment, or an income-based repayment program — is staggering. Naturally, a lot of folks would like to get the government in there to start tweaking those incentives until the market stops being so crazy.

One issue involves the incentives that schools have to ensure that their graduates get value out of their degrees. At the moment, a school can enroll you in practically any program, and the government will lend you money for tuition and living expenses, whether or not that degree is likely to produce the means to repay the loan. Since schools are often in a better position to know the economic value of their degrees than naive potential students, that twists the incentives. Eventually, the student will pay, either with money or trashed credit. If the loan defaults, taxpayers will pay too. The school has the most information about the transaction and yet it has the least at stake. No wonder we have such high tuition, so many dubious degree programs and such a troubling rate of default.

So why not make the schools care? That’s the idea behind “risk sharing,” a reform plan that is hot in Washington. The details come in various flavors, but the core is the same: When graduates default, their schools would be on the hook. That's already true to a small degree, but a school’s default rate has to be egregious before the government will take action. Ideally, risk-sharing would remove those thresholds for government action. Every time a student defaults, the school would pay some fraction of the lost money.

It sounds like an economist’s dream: simple, elegant and even just. Unfortunately, when you start digging into the details, it starts looking less elegant and more complicated.
She's right, it is complicated. Her concern is that
Penalizing schools with high dropout rates would undoubtedly deter schools from preying on naive students with no college graduates in their family background. But it would probably also discourage schools from admitting those sorts of students, because they are the ones who are more likely to default.
True enough. But that's the point. We don't want schools admitting students who will end up in debt and without a productive degree to show for it. Yes, it will have a disparate impact. All that argues for, though, is some marginal degree of attentiveness. Is there a policy approach that can ensure that the very poorest have the ability to graduate with a worthwhile degree. If so, let's implement it. What we should not do is keep immiserating poor students by having them take on debt loads for activities that won't improve their lives.

I think McArdle has been diverted by trying to create a poor analogy to an aspect of healthcare. These are not comparable dynamics and therefore her conclusion, I think, is wrong.

All that being said, the reward for reading is in the comments section. McArdle has generally excellent commenters and they have fun with this proposition,

Fish Heads • 2 days ago

We need an Affordable College Act, or ACA, with a mandate that everyone pays tuition whether they are in school or not. The cost curve would be bent downward, saving the average family a whopping $2,500 per year. Professors could finally get the raises they deserve, and college football coaches would no longer be overworked and underpaid. I'll be in my safe spot.

Jeff R. Fish Heads • 2 days ago

I liked Bernie Sanders' plan: college is getting more expensive, therefore the federal government should make it free. Simple, effective, well-reasoned, unobjectionable.

evadderf • 2 days ago

CRAFT BEER is getting more expensive, therefore the federal government should make
it free. Simple, effective, well-reasoned, unobjectionable.

FIFY

Ron Bruno • 2 days ago

The Affordable Beer Act-- as it turns out the possibilities for affordable legislation are endless.


Sigivald • 2 days ago

The Affordable Affordable Act Act.

Act.


Ann_In_Illinois • 2 days ago

Venezuela has led the way! I've been wanting a flat screen TV. When should I start stockpiling toilet paper?


eyethink2 • 2 days ago

If the thought of free beer makes you want to stockpile toilet paper, I don't want any of what you're having to drink. :)


eyethink2 Ron Bruno 2 days ago

I'll drink to that.


Jeffn • 2 days ago

I think we should push for this, actually. I figure when they start rationing beer, 20 or 30 states will secede within a month.

You can have my Hoppy IPA when you pry it from my frosty, dead fingers.

oilman_15106 Fish Heads • 2 days ago

OH would that be the $2500 a year in health insurance savings I am supposed to be getting?


SgtFraggleRock oilman_15106 • 2 days ago

Hey, at least you got to keep your doctor, right?

Yancey Ward SgtFraggleRock • 2 days ago

Hello, Doctor Hibbard Nick!


SgtFraggleRock Yancey Ward • 2 days ago

"You've tried the best. Now try the rest."

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

From favored visitors to vermin

That's something I didn't know. I thought Canadian Geese simply stopped migrating owing to an abundance of overwinter food. Apparently that's not quite the whole story. From Anatomy of a Miracle by William Langewiesche.
Canada geese used to have a better reputation. They were visitors from the distant north who graced New York each fall and spring, igniting people’s imaginations and providing essential connections to the vastness of the continent beyond the city. When they passed overhead in their majestic formations they seemed destined for faraway places. In the early 1960s, however, the situation began to change, after state wildlife agencies came up with a bioengineering scheme whose purpose in part was to enhance state revenues by stimulating the purchase of bird-hunting licenses. The agencies captured breeding pairs of an endangered but supersize subspecies known as the giant Canada goose, and by clipping their wings forced them to settle permanently into authorized nesting grounds along the Eastern Seaboard and elsewhere in the United States. The offspring of these clipped-wing geese imprinted to the new locations, and, having lost the collective memory of migration, became full-time resident populations. Simultaneously, it seems, other Canada geese may have given up on migration simply in response to changes in farming techniques, which left a new abundance of corn on the ground in the Midwest and the Middle Atlantic states. Then came Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring, the banning of certain pesticides and chemicals harmful to birds, the imposition of environmental-protection laws, and the associated gentrification of former farmlands in places such as Long Island, New Jersey, and Connecticut. The newly non-migratory giant Canada geese settled comfortably into a paradise with few predators, where hunting was frowned upon, where food was abundant, and where there were plenty of golf courses, corporate lawns, and protected wetlands to dominate. Nationwide their population grew from about 200,000 in 1970 to four million today. In New York they now vastly outnumber their migratory cousins. They are magnificent birds in flight, partly because of their size—with wingspans up to six feet. But they are also insatiable overgrazers and prodigious defecators—territorial and overprotective of their young, traits they share with many of their human neighbors. So, in a shift of public emotion, they are no longer seen as honored visitors but as vermin and pests.

Monday, September 12, 2016

In USA, high status men have more offspring than low status men (reverse among women)

Well, this is interesting, even though it is a generation old. I wonder if there is current data somewhere?



I have seen not dissimilar graphs for class but I don't believe I have ever seen one by gender.

How to interpret? Not much of a clue beyond its face value. In many ways this mirrors ancient social tropes. I wonder to what degree and in which direction this might have changed in the intervening 22 years? I wonder what the graphs look like by group cultural origin? How does this tie into Gregory Clark's work where he documents upper class higher offspring survival as a mechanism for disseminating high class culture into lower classes? So many questions.

And what is going on with the women element of the data? Upper class women having fewer children is a disapproved reality going back to Caesar Augustus complaining and trying to come up with a solution to get upper class women to have more children.

Economically it is entirely consistent with theory. Childbearing has significant career and monetary costs to the mother, IF she has high human capital (education, opportunities, status, etc.) A highly educated woman with a well-launched career gives up a lot financially in order to have children, regardless of how supportive might be her husband and company. Anything that costs more is consumed less. In terms of opportunity cost, children have a higher cost to upper class women, therefore they have, all other things being equal, fewer children.

Lower class women, potentially having lower human capital (status, opportunities and education) suffer less opportunity cost and indeed, from a life cycle insurance perspective, might be net beneficiaries of having children. Something that has a lower cost (and higher benefit) is consumed more.

So economic theory is consistent with the observed data.

But what about biological (evolutionary) theory? In what evolutionary scenario does it make sense that nominally (recognizing that all human life has equal inherent value) better off females should reproduce less? I guess, that is the part of the equation that makes least sense to me from a thinking perspective. Reminds me of that Idiocracy trailer.


Click to see full screen.

UPDATE: High Status Men (But Not Women) Capture the Eye of the Beholder from 2008.

UPDATE: The more I think about this, this is really just a data based visualization that is, perhaps, a corollary to the theory of hypergamy. I am still left with the question: hypergamy, assortative mating, and differential fertility by gender and class - what is the net impact of these somewhat divergent (and in tension) theories and realities?

An over-reliance on elite print-news sources can be disorienting

Jonathan Chait is an interesting writer. Definitely among the elite of the chattering class but usually more self-aware than most of his compatriots and more willingly honest. He has had a number of good articles this campaign season but that doesn't include this most recent, Matt Lauer’s Pathetic Interview of Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump Is the Scariest Thing I’ve Seen in This Campaign by Jonathan Chait.

He is quite honest about his commitment to the Democrats and therefore to the Democratic nominee, Hillary Clinton. Donald Trump is a shocking anathema to him. It is no great surprise that those who benefit from the status quo should wish for the status quo to continue, no matter how corrupt it might be.

This is an interesting admission though, relating to the recent interview conducted by Matt Lauer of Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump.
I had not taken seriously the possibility that Donald Trump could win the presidency until I saw Matt Lauer host an hour-long interview with the two major-party candidates. Lauer’s performance was not merely a failure, it was horrifying and shocking. The shock, for me, was the realization that most Americans inhabit a very different news environment than professional journalists. I not only consume a lot of news, since it’s my job, I also tend to focus on elite print-news sources. Most voters, and all the more so undecided voters, subsist on a news diet supplied by the likes of Matt Lauer. And the reality transmitted to them from Lauer matches the reality of the polls, which is a world in which Clinton and Trump are equivalently flawed.
I have not watched the interview but from all accounts I have seen, Lauer did indeed question both Clinton and Trump about equally. Or rather more equally than is common.

Chait's beef is that he reads the elite rags of the privileged chattering class and that based on those sources, he knows that Trump is "an ignorant, bigoted, pathologically dishonest authoritarian" and that Clinton is "a normal politician with normal political failings." He worries Lauer is not conveying that superior knowledge to the "average undecided voter," i.e. to the masses.

Chait is most exercised that Lauer spent much of his time questioning Clinton about her choice to avoid FOIA law and Department of State requirements that she use secure government accounts for all her official correspondence. Chait claims
The impression an uninformed or even moderately informed viewer would receive from this interview is that the email issue represents a sinister crime, perhaps completely disqualifying from office, rather than an unjustifiable but routine act of government non-transparency.
Chait is a bright and informed man. How is it possible that he could claim that this was a "routine act of government non-transparency." One of the reason's (among many) that the e-mail controversy remains germane is that it was not routine. In fact, it was exceptional. No other Secretary of State relied solely on a private network of her own concoction for all her official correspondence. And no other Secretary of State has been caught so completely misrepresenting (whether through culpability or carelessness remains to be seen) all her actions related to the e-mail server. This is by no means routine. This is Nixonian 18 1/2 minutes missing from the tape terrain.

You get the feeling that perhaps Chait must be suffering a massive confirmation bias filtering event. He claims that
Her decision to follow Colin Powell’s advice is a legitimate blot on her record.
as if he is unaware that Powell has publicly disclaimed ever giving her such advice. From the UK Times
“Her people have been trying to pin it on me,” Mr Powell said of the email controversy. “The truth is she was using [her private email server] for a year before I sent her a memo telling her what I did”
Let's revisit Chait's other blind spot. His claim that Hillary Clinton is "a normal politician with normal political failings."

We have had female politicians reach virtually every height (other than the Presidency or Vice Presidency) in our democratic system in the past hundred years. We have had wives fill out their deceased husbands terms many times. It is uncommon but by no means unknown. However, it is relatively rare that we have had a female politician try and leverage her own political career, Eva Peron-like, from her husband's. I am sure there must be some parallel at the state level at some time but I can think of no comparable example at the national level in the past fifty years. Hillary Clinton's near complete dependency for her political career on her husband's career is certainly not normal.

And speaking of Eva Peron, Hillary Clinton and Foundations, I came across a startling consonance from the lyrics of Evita by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. From the song And the Money Kept Rolling In (and Out).
Eva's pretty hands reached out and they reached wide
Now you may feel it should have been a voluntary cause
But that's not the point my friends
When the money keeps rolling in you don't ask how
Think of all the people guaranteed a good time now
Eva's called the hungry to her--opened up the doors!
Never been a fund like the Foundation Eva Peron!

[snip]

Now cynics claim a little of the cash has gone astray
But that's not the point my friends
When the money keeps rolling out you don't keep books
You can tell you've done well by the happy grateful looks
Accountants only slow things down, figures get in
the way
Never been a lady loved as much as Eva Peron!
Hillary Clinton's career is also not normal in terms of the breadth and depth of her scandals. From way back at the beginning in 1978 you have the Hillary Rodham cattle futures controversy. 38 years of financial questions and scandals. Not to mention her role in suppressing rape claims against Bill Clinton, suppression of bimbo eruptions, tawdry favor trading with Travelgate, Rose Law Firm missing billing files, Whitewater, the Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan collapse, the Clinton Foundation as a slush fund, trading State Department access for donations to the Clinton Foundation, and of course, most recently, the e-mail server and its attendant controversies (security, classified information, lying, etc.)

Controversies about money, sex, influence peddling, obstruction of justice, misconduct towards others, hiding evidence, lying under oath, access selling, fraud. That's a pretty broad set of controversies and over nearly four decades. There is nothing normal about that.

That profile of corruption is, very fortunately, rare. Sure, there are plenty of politicians that fall afoul of the law or accepted moral norms. That happens all the time. Money OR Sex OR Corruption OR Obstruction of Justice, etc. But that's OR not AND. Nobody has the whole package of venality as does Clinton.

The closest comparable politician I can think of in modern times for duration and variety of scandal is the former Governor of Louisiana, Edwin Edwards of "Laissez les bons temps rouler" fame. The only differences between Edwards and Clinton is that he was at a local level and she is at the national level and that he was brought to account for his crimes.

Contrary to Chait's claim, Hillary Clinton is not "a normal politician with normal political failings." In that regard she is indeed exceptional. That Chait might think otherwise seems a testament to industrial strength confirmation bias or to an over-reliance on "elite print-news sources" which are essentially Clinton campaign operatives with by-lines.

It is not Lauer or the American public that is alarming in this instance. It is the insulated world of the chattering classes.

Sunday, September 11, 2016

We have demonized those who produce

Good old Thomas Sowell. He is trenchant in his comments.




Saturday, September 10, 2016

Class based inflation rates?

So here's my question. I know, from Cowen's Second Law that the answer must be yes.

Is there any research on class-based inflation rates.

What I am thinking is that the Middle Class, the Lower Class, and Upper Class (or whatever nomenclature is preferred) have distinctively different consumption patterns. They buy different things in different amounts.

All consumption gets dumped into one big pot of data to derive a single inflationary index such as the Consumer Price Index.

But what if, based on the difference in consumption patterns, there are material differences in perceived inflation rates.

More specifically, I would speculate that the lower class of consumers probably face a lower inflation rate. They consume basic commodity items that are exposed to the most extreme competition which in general ought to keep inflation low.

I would guess that the upper class face the second lowest inflation rate owing to consumption opportunism. A much higher proportion of your consumption is purely optional so you can more easily choose to switch between categories of consumption based on market signals. Maybe exotic vacations are especially expensive this year and so instead you upgrade your car because the industry is in a downturn and offering great deals.

In this hypothesis, the middle class are the ones who take it in the neck. They are buying more than commodities but are also more financially constrained to patterns of established purchasing. They don't switch between categories of purchases, at best they postpone them. There is also an element of keeping up with the Joneses which likely makes them less responsive to adjusting spending patterns even if there are inflationary pressures.

Over the past few years, there seems to me from anecdotal conversations that there is a much higher perceived inflation rate than is reflected in the actual averaged data and there is certainly little apparent concern about inflation from the policy elite. But the policy elite are in the upper class. Perhaps they experience a materially lower effective inflation rate than do the much larger middle class?

I don't know, but it seems perhaps plausible.

Friday, September 9, 2016

Attractiveness or gravitas?

From Effects of Instructor Attractiveness on Learning by Richard Westfall, Murray Millar & Mandy Walsh

It's psychology research so caveat lector.

From the abstract:
Although a considerable body of research has examined the impact of student attractiveness on instructors, little attention has been given to the influence of instructor attractiveness on students. This study tested the hypothesis that persons would perform significantly better on a learning task when they perceived their instructor to be high in physical attractiveness. To test the hypothesis, participants listened to an audio lecture while viewing a photograph of instructor. The photograph depicted either a physically attractive instructor or a less attractive instructor. Following the lecture, participants completed a forced choice recognition task covering material from the lecture. Consistent with the predictions; attractive instructors were associated with more learning. Finally, we replicated previous findings demonstrating the role attractiveness plays in person perception.
I wonder if it is attractiveness per se, which I believe is quite conceivable, or whether it might not be fastidiousness. What I mean by that is whether people's assessment of attractiveness might be influenced by how the person is presented - not just their features but how they are dressed, etc. The old adage is that the clothes makes the man and I could conceive of a mechanism that delivers the above results not based on attractiveness but on perceived seriousness.

In other words, an unkempt slovenly person comes in to lecture. Are you going to accord them the seriousness that their expertise might deserve? I suspect not.

Alternatively, someone comes in dressed as a professional and presents themselves confidently. Do you take them more seriously and up your attentiveness game? I don't know but I suspect that the above results might be tied to that mechanism of gravitas signaling over simply attractiveness.

Ardent investigators or lackeys?

Iowahawk is on a roll.



There's freedom of speech. Then there's freedom from speech

Heh.



Thursday, September 8, 2016

But the graphs do show an echo chamber

From Relatively Few People Are Partisan News Consumers, but They’re Influential by Brendan Nyhan.
New research shows that the great majority of people learn about political news from mainstream, relatively centrist media sources, not ideological websites or cable channels. However, relatively small numbers of partisans, especially Republicans, are heavy consumers of a highly polarized media diet.

This dynamic helps explain why there is so much concern about “echo chambers,” even though most people don’t confine themselves to one.

To learn more about where people get their political news, Andy Guess, a postdoctoral researcher in social media and politics at New York University, recruited a nationally representative YouGov online survey panel. The nearly 1,400 panelists agreed to take part in a survey and to anonymously share data on their website visits over a three-week period in early 2015. This approach avoids the pitfalls of many previous studies, which typically ask people to recall their past news consumption — an approach that is plagued with measurement error. These website visits were then matched to estimates of media outlet “alignment” that are based on the self-described ideology of people who share articles from the website on Facebook.

The resulting data, which are reported in a new working paper by Mr. Guess, show the news diet of most respondents was remarkably centrist on average for both Democrats and Republicans alike. The two most common destinations for political news in his data were MSN.com and AOL.com, two large and relatively neutral online news portals.
Lots of red flags as to the methodology though the researchers seem well-intentioned.

One of my biggest concerns is how they rate the ideological skew of the different news sources and which ones they elected to include or not.

In terms of assessing the political skew of media sources, we know that the politics of reporters in all mainstream media skew much more liberal than the average American. Even reporters (as opposed to the editors) for such "conservative" news sources as Wall Street Journal and Fox News skew left.

The calibration that they provide seems wrong to me. I do not use either Fox or Breitbart as primary, or even secondary, sources of current news. But from years of episodic exposure, I would have judged Breitbart to be a genuinely provocative right-oriented new site comparable in nature and (opposite) degree as a left site such as Mother Jones or Daily Kos. The random sampling of news articles I have seen from Fox are nowhere near as provocative or ideological as Breitbart but they are rated basically the same for the study purposes. So something seems off on the calibration. Might be me but, given their methodology and given that the ratings are by opinion rather than empirical measure, I suspect that they err in their rankings.

In the original paper, they allude to one of the biggest right-oriented sites, drudgereport.com, but I don't see any data related to Drudge in their analysis. Drudge would be over there with Breitbart. Did they omit Drudge, and if so why? Drudge is one of the single largest sources of traffic for both the Washington Post as well as the New York Times. Not in a friendly way. He will link some of their more egregious reporting which sends tidal waves of offended conservatives over to comment.

A final concern. They identify MSN and AOL as centrist news aggregators. Again, I don't use either source but glancing at the sources for their articles, most of the aggregation appears to be from significantly left leaning publications. Throwing in a few sources from WSJ or Fox doesn't significantly leaven the skew.

So those are some of the concerns.

What are the conclusions from the study? That most readers are centrist in their news sourcing but that the ideological extremists among both Republicans and Democrats spend more time on their respective more extreme new sources. That's a very neutral interpretation. Not wrong so much as not quite revealing. Look at the distribution of the news sources, keeping in mind that MSN and AOL at the center are actually about 70-80% left leaning in their aggregation.

Click to enlarge. Source is the NYT.

The conclusion again was:
New research shows that the great majority of people learn about political news from mainstream, relatively centrist media sources, not ideological websites or cable channels.
But that's not quite what those graphs show. Rather, it is not all that they show.

A different description would be:
Democrats get all their news from left-leaning media and Conservatives get most their news from left-leaning media sources.
The claim that Democrats aren't in an echo chamber rests on the fact that significant numbers of them get information from AOL and MSN which are only 70-80% left leaning. Democrats read virtually no right-leaning news sources.

Meanwhile, Republicans clearly get the great majority of their news from left-leaning sources. They also happen to get some 20%(?) of their news from right leaning sources. One might say that they are much more committed to reading diversely than are Democrats if one wanted to be snarky.

Somebody has already made this point elsewhere, perhaps Jonathan Haidt. In fact, I think it is Haidt who did research asking left leaning and right leaning people to describe the policy positions of their opposite number. Around foreign policy, religion in school, abortion, safe spaces, gun control, all the normal hot button issues. People on the right were able to accurately describe left policy positions whereas people on the left were unable to accurately describe the policy positions of the right. The conclusion, or speculation, of the research was that people on the right aren't necessarily smarter than those on the left. They are simply more exposed to the left's positions than those on the left are exposed to the positions of those on the right.

This new research seems to support that conclusion.