Thursday, September 8, 2016

Anonymity by not using a family name? Not anymore.

Found via Tyler Cowen. He's quoting from an original newspaper account that reads:
In the northwest corner of Phnom Penh’s Boeng Keng Kang market, a new stall is creating a buzz among shoppers.

Its occupant is a 28-year-old former U.S. Peace Corps volunteer who offers tarot-card readings in Khmer. And customers say her predictions are on point.

With strings of fake leaves hanging from the ceiling, colorful paper butterflies affixed to one wall, and a sign that reads “Mantis Magic,” the booth—which has been open for two weeks—stands out from the neighboring hairdressers and food stalls.

“I didn’t have a job, I needed something to do and I wanted to help people through my spiritual work. I was getting messages to do this, so I just followed my gut,” said Eileen, who speaks conversational Khmer and asked to be identified only by her first name so that her mother in the U.S. would not find out about her new trade.

Originally from New York, Eileen said she graduated from West Virginia University with degrees in gender studies and criminal investigations before relocating to Cambodia nearly five years ago with the Peace Corps.
I can't help but feel that Eileen's confidence in retaining her anonymity by not using her last name might, perhaps, be misplaced when she is further identified as 28 years old, a Peace Corps volunteer, from WVU with a major in gender studies. I would have guessed that she hadn't heard of LinkedIn except that she has a LinkedIn profile that turns up with a search on the quoted characteristics.

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

What this country really needs is a good five-cent nickel

I start with a review of a collection of books about Dorothy Parker, Brilliant, Troubled Dorothy Parker by Robert Gottlieb. Gottlieb describes Parker's literary beginnings.
In 1915, Parker, aged twenty-two, went to work at Vogue (for ten dollars a week), writing captions, proofreading, fact-checking, etc., and after a while moved over to the very young Vanity Fair; her first poem to be published had recently appeared there. She happily functioned as a kind of scribe-of-all-work until three years later she was chosen to replace the departing P.G. Wodehouse as the magazine’s drama critic. She was not only the youngest by far of New York’s theater critics, she was the only female one.

It was at the magazine that she met the lovable and sympathetic Robert Benchley, who would become the closest friend of her life, as well as Robert Sherwood, long before his four Pulitzer Prizes (three for drama, one for biography). They became a threesome, and started eating lunch together at the nearby Algonquin Hotel because it was affordable and the food was okay. At about the same time, another threesome drifted in, graduates of Stars and Stripes, the overseas army’s weekly newspaper. They were Alexander Woollcott, Harold Ross, and Franklin Pierce Adams, who as “F.P.A.” was the most influential newspaper columnist of the day. Soon Adams was quoting Parker’s Vanity Fair verses and, even more effectively, her bon mots. Quickly “Dorothy Parker” was a celebrity.
Parker, Benchley, Woolcott, Ross. I have read works by all these. Sherwood I recognize but have not read any of his works.

But who is this FPA. I have been familiar with the Algonquin Round Table since at least college. I must have come across his name before. Apparently it never quite registered.

This seems to be one of those temporal ironies. At the time of the Algonquin Round Table, Franklin Pierce Adams was probably the best known and most popular writer in the group. He started his column The Conning Tower in 1914. Wikipedia notes:
During World War I, Adams was in the U.S. Army, serving in military intelligence and also writing a column, "The Listening Post", for Stars and Stripes editor Harold Ross. After the war, the so-called "comma-hunter of Park Row" (for his knowledge of the language) returned to New York and the Tribune. He moved to the New York World in 1922, and his column appeared there until the paper merged with the inferior New York Telegram in 1931. He returned to his old paper, by then called the New York Herald Tribune, until 1937, and finally moved to the New York Post, where he ended his column in September 1941.

During its long run, "The Conning Tower" featured contributions from such writers as Robert Benchley, Edna Ferber, Moss Hart, George S. Kaufman, Edna St. Vincent Millay, John O'Hara, Dorothy Parker and Deems Taylor. Having one's work published in "The Conning Tower" was enough to launch a career, as in the case of Dorothy Parker and James Thurber. Parker quipped, "He raised me from a couplet." Parker dedicated her 1936 publication of collected poems, Not So Deep as a Well, to F.P.A. Many of the poems in that collection were originally published in "The Conning Tower".

Much later, the writer E. B. White freely admitted his sense of awe: "I used to walk quickly past the house in West 13th Street between Sixth and Seventh where F.P.A. lived, and the block seemed to tremble under my feet—the way Park Avenue trembles when a train leaves Grand Central."
The irony is that, aside from a few media history majors or American literature majors, who might recognize FBA as a household (college educated household) name today?

I am guessing virtually no-one. But among the people who held him in high esteem and who benefitted from his mentorship? E.B. White, Dorothy Parker certainly would be recognizable and perhaps Woollcott, Ross and Benchley.

Time is a cruel winnower of past reputations.

For all that, FPA's words may be forgotten by most but they have a certain contemporary pertinence.
Elections are won by men and women chiefly because most people vote against somebody rather than for somebody.
Digging a little further, I find that there is an FPA quote I recognize.
There are plenty of good five-cent cigars in the country. The trouble is they cost a quarter. What this country really needs is a good five-cent nickel.
- Reported in Jacob Morton Braude, Complete Speaker's and Toastmaster's Library: Remarks of famous people (1965), p. 53.
Almost certainly from my economic reading rather than from my literary reading.

Tuesday, September 6, 2016

Indeed, What regiment?

From A Literary Education by Joseph Epstein. Page 10.
When a student in the Lionel Trilling story "Of This Time, Of That Place" tells the professor who is the story's protagonist that he used to be an English major, the professor, in the only humorous remark I have discovered in all of Trilling's writing, replies: "Indeed, What regiment?"

Monday, September 5, 2016

Peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of justice

From A Troublesome Inheritance by Nicholas Wade. Page 234.
In the lapidary words of Adam Smith, "Little else is requisite to carry a state to the highest degree of opulence from the lowest barbarism but peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of justice: all the rest being brought about by the natural course of things." But the "little else" is something of an understatement. Peace, easy taxes and justice are seldom found together in history. Only in Europe was this magic formula achieved, and it became the basis for Europe's unexpected ascent in the world.

Sunday, September 4, 2016

I stand between you and the apocalypse

I know the Grey Lady is in her dotage but I find it inexplicable that, as deeply supportive of Hillary Clinton as they are, that they let this reporting through the editorial process.

A couple of weeks ago Trump garnered positive headlines for being the first national politician to bring attention to and visit Louisiana in its storm plight, goading a vacationing Obama to visit first thing after he was back but apparently having no effect on Clinton's priorities (fund raising). In the past week, Trump has been doing serious outreach to Mexico and getting plaudits for his presidential mien. Yesterday he made a major presentation to the Black faith community and, again, has been receiving, albeit sometimes reluctant, plaudits for his efforts and performance.

The New York Times can't help that Clinton spent her day, characteristically, raising money from the rich vested interests of rent seekers, but, while accurate, the contrast between these two opening paragraphs and the Trump machine is startling.

From Where Has Hillary Clinton Been? Ask the Ultrarich by Amy Chozick and Jonathan Martin. This is the same Amy Chozick who a few weeks ago struggled (and failed) to present the Clintons as having been in financially parlous condition early in their marriage, thus explaining, or so went the theory, Hillary Clinton's need for money. I analyzed that reporting in Let The Sun Shine.

Demonstrating the same incapacity to hide the ball as showed in the earlier article, Chozick opens today's reporting with:
At a private fund-raiser Tuesday night at a waterfront Hamptons estate, Hillary Clinton danced alongside Jimmy Buffett, Jon Bon Jovi and Paul McCartney, and joined in a singalong finale to “Hey Jude.”

“I stand between you and the apocalypse,” a confident Mrs. Clinton declared to laughs, exhibiting a flash of self-awareness and humor to a crowd that included Calvin Klein and Harvey Weinstein and for whom the prospect of a Donald J. Trump presidency is dire.
"I stand between you and the apocalypse?" What is this, the French Revolution? All very Marie Antoinette. The echoes of the two women are striking. From that Wikipedia article:
Despite her initial popularity, a growing number of the population eventually came to dislike her, accusing L'Autrichienne, "the Austrian woman" (a nickname given her upon her arrival to France by Louis XV's daughters, Mesdames de France), of being profligate, promiscuous, and of harbouring sympathies for France's enemies, particularly her native Austria. The Diamond Necklace affair damaged her reputation further. During the Revolution, she became known as Madame Déficit because the country's financial crisis was blamed on her lavish spending and her opposition to the social and financial reforms of Turgot and Necker.
Madame Deficit indeed. There is further elaboration of Marie Antoinette's behavior (and its similarities to the current candidate) here, Declining Popularity.

Now that Chozick has put us on the track of perfidious French Royalty, isn't there at least a passing kinship between L'Etat, c'est moi (I am the State) and a certain "What difference at this point, does it make?"

But back to the reporting.
Mr. Trump has pointed to Mrs. Clinton’s noticeably scant schedule of campaign events this summer to suggest she has been hiding from the public. But Mrs. Clinton has been more than accessible to those who reside in some of the country’s most moneyed enclaves and are willing to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to see her. In the last two weeks of August, Mrs. Clinton raked in roughly $50 million at 22 fund-raising events, averaging around $150,000 an hour, according to a New York Times tally.

And while Mrs. Clinton has faced criticism for her failure to hold a news conference for months, she has fielded hundreds of questions from the ultrarich in places like the Hamptons, Martha’s Vineyard, Beverly Hills and Silicon Valley.

“It’s the old adage, you go to where the money is,” said Jay S. Jacobs, a prominent New York Democrat.

Mrs. Clinton raised about $143 million in August, the campaign’s best month yet. At a single event on Tuesday in Sagaponack, N.Y., 10 people paid at least $250,000 to meet her, raising $2.5 million.

If Mr. Trump appears to be waging his campaign in rallies and network interviews, Mrs. Clinton’s second presidential bid seems to amount to a series of high-dollar fund-raisers with public appearances added to the schedule when they can be fit in. Last week, for example, she diverged just once from her packed fund-raising schedule to deliver a speech.
So hobnobbing with the rich and ignoring everyone else is just who she is. Let them eat cake.

With this kind of reporting, either Chozick really doesn't like Hillary Clinton (improbable given her employer), or she is making the very best of the little she has given Clinton's deeply corrupt behavior (quite possible), or perhaps she is playing a very deep game.

If Hillary Clinton is the corrupt, money grubbing, interest favoring, favor dealing, deficit spending, ignorant, clueless Marie Antoinette, then who is Trump? Maybe Chozick is trying to evoke Maximilien Robespierre? But Robespierre had two phases, an early, more noble one where he was advocating for democracy, the poor, equality of rights, suffrage, abolition of slavery, etc. And then there was his second phase as leader of the brutal Committee of Public Safety which played a central role in the Reign of Terror during which some 50,000 people were summarily executed or guillotined.

That seems a little apocalyptic. Godwin's Law only has so much reach.

Perhaps Chozick is being more subtle and casting Trump as the buffoonish, crazy, madman, morally execrable Jean-Jacques Rousseau with his many illegitimate children? Rousseau had a deep influence on the leaders of the Revolution (and progressive totalitarians everywhere) but was kind of a messy monster in his personal life. Perhaps that is the take-away Chozick wishes to invoke.

Possible, but I think a deep game is probably the least likely explanation for this reporting.

The seed of books planted in dry ground

From A Troublesome Inheritance by Nicholas Wade. Page 228.
Islamic rulers long kept challenges away by forbidding the printing press and squelching troublesome lines of inquiry. In Europe, interest in new knowledge was not confined to an elite but pervaded societies in which literacy was becoming widespread. By 1500 there were 1,700 printing presses distributed in 300 European cities in every country except Russia. In the Ottoman empire, a decree of Sultan Selim I specified the death penalty for anyone who even used a printing press. Istanbul did not acquire a printing press until 1726 and the owners were allowed to publish only a few titles before being closed down.

Saturday, September 3, 2016

There are few controlled experiments in history

From A Troublesome Inheritance by Nicholas Wade. Page 215.

I wouldn't invest too much significance into this but it is none-the-less, revealing.
In 1608 Hans Lippershey, a spectacle maker in the Dutch town of Middelburg, invented the telescope. Within a few decades, telescopes had been introduced from Europe to China, to the Mughal empire in India and to the Ottoman empire. All four civilizations were thus on equal footing in terms of possessing this powerful new instrument with its latent power for observing the universe and deducing the laws of planetary motion.

There are few controlled experiments in history, but the historian of science Toby Huff has discovered one in the way that the telescope was received and used in the 17th century. The reactions of the four civilizations to this powerful new instrument bear on the very different kinds of society that each had developed.

In Europe the telescope was turned at once toward the heavens. Galileo, hearing a description of Lippershey's device, immediately set to building telescopes of his own. He was firt to observe the moons of Jupiter, and he used the fact of Jupiter's satellites as empirical evidence in favor of Copernicus's then disputed notion that the planets, including the Earth were satellites of the sun. Galileo's argument that the earth revolved around the sun brought him into conflict with the church's belief that the Earth cannot move. In 1633 he was forced to recant by the Inquisition and placed under house arrest for the rest of his life.

But Europe was not monolithic, and the Inquisition was powerless to suppress the ideas of Copernicus and Galileo in Protestant countries. What Galileo had started was carried forward by Kepler and Newton. The momentum of the Scientific Revolution scarcely faltered.

In the Muslim world, the telescope quickly reached the Mughal empire in India. One was presented in 1616 by the British ambassador to the court of the emperor Jahangir, and many more arrived a year later. The Mughals knew a lot about astronomy, but their interest in it was confined to matters of the calendar. A revised calendar was presented to the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan in 1628, but the scholar who prepared it based it on the Ptolemaic system (which assumes that the sun revolves around an immobile Earth).

Given this extensive familiarity with astronomy, Mughal scholars might have been expected to use the telescope to explore the heavens. But the designers of astronomical instruments in the Mughal empire did not make telescopes, and the scholars created no demand for them. "In the end, no Mughal scholars undertook to use the telescope for astronomical purposes in the seventeenth century," Huff reports.
Wade goes on.
Telescopes had reached Istanbul by at least 1626 and were quickly incorporated into the Ottoman navy. But despite Muslim eminence in optics in the 14th century, scholars in the Ottoman empire showed no particular interest in the telescope.
What about China?
Outside of Europe, the most promising new users of the telescope were in China, whose government had a keen interest in astronomy. Moreover, there was an unusual but vigorous mechanism for pumping the new European astronomical discoveries into China in the form of the Jesuit mission there. The Jesuits figured they had a better chance of converting the Chinese to Christianity if they could show that European astronomy provided more accurate calculations of the celestial events in which the Chinese were interested. Through the Jesuits efforts, the Chinese certainly knew of the telescope by 1626, and the emperor probably received a telescope from Cardinal Borromeo of Milan as early as 1618.

[snip]

The puzzle is that throughout this period the Chinese made no improvements on the telescope. Nor did they show any sustained interest in the ferment of European ideas about the theoretical structure of the universe, despite being plied by the Jesuits with the latest European research. Chinese astronomers had behind them a centuries-old tradition of astronomical observation. But it was embedded in a Chinese cosmological system that they were reluctant to abandon. Their latent xenophobia also supported resistance to new ideas. "It is better to have no good astronomy than to have Westerners in China," wrote the anti-Christian scholar Yang Guangxian.



Friday, September 2, 2016

It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma

Related to the prior post, I came across another accusation that Google search is suppressing search results that are negative for Hillary Clinton. There was a similar report earlier in the summer. The rationale for the accusation is based on the fact that Google is deeply integrated with the current administration (weekly meetings at the White House, extensive exchanges of personnel between Democrats and Google, etc.) and because the Alphabet (holding company of Google) Chairman Eric Schmidt financially supports a pro-Hillary Clinton technology group intended to provide her campaign superior technology enablement.

Did Google Manipulate Search for Hillary? from Source Feed earlier in the summer is probably the most succinct summary I have seen.

The core evidence for the accusation is the difference in autocomplete for each of the three major search engines (Google, Bing, Yahoo). Autocomplete is, in theory, a mechanism for users to find search phrases that are most frequently used by other searchers. For example, if you type in "Today's we" into Google, the autocomplete offerings are:
Today's weather
Today's weather Atlanta (my current location)
Today's weather forecast
You get very similar results from Bing:
Today's weather
Today's weather forecast
Today's weather report
and from Yahoo:
Today's weather
Today's weather in Atlanta
Today's weather hourly
So far so good. Similar inquiry, similar, but not identical results.

But what happens, remembering that Alphabet chairman Schmidt is funding a tech group that is advising Clinton's campaign on all things digital, when you compare different "Hillary Clinton . . ." searches between the different search engines?

As of 8:51am Friday, September 2nd, here are the autocomplete results:
Google . . . cor

Hillary Clinton cory booker
Hillary Clinton corporate donors
Hillary Clinton corporate tax rates

Bing

Hillary Clinton corruption
Hillary Clinton corrupt
Hillary Clinton corruption list

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton corruption
Hillary Clinton corruption scandals
Hillary Clinton corruption list



Google . . . cri

Hillary Clinton cries
Hillary Clinton crisis of character
Hillary Clinton cried after

Bing

Hillary Clinton criminal investigation
Hillary Clinton criminal charges
Hillary Clinton criminal record

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton crimes
Hillary Clinton criminal
Hillary Clinton criminal charges



Google ind . . .

Hillary Clinton india
Hillary Clinton indiana
Hillary Clinton inddictment reddit

Bing

Hillary Clinton indictment coming
Hillary Clinton indictment update
Hillary Clinton indicted


Yahoo

Hillary Clinton indictment
Hillary Clinton indictment coming
Hillary Clinton indictment coming ny times



Google em . . .

Hillary Clinton email fox news
Hillary Clinton email address
Hillary Clinton emoji

Bing

Hillary Clinton emails
Hillary Clinton emails wikileaks
Hillary Clinton emails investigation

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton emails scandal
Hillary Clinton emails
Hillary Clinton emails update



Google ben . . .

Hillary Clinton benghazi
Hillary Clinton benghazi video
Hillary Clinton benghazi movie

Bing

Hillary Clinton benghazi
Hillary Clinton benghazi summary
Hillary Clinton benghazi what happened


Yahoo

Hillary Clinton benghazi cover up
Hillary Clinton benghazi testimony
Hillary Clinton benghazi what does it matter



Google he . . .

Hillary Clinton height
Hillary Clinton healthcare
Hillary Clinton headquarters

Bing

Hillary Clinton health
Hillary Clinton health issues
Hillary Clinton height


Yahoo

Hillary Clinton health issue
Hillary Clinton health
Hillary Clinton health problems



Google li . . .

Hillary Clinton libya
Hillary Clinton live
Hillary Clinton life

Bing

Hillary Clinton lies
Hillary Clinton liar
Hillary Clinton lies and cover ups

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton lies
Hillary Clinton liar
Hillary Clinton lies and scandals



Google br . . .

Hillary Clinton brother
Hillary Clinton brain tumor
Hillary Clinton broad city

Bing

Hillary Clinton brain damage
Hillary Clinton brain tumor
Hillary Clinton briefing

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton brain damage
Hillary Clinton brain tumor
Hillary Clinton brain clot



Google ra . . .

Hillary Clinton rally
Hillary Clinton raise taxes
Hillary Clinton raleigh

Bing

Hillary Clinton racist
Hillary Clinton racist remarks
Hillary Clinton rally schedule

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton raise taxes on middle class
Hillary Clinton rally schedule
Hillary Clinton rape case



Google af . . .

Hillary Clinton age
Hillary Clinton africa
Hillary Clinton afghanistan

Bing

Hillary Clinton affairs
Hillary Clinton affordable care act
Hillary Clinton affairs list

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton affair
Hillary Clinton affair with woman
Hillary Clinton affairs scandals



Google wh . . .

Hillary Clinton what difference does it make
Hillary Clinton whip
Hillary Clinton who wore it better

Bing

Hillary Clinton whitewater
Hillary Clinton what difference does it make
Hillary Clinton white privilege

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton what difference does it make
Hillary Clinton whitewater scandal
Hillary Clinton whhore of babylon



Google tra . . .

Hillary Clinton trade
Hillary Clinton transcript
Hillary Clinton transparent

Bing

Hillary Clinton travel schedule
Hillary Clinton travelgate
Hillary Clinton track record

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton traitor
Hillary Clinton trail of dead bodies
Hillary Clinton travel gate



Google mon . . .

Hillary Clinton monsanto
Hillary Clinton money raised
Hillary Clinton montage

Bing

Hillary Clinton monsanto
Hillary Clinton monsanto ties
Hillary Clinton monica lewinskey

Yahoo

Hillary Clinton money laundering
Hillary Clinton monsanto connection
Hillary Clinton monica lewinskey
What does it all mean? Clearly, there seems to a strong divergence among the search engines with Bing and Yahoo returning basically similar results which are distinctly harsher than those returned for Google. Google returns virtually no results which are harsh to Clinton.

Why? Perhaps, as importantly, How? How might Google be adjusting its search results? I can't imagine that they have some manual intervention. Too time consuming, too expensive, and (with so many people) too likely to be discovered.

Is it possible that Google is using some sort of sensitivity filter? For example, that they are attaching some weighting to affiliative, warm, affirming searches and displaying those, whereas the other two search engines are simply displaying the actual most searched terms? Possible.

To test that, I ran all the above terms with Donald Trump as the subject, i.e. "Donald Trump cor . . . ", etc. I also ran the same test with Mitt Romney. All three search engines returned reasonably close results to one another for each of these names. Bing and Yahoo still had a slightly harsher set of returns than Google, but they are much closer to one another than when searching on Clinton.

So it seems that there isn't a sensitivity filter.

Is it possible that Google, Bing, and Yahoo have dramatically different users and therefore different searches?

This article sheds a little light on that. But not much. Google users are more male and younger than Bing and Yahoo. Not to indulge in too much stereotyping, but I struggle a little with picturing young male Google users having gentler searchers about Hillary Clinton than older female searchers on Bing and Yahoo.

More of Google searchers are international than are Bing's, so possibly that is a moderating influence, assuming that non-US people might have a more positive view of Clinton than those in the US. Possible, but that doesn't seem particularly convincing.

It is possible that there are demographic differences in the users between Google, Bing, and Yahoo but the data available doesn't seem to make a compelling argument that that would be the difference in the autocompletes.

So we are left with an unexplained discrepancy in terms of autocomplete terms.

While autocomplete might skew the results somewhat, one would assume that the biggest difference would be if the different search engines returned materially different search results. That is a trickier analysis, particularly given that most people only check the first ten results. All three engines might return the same results but one might skew the more positive results to the first page whereas the others might simply rank them by relevance. The shading between the two approaches would likely be quite hard to discern without fairly extensive sampling. I did a minimal test of this hypothesis by running three searches on "scandals", "corruption", and "lies".

On "scandals" and "corruption", Bing and Yahoo seemed to be returning results pretty similar to those in Google.

Interestingly though, when I tried "lies", we revert back to the earlier observed profile. Bing and Yahoo had similar results to one another and all the first articles were essentially a listing or an investigation of particular lies. Google, however, had four articles which were efforts to refute reports about Clinton's lies. I.e. the displayed results were clearly far more positive to Clinton than those from Bing and Yahoo.

That's about as far as I can go.

The facts seem to indicate a very strong skew on the part of Google towards downplaying negative news about Clinton in their autocomplete compared to Bing and Yahoo.

On a sample base of three ("scandals", "corruption" and "lies"), it does appear that there are certain search terms that skew favorably towards Clinton in the Google search engine but not in Bing or Yahoo.

As Churchill described Russia, "It is a riddle, wrapped in a mystery, inside an enigma."

A small elite extorts the most it can from a society's productive resources and keeps almost everything for itself

From A Troublesome Inheritance by Nicholas Wade. Page 192.
Surely economists, historians,or other social scientists must have devised some convincing explanation for this substantial and enduring inequality? "Not so," say Acemoglu and Robinson: "Most hypotheses that social scientists have proposed for the origins of poverty and prosperity just don't work and fail to convincingly explain the lay of the land."

Their thesis is that there are bad and good institutions or, as they term them, extractive and inclusive institutions. The bad, extractive institutions are those in which a small elite extorts the most it can from a society's productive resources and keeps almost everything for itself. The elite opposes technological change because it is disruptive of the political and economic order required to maintain their position. Through its own greed, the elite impoverishes everyone else and prevents progress. A permanent vicious circle between the society's extractive political and economic institutions maintains continual stagnation.

Good, inclusive institutions, by contrast, are those in which political and economic power is widely shared. The rule of law and property rights reward endeavor. No sector of society is powerful enough to block economic change. A virtuous circle between politics and economics maintains increasing prosperity.

The archetype of inclusive institutions, in Acemoglu and Robinson's view, was the Glorious Revolution of 1688, in which England replaced its French-Leaning king, James II, with his son-in-law William of Orange, a switch that consolidated Parliaments control over the king. Both political and economic institutions became more inclusive, creating incentives for entrepreneurs and laying the basis for the Industrial Revolution.
Independent of Acemoglu and Robinson's argument, doesn't that summary sound eerily contemporary, not only in the US but in Europe, China, India:
The bad, extractive institutions are those in which a small elite extorts the most it can from a society's productive resources and keeps almost everything for itself.
The difference is the elite don't oppose technological change. Why? Perhaps because the elite now drive technological change because it doesn't threaten position but reinforces it. Who are the biggest defenders of the crony capitalist status quo? Wall Street, Media, the Academy, and Tech. All highly regulated and highly dependent on a raft of dizzying collusions with the centers of power. They use the power of the state to ensure that they are indeed beneficiaries. Hence the revolt of the hoi polloi across the US and Europe.

Thursday, September 1, 2016

The poor have a greater risk of being erased from the gene pool.

From A Troublesome Inheritance by Nicholas Wade. Page 162.
There were relatively few attacks on Clark's proposed mechanism of evolutionary change, the ability of the rich to leave more surviving children who would spread their genes and behavior through the population as some of them descended in social rank.

Clark has since corroborated this mechanism by devising an independent way to check it, based on the prevalence of surnames. Surnames, being passed from father to son, are effectively propagated like the Y chromosome. They track male genes, provided that wives are faithful and no one is adopted, but cases of nonpaternity and adoption were both rare in medieval England. Clark chose two sets of rare surnames, such as Banbricke, Cheveny, Reddyforde, Spatchet, and TOkelove, from English records of 1560-1640. One set belonged to men rich enough to leave a will, the other to people indicted in Essex courts for burglary, poaching and crimes of violence, and therefore assumed to be among the poorest.

For rare surnames, a large fraction of the holders will typically be related. Clark found that his rich families survived through the generations much better than the poor ones. By 1851, only 8% of the richest surnames from the 1560-1640 period had disappeared, but 21% of the indicted surnames no longer existed. The poor have a greater risk of being erased from the gene pool.

[snip]

"The surname evidence confirms a permanent selection in pre-industrial England for genes of the economically successful, and against the genes of the poor and the criminal," Clark concludes. "Their extra reproductive success had a permanent impact on the genetic composition of later population."