Tuesday, August 23, 2016

Your brothers in Syria have no dwelling place save the saddles of camels and the bellies of the vultures? Blood has been spilled!

A friend directed me to the Los Altos Friends of the Library Book Sale this past weekend. A pleasant discovery. Nearly fifty books found a home.

One of the many is The Crusades through Arab Eyes by Amin Maalouf. I have a number of books of this ilk but this one is, so far, the most engaging and compelling.

The book was first published in 1984, 32 years before the current events of the Middle East. None-the-less, the prologue of events in August 1099 sound as if they could be describing Syria in 2016. In keeping with the Arab centric perspective, the Franj below are who we would know as the Franks out of France and Germany.
Baghdad, August 1099.

Wearing no turban, his head shaved as a sign of mourning, the venerable qadi Abu Sa'ad al-Harawi burst with a loud cry into the spacious diwan of the caliph al-Mustazhir Billah, a throng of companions, young and old, trailing in his wake. Noisily assenting to his every word, they, like him, offered the chilling spectacle of long beards and shaven heads. A few of the court dignitaries tried to calm him, but al-Hawari swept them aside with disdain, strode resolutely to the center of the hall, and then, with the searing eloquence of a seasoned preacher, al-Hawari proceeded to lecture to all those present, without regard to rank.

“How dare you slumber in the shade of complacent safety, leading lives as frivolous as garden flowers, while your brothers in Syria have no dwelling place save the saddles of camels and the bellies of the vultures? Blood has been spilled! Beautiful young girls have been shamed, and must now hide their sweet faces in their hands! Shall the valorous Arabs resign themselves to insult, and the valiant Persians accept dishonor?”

“It was a speech that brought tears to many an eye and moved men’s hearts,” the Arab chroniclers later wrote. The entire audience broke out in wails and lamentations, but al-Harawi had not come to elicit sobs.

“Men’s meanest weapon,” he shouted,”is to shed tears when rapiers stir the coals of war.”

If he had made this difficult trip from Damascus to Baghdad, through three long summer weeks under the merciless sun of the Syrian desert, it was not to plead for pity but to alert Islam’s highest authority about the calamity that had just befallen the faithful, and to urge them to intervene without delay and halt the bloodshed. “Never have the Muslims been so humiliated,” al-Hawari repeated, “never have their lands been so savagely devastated.” All the people traveling with him had fled from towns sacked by the invaders, amongthe people were a few survivors of Jerusalem. He had brought them along so that they could relate, in their own words, the tragedy they had suffered just one month earlier.

The Franj had taken the holy city on Friday, the twenty-second day of the month of Cha'ban, in the year of the Hegira 492, or 15 July 1099, after a forty day siege. The exiles still trembled when they spoke of the fall of the city: they stared into space as though they could still see the fair-haired and heavily armoured warriors spilling through the streets, swords in hand, slaughtering men, women, and children, plundering houses, sacking mosques.

Two days later, when the killing stopped, not a single Muslim was left alive within the city walls. Some had taken advantage of the chaos to slip away, escaping through gates battered down by the attackers. Thousands of others lay in pools of blood on the doorsteps of their homes or alongside the mosques. Among them were many imams, ulama and Sufi ascetics who had forsaken their countries of origin for a life of pious retreat in these holy places. The last survivors were forced to perform the wort tasks: to heave the bodies of their own relatives, to dump them in vacant, unmarked lots, and then to set them alight, before being themselves massacred or sold into slavery.

The fate of the Jews of Jerusalem was no less atrocious. During the first hours of battle, some participated in the defense of their quarter, situated on the northern edge of the city. But when, in that part of the city, the walls overhanging their homes collapsed and the blond knights began to pour through the streets, the Jews panicked. Re-enacting an immemorial rite, the entire community gathered in the main synagogue to pray. The Franj barricaded all the exits and stacked bundles of wood in a ring around the building. The temple was then put to the torch. Those who managed to escape were massacred in the neighboring alleyways. The rest were burned alive.”
I am both fascinated and repulsed by the history of the Middle East and the Crusades in particular. You want to find some redeeming aspect to the great conflict but all there is is the ebb and flow of bloodshed and cruelty from the conquest of Greco-Christian Middle East by barbarous Islamic Arabs out of the desert in the 700s to the attempted reconquest by the similarly barbaric Franj in the 1000s.

Maalouf does a great job of laying out the constant, bitter, titanic struggles between and among four great cultures (Greek, Persian, Arab, and Turk) along with the more minor players (Kurds, Armenians, Jews, etc.). A region in constant strife for more than a thousand years.

Monday, August 22, 2016

And I shall have some peace there, for peace comes dropping slow

The Lake Isle of Innisfree
by W. B. Yeats

I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree,
And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made:
Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee;
And live alone in the bee-loud glade.

And I shall have some peace there, for peace comes dropping slow,
Dropping from the veils of the morning to where the cricket sings;
There midnight’s all a glimmer, and noon a purple glow,
And evening full of the linnet’s wings.

I will arise and go now, for always night and day
I hear lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore;
While I stand on the roadway, or on the pavements grey,
I hear it in the deep heart’s core.

High risk discount factors

This is interesting throughout. Insider Trading Isn’t What You See in the Movies by Tyler Cowen. Insider trading:
Kenneth R. Ahern, a professor at the University of Southern California's Marshall School of Business, examined hundreds of Department of Justice and the Securities and Exchange Commission cases from 2009 to 2013, with an associated 5,423 pages of documentation. What emerged was some fascinating detail on the crime and its practitioners (both alleged and convicted).
Looks robust.

Stereotypes are confirmed.
Some aspects come pretty close to what we see in the movies. The average insider trader is 43 years old, and nine out of 10 are male.
Particularly personality stereotypes:
The practice also seems correlated with some features of recklessness: Insider traders are younger than their associates, less likely to own real estate, and have fewer family members on average. More than half have criminal records, with almost all charges stemming from traffic violations.
Insider trading is ultimately a trust-based social activity.
Of the known pairs of people who provide and act upon private information ("tipper and tippee"), 64 percent met before college, and 16 percent met in college or graduate school. Another 23 percent are family relations -- more siblings and parents than aunts and uncles, despite the added capital that the latter might have provided. Tips are also commonly shared among people with ethnically similar surnames: Of 24 tips coming from people with Celtic surnames, for example, 14 went to individuals who also had Celtic surnames.
Next set of findings mirrors what I have noticed over the years about commercial and governmental corruption - it is often over small stakes. I don't intend to diminish the magnitude of a $10,000 bribe but when it is in the context of a lifetime's earnings and even in the context of annual salary which is often on the order of $75,000 - $150,000, that is chump change. Why would you put an income of $150,000 at risk over what might be a family week at the beach in Hawaii say?

I see it all the time in the local paper, and $10,000 tends to be on the high end. School principals sacked for dipping into an account for $2,000 over the years, a city councilman indicted for a $6,500 payoff to sway a contract decision, etc.

The insider trading study reveals a similar dynamic, people already greatly compensated in the national scheme of things but undertaking criminal activity to achieve just that little bit more.
The tight circle of trust -- and the associated lack of capital -- appears to limit perpetrators' ability to take full advantage of a highly profitable activity. Returns averaged about 35 percent, realized over an average holding period of 21 days. Yet despite the nearly certain gains available, the median insider trader invested only about $200,000 per tip and received $136,000 in profit. That's hardly enough to retire on. Granted, the much higher average profit of $2.3 million indicates that some investors hit it big -- and maybe the smartest, wealthiest and best-connected insider traders aren’t included in the data because they don’t get caught.

The insider traders in the sample are hardly rich. The median value of their homes is $656,300, not a lot given that they tend to live in relatively expensive metropolitan areas. Arguably many of them are upwardly mobile enough to have seen real wealth, without quite yet having it themselves.

The average source waits about 12 days between receiving valuable information and providing a tip. This could reflect either indecision about breaking the law or the difficulty of finding a trustworthy tippee. Nearly half, though, pass on the information the same day they receive it, suggesting that a significant group has greater experience and preparation. Repeat offending is also common: The average source gives 2.36 tips, and those who both give and receive tips do even more.
Part of the explanation is likely that only the smaller fry get caught and prosecuted. The bigger fish work out deals which keep their numbers out of the court system. Still, the same dynamic of huge risks to secure relatively small improvements.

Is it simply just a symptom of insiderdom such as we currently see in politics where individuals with long standing in the public eye still pursue grubby increments of money for favorable trade decisions, speeches, exemptions from the rules that apply to everyone else?

I don't know but I wish we knew enough to stamp out the criminal behavior.

Sunday, August 21, 2016

Xenonophon, precursor of Adam Smith

Via a passing reference in Marginal Revolution I get to a Wikipedia article on who first described the principle of the division of labor leading to improved efficiency and effectiveness. It is close run between Plato and Xenophon though my money is on Xenophon as being the more explicit. From Wikipedia.
Plato

In Plato's Republic, the origin of the state lies in the natural inequality of humanity, which is embodied in the division of labour.
Well then, how will our state supply these needs? It will need a farmer, a builder, and a weaver, and also, I think, a shoemaker and one or two others to provide for our bodily needs. So that the minimum state would consist of four or five men.... (The Republic, p. 103, Penguin Classics edition.)
Silvermintz notes that, "Historians of economic thought credit Plato, primarily on account of arguments advanced in his Republic, as an early proponent of the division of labour." Notwithstanding this, Silvermintz argues that, "While Plato recognizes both the economic and political benefits of the division of labour, he ultimately critiques this form of economic arrangement insofar as it hinders the individual from ordering his own soul by cultivating acquisitive motives over prudence and reason."

Xenophon

Xenophon, in the fourth century BC, makes a passing reference to division of labour in his 'Cyropaedia' (a.k.a. Education of Cyrus).
Just as the various trades are most highly developed in large cities, in the same way food at the palace is prepared in a far superior manner. In small towns the same man makes couches, doors, ploughs and tables, and often he even builds houses, and still he is thankful if only he can find enough work to support himself. And it is impossible for a man of many trades to do all of them well. In large cities, however, because many make demands on each trade, one alone is enough to support a man, and often less than one: for instance one man makes shoes for men, another for women, there are places even where one man earns a living just by mending shoes, another by cutting them out, another just by sewing the uppers together, while there is another who performs none of these operations but assembles the parts, Of necessity, he who pursues a very specialised task will do it best.
Xenonophon, precursor of Adam Smith.

Every military working dog is an NCO

From Military Working Dogs: Guardians of the Night by Linda Crippen.
Every military working dog is an NCO - in tradition at least. Some say the custom was to prevent handlers from mistreating their dogs; hence, a dog is always one rank higher than its handler.

"That's out of respect," said Sgt. 1st Class Regina Johnson, operations superintendent at the Military Working Dog School. "I see it all the time, especially in these young handlers. They make the mistake of thinking they're actually in charge. You've got to tell them, 'Hold up. That dog has trained 100 students. That dog is trying to tell you something.' I think the tradition grew out of a few handlers recognizing the dog as their partner."

Johnson said some "non-dog people" get offended when animals receive honors normally reserved for humans, but the tradition seems to be growing stronger. A quick search on the Army website will yield several recent stories about military working dogs receiving promotions, medals and funeral ceremonies with military honors.

The fact is these dogs and handlers save lives. "The more we're out there with the combat commanders, they see. They see that the dog just saved their Soldiers' lives. That dog just saved that entire platoon," Johnson emphasized.

Forget the village - it's the family that raises the child

From Family, Community and Long-Term Earnings Inequality by Paul Bingley, Lorenzo Cappellari, and Konstantinos Tatsiramos

From the introduction:
That the environment in which persons grow up and live in the early stages of their life is an important determinant of lifetime socioeconomic outcomes has been well established in the recent economic literature. Francesconi and Heckman (2016) report that at least 50% of the variability of lifetime earnings across persons is due to differences in attributes determined by age 18. Family and community background, which includes the neighborhood where children grow up and the school they attend, are considered important attributes determining later outcomes (e.g. Page and Solon, 2003; Raaum, Sørensen and Salvanes, 2006; Chetty and Hendren, 2015). Families can determine earnings by transmitting abilities, preference and resources, while communities can influence earnings through neighborhood quality, school quality and peers.

In this paper, we study the relative influence of family, schools and neighborhoods on earnings inequality over the life cycle. While there is a large and growing body of evidence on the influence of each of these attributes on adult outcomes, very little is known about their relative influence on earnings and how it evolves over the life cycle. Understanding the relative magnitude of these initial conditions on earnings throughout the life cycle is important for identifying the driving forces of existing inequalities and for interventions that aim to reduce them, especially because some early influences may be longer lasting than others.
Much of the research here in Thingfinder supports the proposition that Family is by far the strongest forecasting variable over school and neighborhoods for future outcomes. Schooling and neighborhoods have influence, but at the margin.

And that is what the researchers found.
This research design shows that, within the environment individuals grow up and live, family is the most important factor in accounting for the inequality of permanent earnings over the life cycle. Neighborhoods and schools influence earnings only early in the working life in an almost equal way, but this influence falls rapidly and becomes negligible after age 30. This implies that, when earnings can only be observed while relatively young, the influence of community on long run earnings inequality is overstated.

Our findings are based on data from Denmark, which, because of its welfare system, is typically considered to promote equality of opportunity. However, as highlighted recently by Landersø and Heckman (2016), there is much less educational mobility than income mobility in Denmark. Low private financial returns to schooling fail to incentivize educational investments among the children of less educated parents. This is consistent with our finding that family is the most important determinant of long run earnings similarities across siblings. Communities seem to affect earnings early in the working life, for example through peers influencing educational choices or youth behaviors, but these influences determine only short term deviations from an earnings profile that – apart from idiosyncratic abilities – mainly reflects characteristics and choices of the family. As administrative datasets and cohort studies mature in other countries, our approach could be applied to measure family and community effects on long run outcomes in other contexts.

Saturday, August 20, 2016

We will sail pathless and wild seas

I like this line from Walt Whitman's Song of the Open Road
We will sail pathless and wild seas,
We will go where winds blow, waves dash, and the Yankee clipper speeds by under full sail.
It is a refreshing dose of the American Spirit. In recent years, there has been too much Gramscian focus on victims and victimhood, identity, and the ills of the past and who is guilty and who is privileged. All very Frankfurt School reformed marxism.

I wish we had leaders who spoke more to the fundamental optimism, tolerance, goodwill, and sense of exploration, challenge and adventure which is so much more the cultural DNA of America than the mimsying of the borogoves which gets the attention.

More from the opening stanzas of the poem:
Afoot and light-hearted I take to the open road,
Healthy, free, the world before me,
The long brown path before me leading wherever I choose.

Henceforth I ask not good-fortune, I myself am good-fortune,
Henceforth I whimper no more, postpone no more, need nothing,
Done with indoor complaints, libraries, querulous criticisms,
Strong and content I travel the open road.

The earth, that is sufficient,
I do not want the constellations any nearer,
I know they are very well where they are,
I know they suffice for those who belong to them.

IQ Privilege

I have little doubt that this is true but it is also incredibly sad. From The association between intelligence and personal victimization in adolescence and adulthood by Kevin M. Beaver, et al. From the abstract:
Intelligence has been linked to antisocial, violent, and criminal behaviors. Surprisingly, however, there is a lack of research examining whether intelligence differentially affects the risk for personal victimization. The current study addresses this gap in the literature by examining whether adolescent levels of verbal intelligence are related to the odds of personal victimization in adolescence and adulthood. This study analyzed data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health (Add Health). The results revealed a statistically significant and consistent association between intelligence and victimization. Persons with lower intelligence were more likely to report being victimized even after controlling for the effects of violent criminal behavior. Future research would benefit by examining more closely the association between IQ score and the risk for victimization over the life course.
This isn't a minor effect size either. Those in the top quartile of IQ have only 60% of the victimization (assault, armed robbery, etc.) rate of those in the bottom quartile.

Friday, August 19, 2016

Supply and Demand are powerful masters

No insult intended to Max Roster but this is not startling to economists.



In fact, that is the basis, in part, to the Simon-Ehrlich Wager which Julian Simon won. From Wikipedia. Citations and notes removed.
Simon challenged Paul R. Ehrlich to a wager in 1980 over the price of metals a decade later; Simon had been challenging environmental scientists to the bet for some time.[citation needed] Ehrlich, John Harte, and John Holdren selected a basket of five metals that they thought would rise in price with increasing scarcity and depletion.[citation needed] Simon won the bet, with all five metals dropping in price.

Supporters of Ehrlich's position suggest that much of this price drop came because of an oil spike driving prices up in 1980 and a recession driving prices down in 1990, pointing out that the price of the basket of metals actually rose from 1950 to 1975.[citation needed] They also suggest that Ehrlich did not consider the prices of these metals to be critical indicators, and that Ehrlich took the bet with great reluctance.[citation needed] On the other hand, Ehrlich selected the metals to be used himself, and at the time of the bet called it an "astonishing offer" that he was accepting "before other greedy people jump in."

The total supply in three of these metals (chromium, copper and nickel) increased during this time. Prices also declined for reasons specific to each of the five:
The price of tin went down because of an increased use of aluminium, a much more abundant, useful and inexpensive material.

Better mining technologies allowed for the discovery of vast nickel lodes, which ended the near monopoly that was enjoyed on the market.

Tungsten fell due to the rise of the use of ceramics in cookware.

The price of chromium fell due to better smelting techniques.

The price of copper began to fall due to the invention of fiber optic cable (which is derived from sand), which serves a number of the functions once reserved only for copper wire.
In all of these cases, better technology allowed for either more efficient use of existing resources, or substitution with a more abundant and less expensive resource, as Simon predicted, until 2011.

Thursday, August 18, 2016

Environmentalism versus climate change advocacy

From Are Conservationists Worrying Too Much About Climate Change? by Michelle Nijhuis.

At last, a possible signal towards a reasonable sign that the long nightmarish fever of Anthropogenic Global Warming might be about to break.
In January of this year, James Watson, an Australian scientist who works for the Wildlife Conservation Society, noticed an image that had been tweeted by a friend of his, a physician in Sydney. With a chain of progressively larger circles, it illustrated the relative frequency of causes of death among Australians, from the vanishingly rare (war, pregnancy and birth, murder) to the extremely common (respiratory disorders, cancer, heart disease). It was a simple but striking depiction of comparative risk. “I thought, ‘Why hasn’t anyone done something like this for the rest of nature?’ ” Watson recalled.

The answer was that, until recently, nobody had the data. While many scientists have studied the vulnerability of individual species or groups of organisms (corals, say, or birds) to extinction, only in 2010 did ecologists, conservationists, taxonomists, and naturalists begin to more comprehensively assess the threats posed to species of all kinds—an effort to assemble what the biologist E. O. Wilson has called a “barometer of life.”

Over four months this spring, Watson and Sean Maxwell, a doctoral student at the University of Queensland, used the new data to identify and rank the existential threats to nearly nine thousand species, ranging from otters to lilies. In a commentary published today in the journal Nature, they report that almost three-quarters of the species they studied are threatened by overexploitation—human activities such as logging, fishing, and hunting. More than sixty per cent are threatened by the conversion of habitat to farmland and timber plantations. (Many species face multiple threats.) Less than twenty per cent, however, are currently endangered by the many effects of climate change—drought, extreme temperatures, severe storms, and flooding.

Like other conservationists, Watson and Maxwell were already well aware that poaching and agriculture posed serious threats to many species. But even they were surprised by how dramatically the effects outstripped those of climate change. Much like the causes of human death, the current causes of species loss appear to be inversely proportional to the media attention—and, to some extent, the research and funding attention—they receive.
This is the point that Bjorn Lomborg was making way back in 2001 with The Skeptical Environmentalist. Focus on the science and you get different answers than if you focus on the politics.

AGW has always been a political issue. Born out of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and its first report in 1990, AGW has been the fulcrum to transfer resources from rich countries to poorer countries. The science was always much more tentative and subjective than allowed. It has, in the intervening years become a global football kicked all around the pitch with no goals ever being scored.

AGW had many bad consequences, few of them to do with the climate. AGW became the fire that sucked all the oxygen out of the environmental room. Many real environmentalists signed up as AGW foot soldiers, never realizing they were being manipulated. Science was another victim of AGW. Politicians being politicians, the AGW controversy became mired in lies and deceptions. Duly hedged forecasts by well intentioned scientists became statements of certainty in the mouths of social justice politicians.

Lomborg, a genuine environmentalists, was one of the first to see the bad outcomes of hijacking science for hubristic ideology. He argued that all environmental decisions needed to be evidence-based and that there were simply too many unknowns about climate forecasting to make the kind of decisions required.

Nobody argues that climate change is not happening. What is debated is how much change, in what direction, by what mechanisms, and to what degree human activities may be causing change or could prevent it. We really do not understand the great complexity of climate to any sufficient degree to make reliable forecasts as evidenced by the failure of the early forecasts to match the reality of actual temperatures.

Lomborg argued (or at least my paraphrase of him) that we live in a world of limits, including budgets. If we are going to spend $1,000 dollars on the environment, then the overwhelming majority ought to be spent on activities with a real world impact such as improved farming practices, better water management, environment and species conservation, etc. Yes, we should spend some few dollars on research and some part of that should be on understanding the climate, but until some point in the future, we simply do not understood enough about climate effects to even know whether a given action will be net positive or detrimental in consequence.

Nijhuis's is the first mainstream reporter I have seen in a long time to not automatically genuflect to the alter of AGW and actually report on real scientific efforts. Kudos.
Less than twenty per cent, however, are currently endangered by the many effects of climate change—drought, extreme temperatures, severe storms, and flooding.
Even that is likely an overstatement. Without humans, the climate is always changing with consequent deleterious effects on species and environments. It is not enough to know what percentage of species are threatened by drought, temperatures, severe storms and flooding. We have to know what percentage of those would not have happened anyway. In the human scale of things, probably virtually none, i.e. most of climate change is driven by existing phenomenon such as solar activity and other such independent variables not controlled by humans.

What is easy to lose is the real consequence of focusing for twenty years on climate change instead of more practical environmental concerns. Environmental advocacy has certainly continued but I am convinced that much energy and effectiveness has been lost owing to the diversion of attention to AGW.

I hope Nijhuis's report is the first of many to bring attention back to the environment and saving ecologies and species.