Wednesday, August 3, 2016

About me as a particular person there was an undeniable, comprehensive lack of concern.

I recently finished In Pharaoh's Army: Memories of the Lost War by Tobias Wolff. I liked it more than his This Boy's Life and it is a decent war memoir but not among my favorites.

As soon as he arrives in-country and before he has been dispatched to his station, his camp comes under fire. On the disorientation.
You know that an attack is "just a probe" only after it's over.
He says about this attack something that seems a leitmotif of most Vietnam memoirs.
No one came to tell us what was going on. We hadn't received our issue of combat gear, so we had no weapons or ammunition, no flack jackets, not even a steel helmet. We were helpless. And nobody knew or cared. They had forgotten about us - more to the point, forgotten about me. In this whole place not one person was thinking of me, thinking, Christ, I better take a run over there and see how Lieutenant Wolff is doing! No. I wasn't on anybody's mind. And I understood this was true not only here but in every square inch of this country. Not one person out there cared whether I lived or died. Maybe some tender hearts cared in the abstract, but it was my fate to be a particular person, and about me as a particular person there was an undeniable, comprehensive lack of concern.

Prejudice for me but not for thee

This is consistent with other research I have seen but is notable by having a somewhat more robust sample size than normal (n=5,914). Cognitive ability varies, but prejudice is universal by Society for Personality and Social Psychology.
Analyzing the results, the researchers found that people with both relatively higher and lower levels of cognitive ability show approximately equal levels of intergroup bias, but towards different sets of groups. People with low cognitive ability tended to express prejudice towards groups perceived as liberal and unconventional (e.g., atheists, gays and lesbians), as well as groups of people perceived as having low choice over group membership (e.g., ethnic minorities). People with high cognitive ability showed the reverse pattern. They tended to express prejudice towards groups perceived as conservative and conventional (e.g., Christians, the military, big business).

“There are a variety of belief systems and personality traits that people often think protect them from expressing prejudice,” says Brandt. “In our prior work we found that people high and low in the personality trait of openness to experience show very consistent links between seeing a group as ‘different from us’ and expressing prejudice towards that group. The same appears to be true for cognitive ability.”
The inclination to target out-groups with prejudicial thinking is equally prevalent among low and high cognitive populations, the only difference being that they are directed towards different groups.

Well, not the only difference. The cognitive elite, by dominating power centers, media and academia, are able to normalize their prejudices in a fashion not available to the lower cognitive groups. The cognitive elite have easily normalized directing their scorn at those whom they stereotype as ignorant, bitter, gun clingers, overly zealous in their religion, harboring antipathy towards immigrants and those who are not like them. That is the high cognitive prejudice and they carry it lightly. Among the non-elite, opinions that are just as prejudicial are deemed unacceptable and out-of-bounds by the elite.

You can see this at work in this very research. Prejudice against minorities is usually directed at perceived patterns of behavior within those minority groups, not necessarily the ethnicity per se. Respondents often draw a distinction, when given the chance, to distinguish between good and bad minority groups based on stereotypes of behavior ("good" Nigerians, for example, versus "bad" Somalis). The carrying of prejudice is the offensive sin, not the validity or the merits of the target. But instead of acknowledging that the prejudice is towards those who demonstrate patterns of behavior different from the reference group, look at how the researchers (presumably high cognitives) choose to characterize low cognitive prejudices as directed towards ethnic minorities when in fact it is reasonably well documented that the prejudices are towards those with different behavior patterns. High cognitives want to believe that lower cognitives are racist and that is exactly how the higher cognitives of this research have expressed that acceptable prejudice of theirs without even batting an eye.

The prejudice is just as strong and just as obnoxious, but the elite suckle their prejudice while ostracizing everyone else's.

Using Google Search Results as a forecasting tool

OK, I think this popped on twitter. Donald, You Ignorant Slut by Joe Bob Briggs.

It is a reasonably well written, though long, restatement of the objective observation that the media leans far left of the public and that that leaning, whether intentionally or not, shapes both what news is covered and how it is covered. Briggs has a spirited writing style intended to assuage the offended and offend the assuaged. He starts with:
NEW YORK—All over America IKEA futons are groaning with the restless insomnia of journalists—tossing, turning, cursing the impotence of their melatonin capsules—burdened with the future of the Republic. Long nights of torment, and then . . .

Morning resolve! Before they’ve even microwaved their second Jimmy Dean Sausage Sandwich, they know that this will be the day of reckoning. They will fire up the Kia Sedona and take the long way to work, giving them more time to think about the epic 1,500 words that will make the difference between chaos and civilization.

Yes, they tell their wives, It’s time for my “Donald Trump is a Dickwad” column.

Let me make it clear here that I’m not talking about lesbian-rights vegans who organize fair-trade coffee boycotts at Maxwell House and agitate for medical marijuana in The Nation. Nor am I thinking of tweed-jacketed professors of sociology at Montana State submitting articles to the Journal of Spanish-American Diacritical Marks. Think-tank analysts at the Institute for Pan-Arab Non-Alignment are most certainly churning out white papers on why Donald Trump is a dangerous threat to the Maghreb treaty on fish hatcheries, but I’m not discussing them either. I’m not talking about intellectuals or activists or experts.

No. I’m talking about the guy who enrolled at McNeese State in the nineties and fell into deep reverence for Professor Rusty Naugahyde, the legendary teacher whose Newswriting 312 workshop was almost as inspirational as Lou “The News Is Sacred” Grant on The Mary Tyler Moore Show. Our starry-eyed undergraduate buys a safari jacket, takes an oath of objectivity and resolves never to be a member of a political party. After that it takes years of struggle to become the lead Metro columnist at the Lotus Tree, Kansas, Daily Arapaho, days spent chronicling the brutal fights over county bond issues needed to repair the Lost Frenchman Bridge. But now that he’s a 32nd-degree Mason and chairman of the Little League committee on maintenance and parking, he knows that it’s his responsibility, and his privilege, to tell the people of Lotus Tree that Donald Trump is a narcissistic disagreeable soulless callous rude arrogant authoritarian vicious egotistical vulgar braggart and megalomaniac, possibly a lunatic, definitely a psychopath, perhaps a fascist.

This goes against everything in the journalism rule book. Elections are the ultimate on-the-one-hand, on-the-other hand story. You get the League of Women Voters to interview each candidate and then you make sure every biography is exactly the same length as the one before it and the one after it. You never say that one campaign platform is better or worse than another campaign platform. You occasionally note “controversy” over “remarks perceived to be off color,” but you limit your commentary to observations like, “It now appears that Beaver County Sheriff Judd will bring his traditional voting bloc to the side of Culpepper, while District Judge Monahan will side with the Democratic challenger.” The last thing you ever do is suggest, much less state, that someone is a pathological liar, because there’s a strong likelihood that more than 50 percent of the people you write about in the course of a lifetime will be, in fact, pathological liars.
All this is the set-up to Briggs real question and topic:
What is it about Donald Trump that makes journalists go insane?
A fair question.

In addition to his energetic and colorful writing, though, Briggs throws down some data. It isn't especially scientific or rigorous. But we already have reasonably robust academic research supporting his main contentions. Briggs instead proffers much more common sense data that is very easy to engage with and which his readers are likely to easily replicate. Number of Google Results. What is the Google Search Results count when you pair "Donald Trump" with a range of insults such as "insane."

He googles a large number of insulting and vituperative insults heaped on Donald Trump by journalists. The numbers are very large in terms of results. He starts out with a list of forty:
puerile 85,000 (not a popular term in the Midwest)
boorish 115,000
soulless 240,000
patronizing 248,000
egotistical 253,000
megalomaniac 261,000 (this one would score higher if it were not six syllables, therefore rendering it unusable in headlines)
vengeful 304,000
callous 395,000
grandiose 406,000
combative 407,000
birther 425,000
condescending 452,000 (could be combined with patronizing for a higher score)
mean-spirited 453,000
misogynistic 479,000 (misleadingly low because “woman hater” gets over a million)
foul-mouthed 500,000
disagreeable 503,000
arrogant 509,000
lunatic 524,000
immature 525,000 (should probably be combined with puerile)
xenophobic 532,000
fascist 554,000
authoritarian 571,000
braggart 586,000
obnoxious 606,000
narcissistic 635,000
boring 643,000 (wow, this one really shouldn’t make it past the fact-checkers)
haughty 645,000
obsessive 707,000
superficial 713,000
psychopathic 784,000
thin-skinned 785,000
vulgar 967,000
It's an interesting approach but not particularly meaningful on its own. First, you need to compare these numbers with the associated count for Hillary Clinton. For example, here are the results for both of them on the first few insults.
puerile - DT 85,000; HC 113,000
boorish - DT 115,000; HC 81,000
soulless - DT 240,000; HC 184,000
patronizing - DT 248,000; HC 233,000
egotistical - DT 253,000; HC 152,000
I did this for a dozen or so and generally, they are within 30% of each other. I am not sure why Clinton would be seen as more puerile than Trump, but thems the numbers. It makes much sense, at least to me.

Briggs settles on eight terms with the biggest numbers
bully 1.4 million
self-obsessed 2.5 million
vicious 9.1 million
rude 13.3 million
cruel 13.3 million
liar 16.2 million
angry 19.3 million
And the winner—drum roll, please:
idiot 20.5 million
OK, let's do the same thing again, this time with Hillary Clinton's numbers
bully - DT 824,000; HC 720,000
self-obsessed - DT 330,000; HC 320,000
vicious - DT 573,000; HC 566,000
rude - DT 808,000; HC 843,000
cruel - DT 823,000; HC 815,000
liar - DT 11.1 million; HC 10 million
angry - DT 46.1 million; HC 34.6 million
idiot - DT 22.8 million; HC 1.1 million
People seem to think that Trump is much more of an idiot than Clinton but, interestingly, that Clinton is much angrier than Trump.

All very interesting, but Briggs' original contention is that the mainstream media journalists are far more insulting of Trump than Clinton. General search will capture all sorts of blogs and other non-MSM materials. Fortunately you can Google search just the News. Here are the respective numbers for just the media.
bully - DT 299,000; HC 640,000
self-obsessed - DT 5,750; HC 3,750
vicious - DT 320,000; HC 180,000
rude - DT 486,000; HC 421,000
cruel - DT 543,000; HC 497,000
liar - DT 347,000; HC 262,000
angry - DT 3.4 million; HC 855,000
idiot - DT 272,000; HC 184,000
There's a lot of very interesting things going on with these numbers but it is hard to see an overarching pattern.

In general searches, Trump draws 70% more insults than does Clinton. Among journalists, however, he draws 86% more insults than does Clinton, supporting Briggs' contention that journalists hate Trump, perhaps not insanely, but at least more than the public at large.

The score for journalists associating Clinton with bullying is 89% of that of the public, i.e. the public and the MSM seem to see pretty eye-to-eye on that charge. There is a wide divergence between the public and the journalists on most of the Trump items. The closest similarity is on the charge of cruelty, journalist see Trump at 66% of the rate as do the public.

My inclination is that there is not much that can be concluded from these numbers - it is too crude a test. However, the overall results seem to conform with both Briggs argument and the academic research as well, the media views Republicans with a more jaundiced eye than do the public.

I did one more final test. Brigg looked at negative charges. What about positive attributes? Here are the results for the at large searches:
Kind - DT 90.5 million; HC 252 million
Strong - DT 75.9 million; HC 65.9 million
Generous - DT 1.5 million; HC 703,000
Honest _ DT 25.8 million; HC 23.9 million
Leader - DT 85.1 million; HC 72.3 million
Trustworthy - DT 502,000; HC 541,000
And for the mainstream media:
Kind - DT 12.4 million; HC 60.4 million
Strong - DT 9.5 million; HC 8.7 million
Generous - DT 501,000; HC 304,000
Honest _ DT 816,000; HC 710,000
Leader - DT 16.1 million; HC 9.3 million
Trustworthy - DT 39,300; HC 60,500
Well that's an interesting alternative perspective. The general public sees Trump as stronger, more generous, more honest, more of a leader than Clinton. And in all those instances, the mainstream media agrees with them. Clinton is seen as kinder and more trustworthy than is Trump, and again, the media agrees.

If the election hinges on negative attributes, Trump attracts more opprobrium and Clinton will take it. If the election hinges on positive attributes, Trump will take it.

If you believe that Google Search Results is a reliable forecasting proxy. Which I don't.

Tuesday, August 2, 2016

I'm alright Jack but the rest of the country is going to hell in a handbasket

This is an interesting contrast. I actually have been aware of the disconnect in the past but hadn't thought about it in a long while. I wonder if anyone has done any research on the apparent contradiction between the levels of personal satisfaction with the way things are going in the respondents lives and the level of perceived satisfaction with the way things are going in the United States at this time.

Are you satisfied with the way things are going in your personal life at this time (Gallup January 2016).


As you can see, pretty steady in the long haul. In recent times, satisfaction was about five percentage percentage points in the Bush years and a big dip during the Great Recession and tepid recovery under Obama, but back up to 85% in January 2016.

85% with the way things are going for them is not too bad.

Now what about how citizens see things going for the nation as a whole? Are you satisfied with the way things are going in the United States at this time (Gallup July 2016).


In contrast to their own lives, citizens see the country heading in the wrong direction. By a wide margin. Only 17% believe that the country is headed in the right direction.

Is this simply fear of the future? I am doing alright now but am worried about future risks?

I am guessing that that is probably a big part of the disconnect. There is a lot of authoritarianism floating around.
I (the government) will make you buy insurance you don't want but its for your own good.

I will take away your Second Amendment rights despite what the Constitution says, for your own good.

I will continue to admit immigrants to the country even if they end up carrying out a disproportionate number of terror attacks.

I will suppress free speech so that people don't get upset.

I will use the IRS to suppress opinions contrary to my own.

I will use executive orders if the people's Representatives don't give me what I want and even if the Supreme Court rejects my use of that power.
The list is long and grows longer all the time. People are concerned that the system is not looking out for them, particularly if they are in the middle, lower middle, or bottom classes. The FBI tells us that a major politician broke the law, jeopardizing national security, but that it isn't worthwhile charging her. Journolist reveals that the media elite are indeed coordinating against the views and interests of half of Americans. Wikileaks shows us that the system is indeed rigged against anyone threatening to upset the apple cart and endanger the insider dealings.

So perhaps the working hypothesis is: Things are going well for me now (85% personal satisfaction) but I am worried about the direction the country is taking (83%). The problem is, reciting the above known facts, people are right to be concerned.

We are back to the issue that our elites and the institutions they dominate (the academy, the executive branch, the legislative branch, the news media, the entertainment industry) have dramatically lost the trust of the citizenry. In fact, most those groups have trust ratings ranging from 7%-20%. If those elites behave better (honestly) and work towards the betterment of the whole community instead of their own pockets and their selected special interests, then we might see a reconciliation between personal satisfaction and national stisfaction.

Till then, I suspect not.

I have recently discovered that you live dissolutely and slothfully

From The Invention of News: How The World Came to Know About Itself by Andrew Pettegree.

And what do students in medieval Europe write home about? Just what you would think.
The examples that survive of student correspondence are undoubtedly only a tiny proportion of the anxious communications that shuttled back and forth between universities and home. But the letters were sufficiently numerous for us to hope to discover in them some informed commentary on current affairs. Universities were placed in some of Europe's most vibrant cities, close to the ebb and flow of political life. Yet for all this the harvest of insights and comment on the great events of the day is decidedly meager. Students writing home had two things uppermost in mind: to impress their parents with their progress in the art of letter writing, and to ask for cash. The medieval epistolary style was formal and highly structured, and students, often destined for a career as an official or a clerk, were keen to demonstrate their progress in mastering this art. If they happened to be less diligent in the attending of classes of masters who taught these skills, there were copy-books and manuals with model letters to draw on as shortcuts. The formal salutations over, the writer cut to the chase: money had run out; it was hard for family back home to realise how expensive a university could be; send more. This letter from Oxford University written around 1220 could stand for thousands in a similar vein:
This is to inform you that I am studying at Oxford with the greatest diligence, but the matter of money stands greatly in the way of my promotion, as it is now two months since I spent the last of what you sent me. The city is expensive and makes many demands: I have to rent lodgings, buy necessaries, and provide for many other things which I cannot now specify. Wherefore I respectfully beg your paternity that by the promptings of divine pity you may assist me, so that I may be able to complete what I have well begun.
Few parents found it easy to resist the pleas of a starving child even if the presentations of ceaseless industry were treated with healthy skepticism. "I have recently discovered," wrote one exasperated parent from Besancon to his son at Orleans,
that you live dissolutely and slothfully, preferring license to restraint and play to work, and strumming a guitar while the others are at their studies, whence it happens that you have read but one volume of law while your more industrious companions have read several. Wherefore I have decided to exhort you herewith to repent utterly of your dissolute and careless ways, that you may no longer be called a waster, and that your shame may be called to good repute.

Beyond parody

I find this election cycle bewildering in its contradictions. Poe's Law rules.

Looking at the tweet below, I have to assume that this is a parody. But no, it's true.



You click on the link and you go to the candidate's website. It's (unbelievably) real.

Selective enforcement as the hallmark of a corrupted system

I find this a very plausible and insightful article, Why Progressives Mislead: Their coalition is fragile. by John O. McGinnis. At the very least it provides a possible explanation for a longstanding political mystery.

McGinnis's argument is there in the headline. A fuller explanation:
Barack Obama’s supporters and detractors don’t agree on much, but as the president enters his final two years in office, they have voiced a common complaint: the president lacks competence. They cite multiple management breakdowns, such as the disastrous rollout of the Obamacare health-insurance website, which have eroded public support; his lack of engagement with Congress, which has impeded his legislative agenda; and his chronic inability to address serious problems before they become full-blown crises, undermining Americans’ confidence in his leadership.

There is no doubt considerable truth to these charges. But Obama’s fundamental problems stem less from incompetence than from his philosophy of governance. In his first presidential campaign, Obama took pains to distinguish his approach from the incrementalism of Bill Clinton and modeled himself instead on the transformational leadership of Franklin Roosevelt and of Ronald Reagan. During the race, and increasingly after the election, it became clear that Obama embraced a theory of dramatic political change—that of progressivism, which dates its American origins to an early-twentieth-century era of social and political reform. And he has adhered to it, despite some of the worst midterm election defeats faced by any two-term president.

[snip]

Today, the federal government spends more than five times as much, as a percentage of GDP, than it did at the beginning of the last century, and twice as much as when Social Security was introduced. That amount will continue to grow, driven by the rising cost of entitlements for an aging population. The future consequences of past decisions thus constrain the present capacity of the state, even as progressivism’s reach becomes more ambitious: reorganizing health care, as the Obama administration has begun to do with the 2010 passage of the Affordable Care Act, better known as Obamacare, touches everyone’s life in ways that, say, the regulation of railroads did not. Such massive programs are more likely to be complex and to generate popular resistance, as Obamacare has done.

On top of these structural difficulties, the progressive coalition has also become harder to maintain. Over the course of the twentieth century, free-market capitalism created unprecedented mass affluence. The average income of Americans grew by more than four times in the last century, making the United States the wealthiest nation of any substantial size. Citizens now have more to lose from interventions in the free market, because they are better off. It’s hard to imagine that a progressive party could maintain control of both the House and Senate for 20 consecutive years and the House for 40 years, as did the Democrats earlier in the twentieth century.

Faced with these constraints, today’s progressives must resort to more misleading and sometimes coercive measures, as they seek to bring about equality through collective responsibility; they must rally support by looking beyond economics, to cultural and social identifications, in a bid to maintain the support of voters with little need for government intervention. They also want to limit the voices of citizens at election time, and thereby magnify the influence of the press and academia, which lean sharply in the progressive direction.
There is plenty to quibble with and discuss in here, but I suspect that McGinnis is directing our attention in an important direction. After the above passages, there follow extensive evidence supporting McGinnis's argument.

He has some additional insights.
But today’s progressivism needs more than wide-ranging discretion to adapt its laws to new circumstances when its coalition no longer controls Congress. The examples above suggest that President Obama is exercising unilateral power to decline to enforce laws or even to rewrite them. Such power exceeds the traditional norms of prosecutorial discretion. Indeed, it comes perilously close to the “dispensing power” of the Stuart monarchs, who claimed the authority to disregard laws. The British rejected that power during the Glorious Revolution, and the Founders rejected it, too, by inserting language into the American Constitution requiring that the president “take Care that the law be faithfully executed.”

[snip]

The freedom of citizens to pay for political messages poses a threat to progressives because it endangers the control over political and social discourse that the Left otherwise enjoys. The media lean overwhelmingly Democratic, with some studies estimating the imbalance between Democrats and Republicans at more than four to one. Academia is even more lopsidedly left-wing. In the Ivy League, which remains the most powerful educational megaphone for social ideas, Obama attracted 20 times as many contributors as Mitt Romney. This ideological imbalance provides progressivism with one of its most powerful weapons. And here the attack on Citizens United becomes especially practical: restricting independent campaign expenditures will allow the press and the academic world to control the agenda, as they already do for periods between elections.
McGinnis ends with a call, which I heartily endorse, of returning to the rule of law.
Countering the progressive drive to reduce the speech rights of those outside the symbolic class, conservatives should emphasize the principle of equality before the law. No class should be given particular privileges to speak about politics. The answer to complaints about the undue influence of campaign money at election time can be found in the principle of neutrality. Congress should commit itself to operate by evenhanded rules of appropriate generality and thus ban earmarks, targeted regulatory relief, and other favors often used to reward political support.

Devotion to the rule of law can also contain corrosive culture wars. By decentralizing decision making and diffusing debate in this context, federalism lowers the temperature of national politics and allows the national government to focus on defense and other issues to which it is uniquely suited. And decreasing the payoff to victory in the culture wars lessens progressives’ motivation to use social appeals to rally a coalition that might otherwise fracture.

From its inception, progressivism has posed a threat to constitutional government. It has sought to replace limited and decentralized governance with dynamic, centralized authority in order to force some arrangement of equality on the nation. Because the world has a way of upsetting abstract designs, progressivism depends on empowering administrators to impose its frameworks while disempowering citizens from resisting these coercions. The Obama administration’s push for unilateral presidential authority to disregard the law is thus the logical extension of the progressive program. Opposition to this program requires nothing less than a rededication to our Founding ideals: our nation must be governed by the rule of law, not the rule of an elected monarch or of a legally privileged aristocracy.
I like McGinnis's broad argument for several reasons.

For one, it reconciles a longstanding and peculiar paradox. President Obama is clearly not nearly as smart as his followers are wont to claim. There simply is no evidence to support a position that he is anything more than an averagely intelligent politician. Certainly not in his track record of accomplishments. On the other hand, he cannot be nearly as stupid as his actions seem to indicate that he is. A president who cannot function constructively with a Congress dominated by his own party and with a shared agenda seems to have some fundamental impediment. He is obviously not nearly as bright as his acolytes claim but nor can he be nearly as stupid as his actions would indicate.

My explanation for Obama's demonstrated unwillingness to work with others has long been simply that Obama was experientially or psychologically unable to acknowledge the agency of others. He had his agenda and did not have the negotiating skills and horse-trading experience nor the strategic vision to work towards the goals of that agenda. I am still not sure that that is an incorrect interpretation but McGinnis certainly supplements it with the idea that Obama simply had an ideological commitment to transformative government which blinded him to the traditional means of accomplishing change. Under McGinnis's explanation, it is irrelevant whether Obama had the negotiating skills and strategic vision or not. He could only view the world through the lens of compulsory change via coercive orders and therefore that is the path he pursued. When all you have is a hammer, everything is a nail.

I also think McGinnis is absolutely correct about the cure to this strain of totalitarianism. Quit focusing on the culture war trolling and social justice divisiveness of the totalitarians and focus on the more fundamental, the more consequential, and the more inspiring concept of the rule of law.

Have as many laws as you need for a complex society (but no more) and enforce those laws equally on everyone. If they are effective laws that support a societally endorsed goal, they will survive. If they are ineffective laws or are directed towards goals which are not societally supported, they will be reformed or revoked.

The bad habit of selectively enforcing laws only when they are politically expedient is a cancer on the body politic. The practice allows bad laws to live much longer than they should and disenfranchises and disempowers citizens.

The citizenry see and are revulsed by our venal politicians. But our elected leaders can only get away with their corruption as long as they are allowed to enforce laws selectively. Banks that are too big to fail and politicians who are too powerful to indict are symptoms of a dysfunctional system. The fastest way to heal the system and cleanse it of bad or ineffective laws is to enforce the laws on everyone and consistently. I think citizens would be excited to see the stick of selective enforcement removed from the corrupted grasp of the political elite.

Monday, August 1, 2016

News depended on chance encounters with strangers

From The Invention of News: How The World Came to Know About Itself by Andrew Pettegree.
The centuries with which this book is concerned witnessed a vast widening of horizons for Europe’s citizens. The discovery of the Americas and the creation of new trade routes to Asia brought a fresh relationship with distant continents. But while these new discoveries have done much to shape our perceptions of those periods, just as important at the time was the quiet incremental revolution that brought citizens in touch with the neighboring city, the capital and other countries in Europe. Sitting down to their weekly digest of news in any of a dozen European countries in 1750, men and women could experience the fascination of faraway events. They could obtain, through regular perusal, a sense of the leading personalities of European society, and the disposition of its powers. Four centuries previously such knowledge would have been far less widely shared. In this earlier period for the vast majority of citizens news of life outside the village, or the city walls, depended on chance encounters with strangers. Many such citizens would have little knowledge of the world beyond, unless directly affected by the local consequences of high politics or warfare. This was a very different time for news. What we do detect, however, even at this earlier date, is a hunger for information, even if it could only be satisfied for those in the highest reaches of politics and commerce. This was the same hunger that in the centuries that followed would set European society on the road towards a modern culture of communication.

We have a robust form of government and we have had worse choices in the past

From Is the press pushing Hillary's argument that Trump is 'dangerous'? by Howard Kurtz. Well, yes, of course. Democrats with bylines (or JournoLists) gave the DNC 40% more coverage than the RNC and are pushing the primary Democratic themes as hard as they can. Oddly, Trump, with his tendency towards unfettered communication, seems to be doing everything he can to help them.

I do not see anyone commenting on the fact that Trump gives press conferences every time you turn around which offers unfettered opportunity to the opposition press to play gotcha journalism and attack dog journalism on anything that deviates from the Democratic party campaign themes. Seems like that there should be some compensating mechanism for the fact that Hillary Clinton hasn't done a press conference in some 200 days.

Given that the FBI Director Comey has recently confirmed that virtually everything she said in her last press conference was an explicit and objective lie, you can see why the campaign would want to avoid repeating the process. Astonishingly, candidate Clinton doubled down on her lies by claiming in an interview yesterday that:
Director Comey said my answers were truthful, and what I’ve said is consistent with what I have told the American people,
Truly, truly astonishing that a major party could have produced this venal, corrupt, destructive, charlatan as their chosen candidate. An astonishment rivaled only by the outrageousness of the other main party's candidate.

This is hardly a left/right issue, a Democratic/Republican issue, insider/outsider issue. We have a wonderful American system of government that has, this election cycle, coughed up two of the more astonishingly bad hairball candidates in the same cycle in a long time.

From Kurtz's article:
Trump’s theme is that Hillary is weak, beholden to special interests and, well, crooked. Clinton’s theme is that The Donald is crude, reckless, inexperienced and ignorant.
The challenge to the electorate is that both Trump and Clinton are reasonably accurate in their charges against their opponent.

For the time being I am inclined against proven criminality, incompetence, crony capitalism, and corruptness and towards the candidate who may simply be naively reckless. But that that should be the choice is a grave shame.

Ah well, we have endured worse. Thank goodness for a divided and republican form of government with all its checks and balances.

An increase of 67 million welfare recipients and an increase of 82 million emigrants

In a book review column from Why ‘white trash’ Americans are flocking to Donald Trump by Kyle Smith. The fellow grew-up in the culture of the Appalachian Scots-Irish redneck and reflects on the dysfunction of that culture now and how it feeds in to the growing popularity of Trump. We still have 100 days of this ceaseless overindulgence of focusing on elections. Its hard not to feel affinity with Juvenal and his panem et circenses (bread and circuses). In Byzantium we had the division of the empire into competing teams of the Blues, Reds, Whites, and Greens. Today we have competing victimhood groups.

100 more days of the panem et circenses.

The book being reivewed is quite possibly an interesting book but I was more struck by the juxtaposition of data.
Manufacturing shed 5 million jobs after 2000, giving way to welfare, drugs and despondency. The number of Americans receiving welfare of one kind or another exploded from 42 million (or 18.8 percent of Americans) in 1983 to 109 million (or 35 percent) in 2012. As America added 83 million citizens, then, it added 67 million welfare recipients — during a period of massive wealth creation. (Per-capita income rose from about $30,000 in 1983 to over $52,000 in 2012.)
As I have noted elsewhere, the US is still the second largest manufacturing country in the world and we have not suffered a decline in manufacturing at all. What we have suffered is a decline in employment in manufacturing. We have automated the heck out of industrial processes in order to remain globally competitive. That has shored up sales and profitability but at the expense of well-paying manufacturing jobs.

The burden of those lost jobs have not fallen equally, either by class or geography. The social disruption and dislocation has been concentrated in the northeast and midwest while class disruption has been concentrated among the middle and blue collar classes.

What Smith's data illustrates, it seems to me, is lost perspective and false equivalences. In an economy of 115 or so million jobs, the disruption of 5 million jobs should not be a big signifier even if they are geographically and socially concentrated.

I think it is really the all-to-easy false equivalence that is interesting. 67 million more welfare recipients and 83 million more emigrants. If you are an elite in a comfy white-collar high income policy related job, you obviously know that there is no direct equivalence between an increase of 67 million welfare recipients and 83 million emigrants.

But does that distinction remain clear from all perspectives? I suspect not.

Let's add a complication. Of the 83 million emigrants, not all are equal. I don't have the numbers at hand or the time to investigate but I think general numbers illustrate the point.

Let's hypothesize that 20 million of those emigrants are white collar, highly educated. White collar knowledge economy jobs are the part of the economy which is growing. If you are a college educated professional, competition for particular positions with foreign born emigrants might be a nuisance, but it is not the be-all-and-end-all. If you lose out on that desired position, you wait a year or two till the next round of promotions or you switch to another firm. The socioeconomic elite don't in general suffer all that much from increased professional competition.

Let's say that another 20 million of those emigrants are solid middle class people and entrepreneurs. They are running restaurants, gas stations, motels. They are radiology technicians, nurses and dental hygienists. Often they are doing work that others, particularly the elite, are mush less interested in doing. The elite love the increased diversity of and exoticism of varietal restaurant cuisine choices. They appreciate cheaper and more reliable gardening services.

None of the above 40 million are likely to receive welfare benefits on anything other than a very temporary basis.

Then there are the final 23 million. Refugee groups who have a hard time adjusting, illegal economic migrants with minimum skills, extended family migrations with low skilled or welfare dependent family members. There's a whole range of circumstances among this group. I suspect that this is a group that is not actually 23 million but perhaps a bit or a good deal smaller. But they stand out.

If you are among the bottom 20% of native Americans, these are the people competing with you for unskilled and opportunistic jobs. These are the people you see being protected by the system, apparently at your expense. These are the people that turn against America (for example self-radicalized terrorists) or who simply become dependent on welfare programs and NGO generosity. The top 20% do not see this segment of the emigrant group. For all intents and purposes, for the top 20% of native borns, the 23 million do not exist.

But if you are among the bottom 20% (or 30% or 40%), you see all the downsides of emigration and virtually no benefits. If you are in the top 20%, you see no downsides to emigration and all the benefits. Hence the anger against the elites and the excitement over the prospect of a Trump or a Sanders.

Or, at least, it seems to me.