Friday, March 11, 2016

Desirable but unintended consequences

From How The Scots Invented the Modern World by Arthur Herman. Page 27.
The Schools Act of 1696 had set off far-reaching changes the Kirk could never have foreseen--a good example of how social actions have unintended consequences, as Adam Smith and a later generation of Scottish thinkers so well understood. Smith observed, in his Wealth of Nations, how Scotland's parish school system taught "almost the whole common people to read, and a very great proportion of them to write and account." Today we recognize that literacy and its mathematical counterpart, numeracy, are fundamental skills for living in a complex modern society. In that sense, no other society in Europe was as broadly prepared for "takeoff" as was eighteenth-century Scotland.
The Schools Act was intended to facilitate the individual's direct connection with God through the word of the Bible but incidentally set the stage for a rare intellectual blossoming.

Thursday, March 10, 2016

Ancient wisdom




A famine in the winter of 1944–5 that killed a million people

From Small Wars, Faraway Places by Michael Burleigh. Page 33. Its the details left out of other histories which provide so much substance to Burleigh's account.

1) I like the name of the American OSS advisor to the Viet Minh (Archimedes Patti) and 2) Who remembers there was a famine in Vietnam in 1944-45 in which a million people starved to death?
Japanese destruction of French rule forced crucial decisions on the Viet Minh. It also provided the Americans with an opportunity to use the Vietnamese to fight the Japanese. The US began dropping arms from aircraft based in southern China, while the Viet Minh provided valuable weather reports and helped locate shot-down US aircrew. In March 1945 the OSS sent ‘Deer Team’ into Vietnam to liaise with the ‘old man’ who led the Viet Minh. One of these agents, Archimedes ‘Al’ Patti, penned an account of their stay in a jungle encampment. The emaciated Viet Minh leader, already tubercular, lay ill with dysentery and malaria, but rallied enough to chain-smoke Patti’s Chesterfields after the team doctor had treated him. The OSS agents taught guerrillas, commanded by Giap – ‘a wiry little man with large calculating eyes and a perpetually angry look’ – how to use modern weapons. The Americans spent many agreeable hours with Ho Chi Minh, who at one point inquired in English: ‘Your statesmen make eloquent speeches about helping those with self-determination. We are self-determined. Why not help us? Am I different from Nehru, Quezon, even your George Washington? Was not Washington considered a revolutionary? I, too, want to set my people free.’ Privately he thought that the Americans were all about business. As Ho heard news of the dropping of the atomic bombs and the Japanese surrender that August, he and Giap decided to launch their insurrection, their task aided by widespread peasant anger over a famine in the winter of 1944–5 that killed a million people, after the Japanese had refused to stop exporting rice to Japan from their state granaries.

Wednesday, March 9, 2016

Jethro Tull, serendipity edition

I have been listening to Jethro Tull for thirty or more years. Their band name was unusual but I gave it little thought. In reading a history of Scotland I came across the Scottish agricultural scientist Jethro Tull. Could they have been named for him? It seemed improbable but indeed they were. From Wikipedia.
At first, the new band had trouble getting repeat bookings and they took to changing their name frequently to continue playing the London club circuit, which included "Navy Blue", "Ian Henderson's Bag o' Nails" and "Candy Coloured Rain". Anderson recalled looking at a poster at a club and concluding that the band name he didn't recognise was his. Band names were often supplied by their booking agents' staff, one of whom, a history enthusiast, eventually christened them "Jethro Tull" after the 18th-century agriculturist. The name stuck because they happened to be using it the first time a club manager liked their show enough to invite them to return.

Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Mote and beam

Hmm.

I came across Philip N. Cohen's twitter. Seems interestingly eclectic. As I am scanning down his tweets, I see:



From the tenor of his tweets and the nature of his research, Cohen seems solidly of the left. He is responding in this tweet with some criticism directed at Kay Hymowitz who is solidly on the right. I can't quite discern the nature of the back and forth but clearly it is something to do with the election campaign.

None-the-less, it is a quite striking criticism, and I suspect revealing of the differences in weltanschauung between left and right. The left as it exists today in the US and particularly in the academy, media and in the entertainment industry is obsessed with group identities. The right, somewhat ironically given their vilification by the left, is now the torch bearer of MLK's dream of treating people not based on the color of their skin but by the content of their character. It seems almost as if the left's first question is "What color are you?" versus the right's "Who are you, what do you believe?"

This difference in orientation is oddly manifested in the respective candidate fields between the Democrats and Republicans. With their group identity approach, the Democrats ironically muster three white politicians from the northeast, two of them quite elderly. Old white people doesn't quite describe the Democrat field but it is close.

In contrast, the Republicans, with a focus on character and accomplishment rather than race, class, and gender come up with a field of seventeen candidates that is the very model of the diversity which Democrats, in other circumstances, might admire. Men, women, older, younger, establishment, outsiders, candidates with executive experience and executive neophytes, candidates from the North, South, Midwest, and West, black, white, Hispanic and Asian candidates, politicians, attorneys, real estate developers, hi-tech businesswomen, brain surgeons, etc.

That's what makes Cohen's tweet intriguing. Its as if he doesn't see that the Republicans have delivered the very diversity he wants but they have done so without the postmodernist/critical theory worldview to which he, presumably, adheres. Without the ideological adherence, it seems that the desired outcome is invalidated.

Meanwhile, he also seems blind to the fact that the Democrats, while almost obsessively focused on group identity and criticizing racism, have delivered the same old tired homogenous roster of entrenched interests. And, it seems that that is alright so long as they are criticizing that which they are doing.

Arendt and silver linings

Hannah Arendt has only ever been a name in the academic constellation for me. As far as I know, I have never read any of her works. But in the past two weeks I have come across a couple of engaging ideas or passages of hers.

The most recent is from Totalitarianism: Part Three of The Origins of Totalitarianism by Hannah Arendt. From the left side of the spectrum, we have had several years of mob mentality in the name of Social Justice. From the Duke Lacrosse team to George Zimmerman to Ferguson we have had the digital and real life mob baying to suspend the laws of the land and convict people based on hatred rather than evidence and the law.

We also have some of our most respected institutions of higher learning demonstrating a repeated desire to suspend due process as well as suppress any speech that might be offensive to entrenched interests.

From the center (lifelong Democrat but now running as a Republican) we have such phenomena as Donald Trump who articulates little or no respect for the law of the land and the equality of all before the law.

I have no expectation that we will fall into a mob mentality. These are people at the fringes. None-the-less the fringes are impinging more than they usually do. Arendt saw this process herself in Germany in the 1920s and 1930s. Her words are disturbing for their resonance with some of the tides in public discourse today.
Totalitarian propaganda perfects the techniques of mass propaganda, but it neither invents them nor originates their themes. These were prepared for them by fifty years of the rise of imperialism and disintegration of the nation-state, when the mob entered the scene of European politics. Like the earlier mob leaders, the spokesmen for totalitarian movements possessed an unerring instinct for anything that ordinary party propaganda or public opinion did not care or dare to touch. Everything hidden, everything passed over in silence, became of major significance, regardless of its own intrinsic importance. The mob really believed that truth was whatever respectable society hypocritically passed over, or covered up with corruption.
It seems to me that Trump and Sanders with their respective mobs are rising up against the institutional crony capitalism and political correctness of the Clintons and Bushes. "If you won't respect us by telling the truth and dealing in honest fashion, then we won't respect you and will follow the anti-establishment candidates." Not a desirable path to travel but if it is the self-correction needed to shock our political class out of their pampered complacency, then perhaps there is a silver lining.

University of the Toilers of the East

From Small Wars, Faraway Places by Michael Burleigh. Page 29. The peripatetic travels of Ho Ch Minh.
In Indochina the French had ruthlessly suppressed every manifestation of anti-colonial sentiment, from mutinous troops via rebellious peasants to striking schoolboys, but there was one implacable opponent who eluded them for three decades: Ho Chi Minh. This was the final iteration of multiple aliases Ho would use. Nguyen Tat Thanh (He Who Will Succeed) was born in about 1890 to a farmer’s son who had joined the mandarin elite, achieving the equivalent of a doctorate. Whether because of pride or temperament, Ho’s father refused to work directly for the puppet emperor who ruled supposedly autonomous Annam, working instead as a rural teacher and then as a magistrate. In 1910 in a drunken rage he caned the wrong person to death and was dismissed from office. He died poor in Saigon.

The future Ho was a bright boy who shed the long hair that marked him out as a country bumpkin at school. He realized early on that a mastery of Western culture – including its revolutionary tradition – was the way to defeat Western imperialism. By his late teens Thanh was involved in anti-French demonstrations, which resulted in expulsion from his French school. Already marked out by the colonial police, he eventually embarked for France, as ‘Ba’, an assistant cook and stoker on a small liner bound for Marseilles. A truly remarkable odyssey had begun.

When Ho arrived in Marseilles in July 1911, he noted that ‘the French in France are better and more polite than in Indochina’. In cafés waiters called him ‘Monsieur’. He applied without success for a scholarship to attend the Colonial School. After he had opted for the merchant marine his movements were necessarily opaque; but, wherever he ventured ashore, he moved in political circles as Nguyen Ai Quoc (Nguyen the Patriot).

In July 1923 he slipped his French police shadows through the rear exit of a Parisian cinema and boarded a train to Hamburg and on to Russia by ship as the Chinese merchant ‘Chen Vang’. In Moscow he enrolled in the University of the Toilers of the East, which was informally known as the Stalin School since it was under his Commissariat of Nationalities. By July 1923 Ho was deemed important enough to move into the Lux Hotel, albeit into a small room with a bed infested with bugs. In January 1924 his face and fingers were damaged after queuing for hours in deep winter to view Lenin’s body. After impressing his Comintern comrades at the Fifth Congress in 1924, speaking of the need to strike imperialism in the colonies from which it drew its resources, he persuaded his superiors to send him to Canton to organize exiled Vietnamese revolutionaries.
University of the Toilers of the East - I really miss the linguistic felicity of the old Soviet Union. Heh.

Monday, March 7, 2016

The Life of Sir William Wallace, lent to him by the local blacksmith.

From How The Scots Invented the Modern World by Arthur Herman. Page 24.
Robert Burns's father was a poor farmer from Alloway in southwestern Scotland, who taught his son to make a living by handling a plow. But he also saw to it that young Robert received an education worthy of an English gentleman, including studying Latin and French. For the future poet, it opened up an incredible new world. "Though I cost the schoolmaster some thrashings." Burns remembered later, "I made an excellent scholar." The first books he read were a biography of Hannibal and The Life of Sir William Wallace, lent to him by the local blacksmith. "The story of Wallace poured a Scottish prejudice in my veins," Burns recalled, "which will boil along there till the flood gates of life shut in eternal rest." By the time he was sixteen, Burns the budding Ayrshire plowman had made his way through generous portions of Shakespeare, Alexander Pope, Addison's Spectator essays, and the Scottish poet Allan Ramsay, along with Jeremy Taylor on theology, Jethro Tull on agriculture, Robert Boyle's lectures on chemistry, John Locke's Essay Concerning Human Understanding, several volumes on geography and history, and the French Enlightenment philosopher Fenelon's Telemaque in the original.

Do we treat Burns's case as typical? Of course not. But his story does illustrate how early on reading and writing became embedded in Scottish society, even in rural areas.

In Edinburgh the book trade was an important part of the local economy. There were six publishing houses in 1763, for a city with a population of only sixty thousand. By 1790 there were sixteen. Papermaking become a mainstay of the national economy; in fact, as the historian Anand Chitnis notes, "of Scottish domestic manufactures, only woolens, linen, and hemp, iron and liquors employed more people than the paper industry." The paper mill was often the only industry in rural villages and hamlets in the Lowlands agricultural belt. The one at Currie brought two hundred new inhabitants into the village when it opened.

Bookselling, printing, the paper and ink industries a whole range of businesses to service a large literate public. An official national survey in 1795 showed that out of a total population of 1.5 million, nearly twenty thousand Scots depended for their livelihood on writing and publishing and 10,500 on teaching. All this meant that despite its relative poverty and small population, Scottish culture had a built-in bias toward reading, learning, and education in general. In no other European country did education count for so much, or enjoy so broad a base.

This attitude also decisively shaped the character of Scotland's universities and would play a key role in creating modern Scotland. But their roots ran solid and deep. Glasgow and St. Andrews, in particular, enjoyed a long tradition that reached back to the Middle Ages. The greatest figure of later medieval thought, John Duns Scotus, had been a Scot, while John Mair, dubbed "the prince of philosophers and theologians" at the University of Paris, finished his career teaching at both Glasgow and St. Andrews (his students there included George Buchanan and John Knox). In 1574 an observer wrote that "there is no place in Europe comparable to Glasgow for a plentifull and gude chepe mercat of all kind of langages artes and sciences."

The University of Edinburgh and Aberdeen's Marischal College and King's College had been founded more recently, but, like Glasgow and St. Andrews, they never became remote ivory towers or intellectual backwaters, as eighteenth-century Oxford and Cambridge did. Despite their small size, Scottish universities were international centers of learning, and drew students from across Protestant Europe as well as England and Ulster (since only Episcopalians could attend Oxford or Cambridge or Trinity College in Dublin).

Thanks to the swelling tide of literacy, these universities became in effect centers of popular education as well as more academic learning. Between 1720 and 1840 the college student population of Scotland trebled. Knowledge of Latin was usually enough to get you in, and many students learned this at their parish schools. A university education was also relatively cheap.

At Glasgow the tuition fee of five pounds a year was one-tenth the cost of going to Cambridge or Oxford. This meant that students like the Edinburgh apothecary's son Thomas Aikenhead were more the rule rather than the exception. A father in trade, commerce, or the professions was more typical than a working- or labouring-class one; but even this contrasted with the socially top-heavy landed gentry and aristocratic student bodies in the English universities. More than half of the students at the University of Glasgow between 1740 and 1830 came from middle-class backgrounds. Many, although probably not very many, of the rest came from lower down the social ladder.

In the eighteenth century, sons of artisans and shopkeepers and farmers, some as young as thirteen or fourteen, would scrape together enough money to pay their university fees, attending lectures alongside Frasers and Maxwells and Erskines, the sons of Scotland's most aristocratic families. Robert Foulis, who was an apprentice barber and the son of a maltman, spent his spare time in the 1730s taking classes with the University of Glasgow's most distinguished philosopher, Francis Hutcheson, as well as the mathematician Robert Simson. Hutcheson was so impressed by Foulis that he hired him as his classroom assistant. It was the sort of scene unimaginable at Oxford or Cambridge until very late in the Victorian era.

Nor were boys the only ones who benefited from this. Auditing university classes became a favorite hobby among Edinburgh and Aberdeen townspeople, just as professors regularly engaged in a "community outreach" to offer classes to students outside the academic setting.

Robert Dick, at the University of Glasgow, taught natural philosophy to a lecture hall of townspeople, men and women, in the 1750s. In the early nineteenth century, University of Edinburgh chemistry professor Thomas Hope's public lectures drew more than three hundred serious-minded ladies from the town. For middle-class Scots, education was more than just a means to professional credentials or social advancement. It became a way of life.


Occam's Razor versus spinning

I think both these articles are misleading but that their underlying point is still interesting. From Fewer Democrats Are Voting This Year In (Surprise!) States With Strict New Voter Laws by Janie Velencia and Alissa Scheller and from Dem turnout and voter ID: The dirty little secret by Thomas Lifson, respectively left-leaning and right-leaning magazines.

Scheller and Velencia are bringing to attention to an interesting phenomena that has received some, but not a lot, of media attention; the differences between the two parties in their turn-out so far in the election cycle.
GOP voter turnout in this year's presidential race is up 62 percent relative to 2008, the last time both parties had open contests. But Democratic voter turnout is down by 29 percent across all the primary and caucus states that have voted so far. In all but two states, fewer Democrats turned out to vote in 2016 than did in 2008.
My go-to explanation is that this reflects primarily different levels of competitiveness in the two races.

On the Democratic side you have two white, northeastern candidates long in the tooth. One is a principled and self-identified socialist and the other is a politician under FBI investigation on multiple issues and with a career clouded by controversy, ethically dubious decisions, and legally questionable actions. In addition, from the start of the contest, all the establishment powers were trying to force this into a coronation rather than a contest with super delegates and sycophantic press coverage and DNC shenanigans to provide coverage for the preferred candidate. The deck was stacked and there wasn't much choice. To the surprise of everyone, the principled socialist conducted a more than forlorn hope campaign. None-the-less, this was a campaign of few choices and little competition.

On the Republican side you have had a field of, what, seventeen candidates? Men, women, older, younger, establishment, outsiders, candidates with executive experience and executive neophytes, Tea Party conservatives, social conservatives, libertarians, religious conservatives, fiscal conservatives, candidates from the North, South, Midwest, and West, black, white, Hispanic and Asian candidates, etc. Lots of choice and lots of competition.

Competition tends to increase turnout. My Occam's Razor is that the Republicans have had much more choice, a much wider range of choice and fought much harder over their choices and that is why their turnout is up whereas the Democrat turnout is down.

Scheller and Velencia want to make this empirical phenomena (increased Republican turnout versus declining Democrat turnout) about voter identification. I think they have a poorly structured and unsupported argument.

My standing assumption about voter fraud is that it is more prevalent than Democrats want to acknowledge and less prevalent than Republican activists make it out to be. There are enough well documented (though rarely publicized) incidents to affirm that it is a real issue. Incidents such as counties with 104% turnout of registered voters and the like.

It does happen. But how prevalent is it? That is the critical question to answer and that is unanswered. And how consequential is it? Also unanswered. We have a lot of elections that come down to a swing of a few hundred votes or of a percentage point or two. It is quite conceivable that it is more prevalent than we realize and that it is consequential. Possible but not certain. It warrants investigation but Democrats have been reflexively resistant to even the lightest research to answer the question. A position which makes it appear that they have something to hide.

An impression that is increased by the fact that their claimed suppression of voting following implementation of voter ID laws has not showed up in actual election results. In fact, in the last research report I saw a couple of years ago, states with voter ID laws typically saw higher turnout than before the ID law was passed. Remembering that the sample size is still very small, I don't view that as conclusive by any means but it does call into question the Democrat concern that voter ID suppresses voting.

The Republicans have been more exercised about voting fraud because they appear to believe that it is more prevalent and more consequential. The Democrats have been more obstructionist to voter ID laws and also seem to have been the greater beneficiaries of elections where there are greater accusations of voter fraud. Sometime in the aughts, there was a string of Senate contests where the Republican came in with a victory of a couple of hundred votes which election was then contested by Democrats with one, two and three recounts, each recount increasing the number of Democrat ballots. Might have been a statistical fluke, but it looked suspicious.

Back to Scheller and Velencia's argument:
Eight out of the 16 states that have held primaries or caucuses so far have implemented new voter ID or other restrictive voting laws since 2010. Democratic turnout has dropped 37 percent overall in those eight states, but just 13 percent in the states that didn't enact new voter restrictions. To put it another way, Democratic voter turnout was 285 percent worse in states with new voter ID laws.
That's interesting and worth investigating. Scheller and Velencia don't investigate, they simply try and make a correlational argument from a small sample size, and then leave it at that. My eyeballing of their data suggests that there might be a different and stronger correlation than between states with and without voter ID.

In six of the nine states with Democrat turnout declines of greater than 20%, the states had a Democrat majority twenty years ago and have switched to Republican majorities. In other words, the current decline is part of a longer term trend of Democrat decline in those six states (South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Arkansas, Tennessee and Texas.) Iowa, Virginia, and Nevada are the possible exceptions (I simply don't know whether the Democrats are declining there or not).

So structural decline is likely a more probable explanation than voter ID laws. The other explanation that seems relevant arises from the observation that the Republican candidate Trump is a lifelong Democrat who seems to be drawing large numbers of Democrats into the Republican column. He has so far done quite well in open primaries (you don't have to be a registered Republican to vote in the Republican primary) and less well in closed primaries (only registered Republicans can vote in the Republican primary). It appears from various polls that 15-30% of Trumps voters are actually Democrats.

If you are a Democrat who votes for Trump in an open primary, you numerically decrease the Democrat turnout and increase the Republican turnout.

Scheller and Velencia make the argument that voter ID laws have been influential in reducing Democrat turnout but they cherry pick their data and do not present the readily available counterarguments that appear to be more explanatory. Turnout is down because 1) the Democrat choices are not appealing to swaths of voters, 2) the elections so far have been primarily in states where the Democrats are in systemic decline anyway, and 3) a segment of Democrats are defecting in open primaries to Donald Trump.

That's my read of the situation.

Lifson's argument is even weaker. His synopsis is:
The numbers tell a story, and you can draw the obvious conclusions. Because the mainstream media certainly won’t. Keep this statistic in mind the next time some progressive tries to claim voter fraud is not a serious problem.

Political Wire quotes the HuffPo:
Huffington Post: “Eight out of the 16 states that have held primaries or caucuses so far have implemented new voter ID or other restrictive voting laws since 2010. Democratic turnout has dropped 37 percent overall in those eight states, but just 13 percent in the states that didn’t enact new voter restrictions. To put it another way, Democratic voter turnout was 285 percent worse in states with new voter ID laws.”
Left unsaid: despite the “burden” of obtaining voter ID, GOP turnout was up.
In other words, for Lifson, the decline is simply a product of reduced opportunity for fraud. I understand the emotional appeal of that argument but it is inadequate as it does not explain the Democrat voting decline in states without voter ID laws.

One final note of interest from these articles and it has to do with journalist advocates and their, presumably, subconscious framing of issues.

The issue is voter ID laws. Scheller and Velencia are comparing states with and without voter ID laws. But notice how they frame it as an issue between states with and without voting restrictions. Very interesting. No state has limited voting. They have limited the opportunities of fraudulent voting. Given how they frame the issue, it would be easy to interpret Scheller and Velencia as being upset that opportunities for fraudulent voting have been reduced. Not what I think they intended to communicate but it seems plausible.

Sunday, March 6, 2016

The Japanese stationed an enormous occupation force, some 625,800 soldiers, in the Philippines

From Small Wars, Faraway Places by Michael Burleigh. Page 25. I had not realized that the Japanese occupation of the Philippines required such a sizeable part of their army (about 10% of their entire field force). Nor had I realized that the occupied Philippines had declared war on the US. All sorts of interesting details get left out of the simplified overviews.
In the event, by May 1942 the Japanese had overrun the Philippines, forcing the US to surrender its forces after dogged rearguard actions at Bataan and Corregidor. MacArthur was evacuated, accompanied on his retreat to Australia by the Commonwealth’s President Manuel Quezon. The Japanese stationed an enormous occupation force, some 625,800 soldiers, in the Philippines, which were rightly regarded as crucial to defence of the home islands and to the entire Japanese position in South-east Asia. Few members of the Hispanic elites who had collaborated with the Americans had qualms about switching their allegiance. The Japanese met them halfway, explaining, ‘Like it or not you are Filipinos and belong to the Oriental race. No matter how hard you try, you cannot become white people.’33 Tokyo offered its collaborators independence more rapidly than the defeated Americans had done. In July 1943 they were instructed to draft a constitution, the quid pro quo being that they declare war on the US, which after much foot dragging they did in September 1944.