Monday, February 15, 2016

Visiting with one's ancestors

Just finished Empire of Blue Water by Stephan Talty. From the blurb:
The passion and violence of the age of exploration and empire come to vivid life in this story of the legendary pirate who took on the greatest military power on earth with a ragtag bunch of renegades. Awash with bloody battles, political intrigues, natural disaster, and a cast of characters more compelling, bizarre, and memorable than any found in a Hollywood swashbuckler, Empire of Blue Water brilliantly re-creates the life and times of Henry Morgan and the real pirates of the Caribbean.
Well, yes, on balance.

I first came across Henry Morgan among my first ventures into reading and he has been around in various accounts of history and maritime books I have read over the years. This is the first book I have read which substantially focused on Morgan.

Several glitches: a handful of recognizable errors, several instances of awkward wording, occasional deviations into non-pertinent material. Could have done with a good editor.

That said, lot's of interesting information that was new to me, lots of connections to global events, and a high energy narrative style that keeps you eagerly reading. Glad to have read it and I will keep my eyes open for his other works. Lot's of interesting passages.

The social habits of Spanish royalty.
On the hot days of that spring and summer, as the news of Jamaica's fall made its way to his court, Philip could be found at the Escorial, the palace built by his grandfather on the slopes of the Sierra de Guadarrama outside of Madrid. Constructed in gratitude for the victory over the French at Saint-Quentin in 1557, it contained art galleries, a library, a college, and a monastery. But Philip was not studying the masterpieces that were hung on the gallery walls, though they were magnificent and featured the faces he knew so well, those of his own family of Hapsburg kings; instead he could be found in the mausoleum, where he'd recently had the bodies of his ancestors brought together and placed in the marble pantheon. Courtiers gossiped about the long hours Philip spent there; he emerged, they reported, with eyes red from weeping. But for Philip, the hours spent alone in the dark, cool tomb were his new pleasure. "I saw the corpse of the Emperor, whose body, although he had been dead ninety-six years, is still perfect," he wrote to a friend, "and by this it may be seen how richly the Lord has repaid him for his efforts in favour of his faith whilst he lived." Still, the bodies of his illustrious dead comforted him less than one empty space; he spent hour after solitary hour kneeling on the stone floors, staring into the slot where his own body would lie. "It helped me much," he admitted. How he envied the dead, who could not be humiliated by events and whose bodies had ceased to rebel against them. How, in his quiet moments, he wished to join them.

Sunday, February 14, 2016

Instead of being able to confess their allegorical nature, they have to conceal it.

A couple of quotes from Arthur Schopenhauer. Schopenhauer lived 1788-1860 so the intellectual ossification he was struggling against was the Church. Today the intellectual ossification against which we struggle is failed totalitarian ideologies desperately trying to bring utopia to earth through coercive means. Currently most manifested in the social justice movement.
When the Church says that, in the dogmas of religion, reason is totally incompetent and blind, and its use to be reprehended, this really attests the fact that these dogmas are allegorical in their nature, and are not to be judged by the standard which reason, taking all things sensu proprio, can alone apply. Now the absurdities of a dogma are just the mark and sign of what is allegorical and mythical in it.
Most participants in the social justice movement are well intended but their intention is primarily an emotional energy. They feel that something should be different. This emotion gives tremendous energy to their efforts. However, noble though their goals might be, their means are almost always woefully uninformed, misguided, and destructive. Which brings me to a second Schopenhauer quote.
The bad thing about all religions is that, instead of being able to confess their allegorical nature, they have to conceal it.
Think of "Hide the decline" from the global warming debate, the repeated failures of Head Start to demonstrate lasting beneficial impact, the jargon of multiple professions intended to fog issues with magisterial command.

Dunbar number and socializing in a technical environment

Dunbar's number is a quite interesting idea that has some appeal to logic and experience but which is still being fleshed out by research. Per Wikipedia:
Dunbar's number is a suggested cognitive limit to the number of people with whom one can maintain stable social relationships. These are relationships in which an individual knows who each person is and how each person relates to every other person. This number was first proposed in the 1990s by British anthropologist Robin Dunbar, who found a correlation between primate brain size and average social group size. By using the average human brain size and extrapolating from the results of primates, he proposed that humans can only comfortably maintain 150 stable relationships. Proponents assert that numbers larger than this generally require more restrictive rules, laws, and enforced norms to maintain a stable, cohesive group. It has been proposed to lie between 100 and 250, with a commonly used value of 150. Dunbar's number states the number of people one knows and keeps social contact with, and it does not include the number of people known personally with a ceased social relationship, nor people just generally known with a lack of persistent social relationship, a number which might be much higher and likely depends on long-term memory size.

Dunbar theorized that "this limit is a direct function of relative neocortex size, and that this in turn limits group size ... the limit imposed by neocortical processing capacity is simply on the number of individuals with whom a stable inter-personal relationship can be maintained."
There is an interesting article in The New Yorker, The Limits of Friendship by Maria Konnikova which explores the implication of the Dunbar Number in the world of hyperconnectedness and social media.
There’s no question, Dunbar agrees, that networks like Facebook are changing the nature of human interaction. “What Facebook does and why it’s been so successful in so many ways is it allows you to keep track of people who would otherwise effectively disappear,” he said. But one of the things that keeps face-to-face friendships strong is the nature of shared experience: you laugh together; you dance together; you gape at the hot-dog eaters on Coney Island together. We do have a social-media equivalent—sharing, liking, knowing that all of your friends have looked at the same cat video on YouTube as you did—but it lacks the synchronicity of shared experience. It’s like a comedy that you watch by yourself: you won’t laugh as loudly or as often, even if you’re fully aware that all your friends think it’s hysterical. We’ve seen the same movie, but we can’t bond over it in the same way.
As always, there are constraints and tradeoffs.
With social media, we can easily keep up with the lives and interests of far more than a hundred and fifty people. But without investing the face-to-face time, we lack deeper connections to them, and the time we invest in superficial relationships comes at the expense of more profound ones. We may widen our network to two, three, or four hundred people that we see as friends, not just acquaintances, but keeping up an actual friendship requires resources. “The amount of social capital you have is pretty fixed,” Dunbar said. “It involves time investment. If you garner connections with more people, you end up distributing your fixed amount of social capital more thinly so the average capital per person is lower.” If we’re busy putting in the effort, however minimal, to “like” and comment and interact with an ever-widening network, we have less time and capacity left for our closer groups. Traditionally, it’s a sixty-forty split of attention: we spend sixty per cent of our time with our core groups of fifty, fifteen, and five, and forty with the larger spheres. Social networks may be growing our base, and, in the process, reversing that balance.
There is interesting speculation about an aspect of socialization which puts a constrant on effective social media:
On an even deeper level, there may be a physiological aspect of friendship that virtual connections can never replace. This wouldn’t surprise Dunbar, who discovered his number when he was studying the social bonding that occurs among primates through grooming. Over the past few years, Dunbar and his colleagues have been looking at the importance of touch in sparking the sort of neurological and physiological responses that, in turn, lead to bonding and friendship. “We underestimate how important touch is in the social world,” he said. With a light brush on the shoulder, a pat, or a squeeze of the arm or hand, we can communicate a deeper bond than through speaking alone. “Words are easy. But the way someone touches you, even casually, tells you more about what they’re thinking of you.”
An interestingly speculative piece with many implications.

I wonder if this latter point regarding tactile sensations and the social dimension might not be in some way connected with reading. E-books have entered our cognitive environment and they are useful in their context, which tends to vary by person. They have not displaced physical books and physical books appear to be the first order of choice for most readers. I wonder if there are not perhaps two mechanisms related to that. 1) The sensory recollection of the physicality of reading with a loved parent, and 2) the tactile sense of paper, covers, the smell, etc. that is in some way reinforcing.

Saturday, February 13, 2016

STEM, STEAM, et al

Mulling recently about the focus in education on STEM. That then led to a train of thought about those who keep insisting that Arts should be included in Science, Technology, Engineering, Maths. I understand not wanting to be left out but the effort to advance STEAM has always struck me as chimerical. Arts are undoubtedly important but they are not of a like nature with STEM.

But why that instinctive response?

That led to this consideration as each of these categories relate to education.
STEM - The transfer of a body of knowledge.

Humanities - The transfer of a body of interpretations.

Arts - The transfer of a body of techniques.

Friday, February 12, 2016

Motivations count

I am glad people are beginning to focus on the size of the prison population as something that needs to be addressed. While I wish that there were low hanging fruit to get the numbers down, I suspect it is going to be much harder than is envisioned. In many states, it is very hard, with plea agreements, and non-incarceration punishments, to actually get into prison in the first place. Those who do get there tend to be the most persistent of recidivists.

The root of my concern is that reformers treat this as an issue of numbers rather than of human behavior. These people aren't in prison by accident. They did many dreadful things to get there. The root issue is their capabilities, values and behaviors. Without fixing those issues, simply releasing them back into the general population will likely have little positive effect and quite likely some "unexpected" negative outcomes.

Nor is everyone approaching prison population reduction with the cleanest of motives either.

From When will mass incarceration end?, America fact of the day by Tyler Cowen.
Three states stand out for making significant cuts in their prison populations in the past decade: New York (19 percent), California (17 percent), and New Jersey (17 percent). The reductions in New York and New Jersey have been in part a function of reduced crime levels, but also changes in policy and practice designed to reduce the number of lower-level drug offenders and parole violators in prison. But the pace of reductions in most other states has been quite modest. Moreover, 22 states still subscribed to an outdated model of prisoner expansion in 2012.
I don't think you have to be unduly cynical to note that the three states with the largest prison population reductions are also three of the states with the most parlous state finances.

In the worst case scenario, felons are pawns in a financial budget balancing game. Pawns who will be sacrificed to political expediency. Politicians and bureaucrats release the felons in order to balance the budget. Felons, with no expensive support or other militating strategies to change their capabilities, values and behaviors, repeat their prior patterns of behavior and end up back in prison. The budget remains unbalanced, citizens will have been victims of crime that could and should have been prevented. Felons will become ever more mired in their dysfunctional state of low capabilities, poor values and bad behaviors. The citizenry's perspective that politicians and government cannot be trusted will be further reinforced.

None of this is good.

Thursday, February 11, 2016

Hard to accept that these imbeciles represent the people in our government.

One of the ancient concerns about democracy is the capacity for majoritarian emotionality to get carried away leading to expropriations, human rights abuses, and atrocities. Our Founding Fathers sought to contain the monster of majoritarian emotionality by seeking to constrain government while leaving it the capacity to act in slow, measured fashion. By dividing power between three branches (executive, legislative, and judicial) and by instituting three layers of sovereign government (local, state and federal) they sought to constrain then current and future, unanticipated BIGS. Big government, big business, big labor, big religion, big mob, etc.

Human nature being what it is, even the best designed systems are prey to persistent attacks. My concern in recent years has been the increasing emotionalism of debate and the totalitarian desire to impose outcomes rather than obey the law.

This has taken many forms. There is the simple partisan abuse of power as demonstrated by the District Attorney in Madison, Wisconsin in the still unfolding John Doe scandal where the DA used the coercive power of the state to go on an unfounded fishing expedition against political opponents and attempted to cover it up by again using the coercive power of government through a gag order to prevent the victims from speaking to the press of the crime being committed against them by the DA.

There was the Duke University Scandal where the local District Attorney, seeking to curry favor with the local electorate, went after the Lacrosse team with virtually no evidence that a crime had been committed and then, as time passed, increasing evidence that in fact all charges had been false. The DA dug himself into a deeper hole by obstructing justice by hiding the refuting evidence. The debacle was exacerbated by the Gender and Ethnic studies professors at Duke wanting to punish white athletes simply for being white athletes rather than for actually having committed a crime.

This was followed by the George Zimmerman trial where all the evidence was supportive of Zimmerman's account and the DA was unable to even construct a coherent alternative account.

In all these cases, the media, select politicians, and certain segments of the academy have sought to circumvent the law in order to exact punishment on the innocent.

The more egregious example, to me, has been Harry Reed, former Senate Leader, who seems to have taken a manic interest in the Koch brothers that seems to extend beyond even ideology. They are libertarians and support all sorts of issues consonant with Reed's beliefs such as gay marriage. None-the-less, Reed has taken to using his platform as a US Senator to conduct a campaign of harassment against them by spreading lies and rumors. A US Senator using his position of governmental coercive power to campaign against private citizens who have committed no crime other than to incur his dislike. That is not how our democracy is supposed to work.

For those of us who believe all citizens should be impartially subject to the same law, these mob like show trials are concerning, particularly when, as is often the case, no law has been broken or simply some regulatory fig leaf to shield the coercion that is actually being exercised.

I have paid little attention to the most recent media storm regarding some pharmaceutical CEO who incurred social media and mainstream media aprobrium by making an unpopular, but legal, decision to substantially raise prices on a drug. I am still not paying attention other than to note this useful observation from Everyone Hates Martin Shkreli. Everyone Is Missing the Point by Kelefa Sanneh. Shkreli is the targeted CEO and being interrogated by a Senate committee. Brafman is his lawyer counselling him assert his right to not respond.
The questioning continued this way, with Shkreli sometimes fidgeting, sometimes smiling, and sometimes furrowing his eyebrows, as if he couldn’t believe he had to sit through something so ridiculous. Brafman later explained that his client was suffering from a surfeit of “nervous energy,” but Shkreli himself provided a different account of his state of mind, via Twitter: “Hard to accept that these imbeciles represent the people in our government.”

No one, least of all Shkreli, should be surprised that Thursday’s performance inspired a new round of Shkreli-bashing. Perhaps the most eager participant was Jake Tapper, of CNN, who criticized Shkreli’s “smirky smugness” and added some startlingly violent commentary: “I’m sure there are many ailing individuals out there who might like to remove Shkreli’s smile with the business end of a shovel.”

But was Shkreli’s performance actually more objectionable than that of the legislators who were performing alongside him? Elijah Cummings, of Maryland, is the ranking Democrat on the committee, and he used his allotted time to deliver a scolding. “Somebody’s paying for these drugs, and it’s the taxpayers that end up paying for some of them,” he said. “Those are our constituents.” In fact, it’s hard to figure out exactly who is paying what for Daraprim. Shkreli and Turing have claimed that hospitals and insurance companies will pay, while patients who can’t afford it will get a discount, or get it for free. And Nancy Retzlaff, Turing’s chief commercial officer, told the committee about her company’s efforts to get the drug to people who can’t afford it. The arrangement she described sounded like a hodge-podge, an ungainly combination of dizzyingly high prices, mysterious corporate bargaining, and occasional charitable acts—which is to say, it sounded not so much different from the rest of our medical system.

Even so, Cummings acted as if Shkreli were the only thing preventing a broken system from being fixed. “I know you’re smiling, but I’m very serious, sir,” he said. “The way I see it, you can go down in history as the poster boy for greedy drug-company executives, or you can change the system—yeah, you.” Cummings has been in Congress since 1996, and he is a firm believer in the power of government to improve industry through regulation. And yet now he was begging the former C.E.O. of a relatively minor pharmaceutical company to “change the system”? It seemed like an act of abdication.

The Republican-led committee was no more impressive. As if to establish that Turing was unnecessarily profitable, the committee released documents showing that the company had thrown a lavish party—fireworks included—and given some executives six-figure raises. (If this now counts as corporate behavior worthy of oversight and reform, the committee may soon find its schedule overbooked.) And then there was John Mica, a Republican from Florida, who has vowed to “keep the government out of patients’ sick beds.” Notwithstanding his skepticism of government intervention, he expressed alarm that some drug prices have “skyrocketed.” Even more than his colleagues, he seemed taken aback by the star witness’s recalcitrance, as if he couldn’t fathom why a private citizen wouldn’t be more deferential to his government—at one point, he threatened to move to hold Shkreli in contempt.

The Daraprim saga has as much to do with the Food and Drug Administration as with Shkreli: although the drug’s patent expired in the nineteen-fifties, the F.D.A. certification process for generic drugs is gruelling enough that, for the moment, whoever owns Daraprim has a virtual monopoly in America. (Overseas, it is much cheaper.) One of the witnesses on Thursday was Janet Woodcock, an F.D.A. official in charge of drug evaluation. Mica asked her about reports that a number of drugs had doubled or quadrupled in price in recent years. Woodcock said, “Congress has not really vested any authority for the F.D.A. over pricing, so we do not follow that.” If Mica wants to lower drug prices by encouraging competition, then he should concentrate on changing the regulatory process. And he should be aware that his plan will require more medical entrepreneurs, not fewer.

One of the strangest things about the anti-Shkreli argument is that it asks us to be shocked that a medical executive is motivated by profit. And one of the strangest things about Shkreli himself is that he doesn’t seem to be motivated by profit—at least, not entirely. Last fall, Derek Lowe, a chemist and blogger affiliated with Science, criticized Shkreli’s plan to raise prices as a “terrible idea,” not least because such an ostentatious plan posed “a serious risk of bringing the entire pricing structure of the industry under much heavier scrutiny and regulation.” He called on the pharmaceutical industry to denounce Shkreli as a means of protecting its own business model; from an economic point of view, Shkreli’s strategy seemed self-defeating. At least one person close to Shkreli seems to have agreed. One of the most revealing documents uncovered by the committee showed an unnamed executive imploring him not to raise the price of Daraprim again, saying that the risk of another media firestorm outweighed the benefit. “Investors just don’t like this stuff,” the e-mail said. Shkreli’s response was coolly noncommittal: “We can wait a few months for sure.”

A truly greedy executive would keep a much lower profile than Shkreli: there would be no headline-grabbing exponential price hikes, just boring but reliable ticks upward; no interviews, no tweeting, and absolutely no hip-hop feuds. A truly greedy executive would stay more or less anonymous. (How many other pharmaceutical C.E.O.s can you name?) But Shkreli seems intent on proving a point about money and medicine, and you don’t have to agree with his assessment in order to appreciate the service he has done us all. By showing what is legal, he has helped us to think about what we might want to change, and what we might need to learn to live with.

Most of our Presidential candidates claim to disdain Washington politicians, but, on Thursday, Shkreli put that disdain into practice—and helped illustrate, to anyone paying attention, why it is so richly deserved. He is candid even when candor doesn’t pay. (Can there be any doubt that Hillary Clinton, after her own recent appearance before Gowdy and some of his colleagues, would have loved to send a tweet like Shkreli’s?) Last fall, Trump said that Shkreli “looks like a spoiled brat”; in fact, he is the son of a doorman, born to parents who emigrated from Albania. Look at him now! True, he has those indictments to worry about. But he is also a self-made celebrity, thanks to a business plan that makes it harder for us to ignore the incoherence and inefficiency of our medical industry. He rolls his eyes at members of Congress, he carries on thoughtful conversations with random Internet commenters, and, unlike most of our public figures, he may never learn the arts of pandering and grovelling. He is the American Dream, a rude reminder of the spirit that makes this country great, or at any rate exceptional. Shkreli for President! If voters in New Hampshire are truly intent on sending a message to the Washington establishment they claim to hate, they could—and probably will—do a lot worse.

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

It is what matters most to to most people for most of the time

From Near A Thousand Tables: A History of Food by Felipe Fernandez-Armesto.
The great press baron Lord Northcliffe used to tell his journalists that four subjects could be relied on for abiding public interest: crime, love, money, and food. Only the last of these is fundamental and universal. Crime is a minority interest, even in the worst-regulated societies. It is possible to imagine an economy without money and reproduction without love but not life without food. Food, moreover, has a good claim to be considered the world's most important subject. It is what matters most to to most people for most of the time.
All true. And an extreme example of the Paradox of Value or, more strikingly, the Diamond-Water paradox.

Tuesday, February 9, 2016

The attempt to make heaven on earth invariably produces hell.

From Karl Popper, Vol. 2, Ch. 24 "Oracular Philosophy and the Revolt against Reason"
The attempt to make heaven on earth invariably produces hell. It leads to intolerance. It leads to religious wars, and to the saving of souls through the inquisition. And it is, I believe, based on a complete misunderstanding of our moral duties. It is our duty to help those who need help; but it cannot be our duty to make others happy, since this does not depend on us, and since it would only too often mean intruding on the privacy of those towards whom we have such amiable intentions.


Monday, February 8, 2016

Talent hits a target no one else can hit. Genius hits a target no one else can see.

From the comments section of Unemployment: The All-but-Certain Fate of Too Many Poor Black Boys by Gillian B. White.

Regrettably the article itself is anodyne post-modernist social justice virtue signalling clap-trap. The author starts by asserting the well refuted Marxian deterministic liturgy that individuals' futures are predetermined by their poverty, race, etc. rather than by the much more demonstrable causal explanation of capabilities, values and behaviors.
Study after study has proven that when children are sequestered in neighborhoods of concentrated poverty, their educational and economic opportunities are stunted, creating enduring cycles of poverty.

But a new paper, written by a team of researchers led by the Stanford economist Raj Chetty, indicates that these findings have yet another critical element: Concentrated poverty can be significantly more detrimental to young boys than to young girls.

In America it’s generally been true that men are more likely to be employed than women. According to the most current data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, even as women have entered the workforce in greater numbers, men’s labor-force participation rate is around 69 percent, while women’s is around 57 percent. This division in the labor force holds among middle- and upper-income families, but Chetty and his fellow researchers find that when poor kids become adults, a reverse gender-employment gap appears, with poor boys more likely than poor girls to become unemployed adults.
The fact of the gender reversal is well known already but it is useful to have it quantified.

The intellectual crime committed by these ideology motivated research papers is that they take us down the wrong policy roads. In this case, the researchers are pre-committed (as evidenced in their past research) to believe that segregation is the root cause of all these poor life outcomes when in fact the causal mechanisms are abilities, values and behaviors.
And for another, it’s a paper that, like a lot of Chetty’s previous research, strongly suggests that as long as residential segregation continues, poor black children have little hope of having a life better than their parents.
The solution for the postmodernist totalitarians is to strip away rights of association from the population and impose choices made by the unelected enlightened. It is a pathway to misery trodden many times in many countries and has never, not once, led to the imagined desirable outcomes that the intellectual totalitarians imagine. Human nature and reality always get in the way.

But I have gotten distracted by the nonsense. What interested me was a quotation from Arthur Schopenhauer in the comments that I found interesting.
Talent hits a target no one else can hit. Genius hits a target no one else can see.


UPDATE: I blog primarily to keep track of items that I find interesting, to think through issues out loud (as it were), and to make connections between ideas I might not have seen as connected. In doing so, I have found over the years that it has been a good mechanism for also seeing patterns of communication in my own expression.

This is one of those instances. This post is too harsh. It isn't wrong. Totalitarian utopianism and neo-marxian determinism are some of the most insidious habits of mind among some of our contemporary journalists. Though perhaps well intended, their sloppy thinking, both in terms of failing to use logic and in terms of failing to research that about which they are opining, can lead to disastrously bad policy recommendations. As bad, it delays focusing on actual real causes of undesirable conditions. White fully deserves castigation for propagating a naive and long discredited idea (taking people out of poor neighborhoods will make them no longer poor). Frustration, though, is no justification for harshness.

Sunday, February 7, 2016

YA Classics using objective data

Some time ago, someone posted on one of the book forums to which I belong, a request for a list of classic teen literature. This got me to mulling, particularly as I was aware of a couple of interesting new data sets that might be helpful.

While the request seems simple, it needs to be disambiguated and made objective. What do we mean by "classic," what do we mean by "young adult," and what does it mean to "read" a book. How can we measure this? We can't go by publisher hype. Teachers tend to be biased towards texts geared towards the college bound. Copies sold and copies checked out of a library do not necessarily reflect copies read.

I would argue that what we should be interested in are the books young adults are actually reading and which they deem to be meaningful and influential to them over reaches of time. So let's start putting some parameters around that concept.

First, what do we mean by Young Adult (YA)? YA is a genre in publishing. That seems straight-forward enough. The problem is that most publisher research indicates that 60-80% of the readership are in fact adult women. So let's throw that out. Some people use bounds more associated with school grades such as fifth, seventh or ninth grade as beginning points and others prefer to limit to high school completion or the rounded number of age 20. I propose that YA is the age category covering the decade between 12-21 years old. I.e just as most approach all the physical and cognitive changes associated with maturity (12) and then the closing point when individuals are accorded all the benefits and responsibilities of full adulthood (21) and when virtually all the physical and neurological changes associated with maturity are substantially complete.

These are the most tumultuous years, with greatest variability and span of change in reading ability, physical maturity, mental maturity, degree of socialization and acculturalization, academic achievement, etc. No other decade of life is quite like it, thank goodness. Young adults at the lower bounds will still reach back into the ease and simplicity of picture books and chapter books. Young adults at the upper bound will stretch into harder core texts in sciences, philosophy, and fields beyond the entertainment of storytelling in written form. All in that decade between 12 and 12.

So that's the age group. What do we mean by someone having read something? Books, obviously. What about plays and poems? What about short stories?What about nonfiction? Even with books, do we mean being aware of the book, having read at least a chapter, having read excerpts, having had it assigned in class? Do we only count those books which have been read cover-to-cover? A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking is notorious as a book that everyone bought but virtually no one read. A seventeen year old who is intensely interested in biology reads three or four chapters of Charles Darwin's Origin of Species. Has she "read" The Origin of Species? Does it make a difference to what is being counted if we focus only on what is assigned versus what is electively read?

All these are fair and knotty issues. I am going to go with any book which a child between 12-21 has some form of meaningful engagement (usually revealed in conversation or recollection when older), principally through having read the book or portions of the book. I am not excluding books that might have been skimmed and which might have been supplemented via movies, stage productions, graphical renditions, and abridged editions.

Finally - what do we mean by classic? There are several issues tied up in this bundle. You might argue it is the book that is most read by the most members in a particular cohort. For example, each year there are some 4 million youth who turn 21. We might say that a classic is a book read by X% of that cohort. The challenge here is that many children are literate and don't elect to read at all or read very little. In addition, a large percentage of reading time, particularly as they get older, are books outside the traditional canon, primarily nonfiction. For example, With the Old Breed is a classic war book and it is read by a material number of YA youth, primarily boys. Is that therefore a YA classic? I would argue no because it is not read by a large enough population and too narrowly in terms of demographics.

It is hard to get a read on what represents the penetration ceiling for a book within an age cohort. From a variety of sources and studies, I suspect that it is very rare for any book to have been read by more than 10% of an age cohort by the time they turn 21. The numbers suggest that there is much greater penetration for picture books. Something like 50-75% will have had Dr. Seuss or Margaret Wise Brown read to them as a child, but at most 10% of them will have actually read Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird even though it is a widely assigned classic.

There is also a very real class issue in designating classic. Classic for whom? The 30% that go on to college or for the 100% of the age cohort? For example, there is a reasonable chance that a good portion of those destined for college will have read some of Dante's Inferno but I suspect that a very low percentage of the other 70% would even have much awareness of it.

There are other issues. For example, Toni Morrison's Beloved is regarded as a classic in African-American literature and it is frequently assigned in high school. But how many actually read it and are engaged by it. It does not show up in many surveys of books that were important to people.

I am going with four approaches as to what constitutes a classic - 1) It is widely acknowledged as a classic, 2) It is widely read within age cohorts across time, 3) It is of merit and interest beyond the US, and 4) It is widely recognized even if only a small percentage may have actually read it in its entirety. An example of the latter might be Philip K. Dick's Total Recall - a classic of science fiction literature. It might have only been read by 5% of 21 year olds (basically anyone interested in science fiction) but it is also rendered in two block buster movies over the past twenty years making it widely recognized.

If these are the parameters, how do we construct such a list. No one measures which books YA actually read. I have drawn on multiple sources. The two primary sources are the Pantheon 1.0 database and The Open Syllabus Project. Pantheon gives you all authors who have Wikipedia entries in at least 25 languages (thus indicating that the authors are of interest to a wide range of people/cultures). Pantheon also gives you a measure of intensity of interest over time (page views within a time period).

Open Syllabus lets you know which books are most assigned for reading to the 30% of YA who go on to college.

Supplementary sources include a database I have built compiling library recommendations as well as public surveys of books people mention as favorites from their youth, Renaissance Learning's annual report of the top twenty most popular books read in each grade (their program being in some 25% of schools), Goodreads, and Library Thing. Renaissance Learning is interesting because it gives insight to differences in reading preferences between the genders. It also, to some small degree, corrects for the overwhelming class bias towards those who are college bound.

Pantheon only gives you authors so you have to make an educated guess as to which of the authors' works are most read by YA. In most instances this is pretty clear but there are a few judgment calls. I have checked these calls against popularity rankings in Good Reads and Librarything.

I have taken the HPI measure (a measure of balanced interest over time) from Pantheon and sorted from high to low and given the titles their ordinal rankings. Similarly, I sorted the Open Syllabus candidates from high to low, based on the number of syllabi in which they are assigned. For example, in college, Mary Shelley is the most frequently assigned author, cited in 2,710 syllabi, followed by Machiavelli, Shakespeare and Homer. Their ordinal rankings are, respectively, 1,2,3,and 4.

Pantheon and Open Syllabus diverge significantly from one another in ordinal ranking. Interestingly, if you average the two ordinal ranks, you end up with a list that likely comes closer to representing a whole population list (as opposed to only that which is of interest in college.)

Some caveats. I included several authors about whom I am dubious as to really how widely they are read by YA, even if they are well regarded among adults. Examples include Simone de Beauvoir's Second Sex, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Toni Morrison, and others. Another caveat is that, despite my best efforts, this list still appears to me to be strongly biased towards the reading interests of the 30% who go on to college. Finally, the 25 languages bar filters out a lot of writers who are definitely in the American YA canon of classics such as Laura Ingalls, Wilder, Mary Norton, Katherine Paterson, E.B. White, Lois Lowry, Louis Sachar, Richard and Florence Atwater, Robert C. O’Brien, Jean Craighead George, Norton Juster, Mildred D. Taylor, Christopher Paul Curtis, Madeleine L’Engle. I was quite surprised by the number of American classics which apparently are not as well engaged with in other places as I would have thought.

Details: In Pantheon 1.0 there are 954 authors overall from some 50 or so countries and right back to Homer and that era. While many of these might be globally consequential, many of them are unknown in the US or known only to specialists, or did not write books likely to be read by YA. Examples: Francois Rabelais, Juvenal, Milan Kundera, Lope de Vega, etc.

There are 166 from the Pantheon list who have written books that are read or assigned with some frequency in the US. Of those, 17% are female authors, right in the range of representation normally seen (15-30%). 58% are foreign born. 27% were by authors born after 1900 (very roughly, "modern"). 8% are People of Color.

The final caveat. These are all proxies for the reality that we do not know which books YA actually read and value. This list is arrived at more rigorously and with better objective data than most but it is still just a proxy. And, as noted earlier, it omits many authors apparently less well known outside the US.

Apologies for the display. Beyond my HTML skills under time constraints. The listing is: Author, Title, HPI Ordinal Rank (from Pantheon), College Syllabus Ordinal Rank, and Overall Ordinal Rank.
William Shakespeare Romeo & Juliet 2 3 1
Homer Odyssey 1 4 2
Mark Twain Tom Sawyer 15 11 3
Oscar Wilde Picture of Dorian Gray 6 27 4
Franz Kafka The Metamorphosis 22 17 5
Jane Austen Pride and Prejudice 30 13 6
Geoffrey Chaucer The Canterbury Tales 39 6 7
Daniel Defoe Robinson Crusoe 19 30 8
Jonathan Swift Gulliver's Travels 29 21 9
Joseph Conrad Heart of Darkness 46 5 10
Simone de Beauvoir The Second Sex 26 25 11
Charles Dickens A Tale of Two Cities 32 20 12
George Orwell 1984 13 39 13
Edgar Allan Poe Tell Tale Heart 10 43 14
Ernest Hemingway The Old Man and the Sea 16 42 15
Henry David Thoreau Walden Pond 55 8 16
Aldous Huxley Brave New World 50 14 17
William Faulkner The Sound and The Fury 41 28 18
Arthur Conan Doyle The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 23 47 19
Dante Alighieri Inferno 3 68 20
T. S. Eliot The Waste Land 56 16 21
Mary Shelley Frankenstein 73 1 22
Leo Tolstoy Anna Karenina 9 65 23
Erich Maria Remarque All Quiet on the Western Front 44 32 24
Aesop Fables 4 72 25
Walt Whitman Leaves of Grass 51 26 26
Albert Camus The Stranger 37 40 27
John Steinbeck The Pearl 49 29 28
J. R. R. Tolkien Lord of the Rings 31 48 29
Vladimir Vladimirovich Nabokov Lolita 47 46 30
F. Scott Fitzgerald The Great Gatsby 85 9 31
Henry James The Turn of the Screw 63 34 32
Lewis Carroll Alice in Wonderland 36 61 33
Jack Kerouac On The Road 62 36 34
Arthur Miller The Crucible 77 23 35
Fyodor Dostoyevsky Crime and Punishment 8 94 36
Jack London The Call of the Wild 28 75 37
Thomas Paine Common Sense 89 15 38
Umberto Eco The Name of the Rose 27 78 39
Isaac Asimov Foundation 21 86 40
Victor Hugo Les Miserables 5 102 41
Hans Christian Andersen Fairy Tales 17 92 42
Charlotte Bronte Jane Eyre 59 52 43
Emily Bronte Wuthering Heights 45 66 44
Nathaniel Hawthorne The Scarlet Letter 94 18 45
Tennessee Williams A Streetcar Named Desire 78 35 46
William Golding Lord of the Flies 67 49 47
Alexandre Dumas The Count of Monte Cristo 58 59 48
Toni Morrison Beloved 109 10 49
Bram Stoker Dracula 97 22 50
Robert Louis Stevenson Treasure Island 88 37 51
Samuel Taylor Coleridge The Rime of the Ancient Mariner 82 44 52
Stephen King Carrie 20 108 53
Philip K. Dick Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? 72 58 54
Suzanne Collins The Hunger Games 24 110 55
Herman Melville Moby-Dick 118 19 56
H. G. Wells The Time Machine 90 50 57
Elie Wiesel Night 117 24 58
Raymond Chandler The Big Sleep 70 71 59
Saul Bellow The Adventures of Augie March 79 63 60
C. S. Lewis The Chronicles of Narnia 69 73 61
Miguel de Cervantes Don Quixotes 11 131 62
Rudyard Kipling The Jungle Book 38 105 63
J. D. Salinger The Catcher in the Rye 113 31 64
Italo Calvino If On A Winter's Night a Traveller 76 69 65
E.T.A. Hoffmann The Nutcracker 52 96 66
Gabriel García Márquez One Hundred Years of Solitude 18 130 67
Agatha Christie And Then There Were None 25 124 68
Alexandre Dumas The Count of Monte Cristo 91 60 69
Jules Verne Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea 35 117 70
Guy de Maupassant Collected Stories 43 111 71
Thomas Pynchon Gravity's Rainbow 114 41 72
Philip Roth Portnoy's Complaint 98 57 73
Walter Scott Ivanhoe 40 115 74
Charles Perrault Mother Goose 33 122 75
Paulo Coelho The Alchemist 48 109 76
Chinua Achebe Things Fall Apart 152 7 77
Boris Pasternak Doctor Zhivago 54 106 78
James Fenimore Cooper Last of the Mohicans 101 62 79
Louisa May Alcott Little Women 111 54 80
Frank Herbert Dune 81 84 81
Thomas Mann Death in Venice 14 152 82
E. M. Forster A Room With A View 122 45 83
Washington Irving The Legend of Sleepy Hollow 116 51 84
Niccolò Machiavelli The Prince 166 2 85
Ralph Ellison The Invisible Man 156 12 86
Ray Bradbury Fahrenheit 451 115 56 87
Anthony Burgess A Clockwork Orange 108 64 88
Thomas Hardy Tess of the D'Urbervilles  105 67 89
D. H. Lawrence Lady Chatterley's Lover 96 77 90
Nostradamus Prophresies 7 166 91
Dale Carnegie How to Win Friends and Influence People 87 87 92
Ambrose Bierce An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge 95 82 93
Khalil Gibran The Prophet 57 120 94
Hermann Hesse Siddhartha 12 165 95
Alice Walker The Color Purple 148 33 96
Pearl S. Buck The Good Earth 74 107 97
Harper Lee To Kill a Mockingbird 144 38 98
Anne Rice Interview With The Vampire 64 118 99
Mario Puzo The Godfather 68 116 100
Haruki Murakami Kafka on the Shore 65 119 10
Antoine de Saint-Exupery The Little Prince 42 142 102
Ayn Rand Atlas Shrugged 106 80 103
Georges Simenon Maigret 61 127 104
Roald Dahl Best Of Roald Dahl 60 129 105
Dashiell Hammett The Maltese Falcon 107 83 106
William S. Burroughs Naked Lunch 104 88 107
Allen Ginsberg Howl and other Poems 83 112 108
Astrid Lindgren Pippi Longstocking 34 161 109
Truman Capote In Cold Blood 53 146 110
Lucy Maud Montgomery Anne of Green Gables 102 99 111
Kurt Vonnegut Slaughterhouse-Five 75 126 112
Frances Hodgson Burnett A Little Princess 124 79 113
Stephen Crane The Red Badge of Courage 151 53 114
Dan Brown The Da Vinci Code 132 74 115
Thomas Malory King Arthur 125 81 116
Margaret Mitchell Gone With the Wind 119 90 117
Maya Angelou I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings 155 55 118
Ursula K. Le Guin A Wizard of Earthsea 112 100 119
Carlos Castaneda The Teachings of Don Juan: A Yaqui Way of Knowledge 71 141 120
L. Frank Baum The Wonderful Wizard of Oz 147 70 121
J. M. Barrie Peter Pan 134 85 122
Cormac McCarthy The Road 127 93 123
Robert A. Heinlein Stranger in a Strange Land 100 121 124
Arthur C. Clarke 2001: A Space Odyssey 99 123 125
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich  66 157 126
Johanna Spyri Heidi 92 132 127
O. Henry The Gift of the Magi 93 133 128
Daphne du Maurier Rebecca 129 98 129
Margaret Atwood The Handmaid's Tale 133 95 130
Thornton Wilder The Bridge of San Luis Rey 143 91 131
Philip Pullman The Golden Compass 137 97 132
Khaled Hosseini The Kite Runner 159 76 133
Chuck Palahniuk Invisible Monsters 150 89 134
Terry Pratchett The Color of Magic 86 153 135
Graham Greene The Quiet American 80 162 136
Ian Fleming Casino Royale 103 143 137
Karen Blixen Out of Africa 84 163 138
Evelyn Waugh Brideshead Revisited 145 103 139
Jacob Grimm Fairy Tales 110 140 140
Richard Bach Jonathan Livingston Seagull 123 128 141
Edgar Rice Burroughs Tarzan 141 114 142
Harriet Beecher Stowe Uncle Tom's Cabin 121 137 143
Neil Gaiman American Gods 160 101 144
Bill Bryson A Short History of Nearly Everything 157 104 145
J. K. Rowling Harry Potter 138 125 146
Patricia Highsmith Strangers on a Train 131 134 147
Michael Crichton Jurassic Park 136 136 148
Robert Ludlum The Bourne Identity 120 154 149
Hunter S. Thompson Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas 130 145 150
Suzanne Collins The Hunger Games 164 113 151
Joseph Heller Catch-22 135 144 152
Dean Koontz Odd Thomas 126 155 153
J. G. Ballard ConcretE Island 146 138 154
Wilhelm Grimm Fairy Tales 128 160 155
George R. R. Martin A Song of Fire and Ice 138 151 156
Ken Kesey One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest  140 150 157
Eoin Colfer Artemis Fowl 162 135 158
Douglas Adams Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy 149 148 159
H. Rider Haggard King Solomon's Mines 142 156 160
Stephenie Meyer Twilight 154 149 161
Christopher Paolini Eragon 165 139 162
Orson Scott Card Ender's Game 161 147 163
Alex Haley Roots 153 159 164
Cornelia Funke Inkheart 158 158 165
Rick Riordan The Lightning Thief 163 164 166