Tuesday, July 24, 2012

We are rich and blessed to have such young men

I saw this article (The Victims: Real movie heroes saved their sweethearts during Colo. ambush by Caitlin Gibbons) the other day but decided not to post about it. Too great a tragedy.
Three young men are being hailed as heroes for their old-fashioned chivalry and courage under fire in saving the lives of their girlfriends.

While using their bodies as shields, Matt McQuinn, 27, Jonathan Blunk, 26, and Alex Teves, 24, were killed in the worst mass shooting in US history.
Then my son, just returned from Philmont, sent me the following article, Boy Scouts use talents to aid scout leader at Philmont by Aric Mitchell, and I reconsidered.
Ric Cooper, a resident of Northwest Arkansas, felt the clutching at his chest too late to turn back on Trek 4 of the Philmont Boy Scout Camp near Cimarron, N.M.

All he could get out was the word “Jim,” and he was tumbling backwards.

“Jim,” because the second chaperone on this journey was Dr. Jim Hattabaugh, principal at Trinity Junior High School in Fort Smith and second of a required two adult chaperones on the trip.

Cooper didn’t have time to call out the names of the nine boys with him: Brian Boatright, Eric Boltuc, Joseph Boltuc, Eli Hattabaugh, Ian Hattabaugh, Cameron Mask, Matthew Schultz, Alex Sharum, and Joseph Smith.

He didn’t need it. Instantly, the members of Boy Scout Troop 3 sprung to action and did “exactly what needed to be done to save the man’s life,” Hattabaugh said.

Jim rushed to Cooper, who’d taken “a five-foot drop,” according to 17-year old Subiaco Academy student Joseph Boltuc, and began chest compressions.

Then, Jim’s son Eli, a 17-year old student of Fort Smith Southside High School, stepped in and “gave two breaths” followed by another set of 30 chest compressions. Halfway through, “he started gasping for air and came back,” Eli said.

Meanwhile, Mask, Smith, and Sharum, set up a tarp using “ropes, hiking sticks, stuff like that,” said Smith, a 15-year old student of Fort Smith Northside High School. Their goal: to keep Cooper safe from the raging July sun.

“We (Mask, Sharum, Smith) actually stuck together most of the time. The wind coming through the trees kept sounding like there were cars coming down the roads, so me and Cameron went down to see if there actually was,” said Smith.

Boatright, Eric, Ian, and Schultz, lit out for the Cyphers Mine base camp to report the emergency.

The four boys made the run after three hours on the trail carrying 45-pound backpacks on an uphill journey of 2,000 feet, Jim Hattabaugh added.

They had four miles in front of them starting from an altitude of 11,000 feet.
As a scout master, I am proud of these young men. But there is something more.

News is news but it isn't always the type of news we need or want.

These articles are a testament to what is too often overlooked. We get caught up in the minutiae of things to worry about. We anticipate decline. We bemoan the loss of social cohesion and spiral of negativity. There is plenty of misery and tragedy upon which we can fixate.

It is too easy to overlook that there are many, many young men and growing boys out there eager and able to do the right thing, in a split second, as best they can and no matter the cost. We should bring attention to them and celebrate them. That is news worth reading. We are rich and blessed to have such young men.

Jonathan Blunk, 26
Matt McQuinn, 27
Alex Teves, 24
Brian Boatright
Eric Boltuc, 14
Joseph Boltuc, 17
Eli Hattabaugh, 17
Ian Hattabaugh, 14
Cameron Mask, 17
Matthew Schultz, 16
Alex Sharum, 15
Joseph Smith, 15


Competence without comprehension

From ‘A Perfect and Beautiful Machine’: What Darwin’s Theory of Evolution Reveal About Artificial Intelligence by Daniel C. Dennett.
What Darwin and Turing had both discovered, in their different ways, was the existence of competence without comprehension. This inverted the deeply plausible assumption that comprehension is in fact the source of all advanced competence. Why, after all, do we insist on sending our children to school, and why do we frown on the old-fashioned methods of rote learning? We expect our children's growing competence to flow from their growing comprehension. The motto of modern education might be: "Comprehend in order to be competent." For us members of H. sapiens, this is almost always the right way to look at, and strive for, competence. I suspect that this much-loved principle of education is one of the primary motivators of skepticism about both evolution and its cousin in Turing's world, artificial intelligence. The very idea that mindless mechanicity can generate human-level -- or divine level! -- competence strikes many as philistine, repugnant, an insult to our minds, and the mind of God.
and later;
It was, indeed, a strange inversion of reasoning. To this day many people cannot get their heads around the unsettling idea that a purposeless, mindless process can crank away through the eons, generating ever more subtle, efficient, and complex organisms without having the slightest whiff of understanding of what it is doing.
Is this not a mirror of much of the current political discourse between the centralizers who wish to achieve outcomes through directed action and the laissez-faire people who trust to an uncontrolled process as long as it bounded within some moral or ethical code (as Adam Smith presupposed). Both world views have a logical basis but only one is frequently demonstrated in reality. Enthusiastic seekers of justice believe that it can be attained through sufficient intellectual artifice. Every utopia predicated on the intelligence and rationality of man (or some small cadre of thought leaders of men), though, seems to come crashing down, not before having wreaked terrible injustice and inflicted suffering far and wide. But all of it logical. It calls to mind Thomas Wolfe’s “the dark night of fascism is always descending in the United States and yet lands only in Europe.” There would seem to be a groundedness or pragmatism in the culture of the Anglosphere (or perhaps it is the attributes of agency, individualism and skepticism) which tends to forestall the worst excesses of scientific behaviorism and logical zeal.

In contrast, there are those believers in freedom and liberty who rely on the mysterious forces of dispersed individual decision-making, the chaos of the marketplace and the wisdom of crowds. Time and again, when exercised within some constraining moral or philosophical framework, the individual agent, market and the crowds end up delivering superior outcomes to those achieved by credentialed, cognitive, or inherited elites.

The markets and crowds deliver competence without comprehension while reason-based utopias seeking to achieve desired outcomes time and again founder on the human fallibilities of those deemed the best and the brightest and deliver up only failure and human misery.

It seems that the challenge is not to choose one or the other but to recognize the circumstances under which one may be more likely to yield success than the other, or really, how to blend a balance of the two for the particular situation. My guess is that the bedrock recipe is maximum liberty with a rare dash of occassional centralism.

Highfalutin but fun speculation.

Inattentional deafness, confirmation bias and lying

From Introducing "inattentional deafness" - the noisy gorilla that's missed by Christian Jarrett.

Inattentional Blindness and Inattentional Deafness would appear to be kissing cousins with the logical fallacy of confirmation bias.

I am currently involved in a neighorhood project to protect a nature preserve from being converted to a recreational hiking trail against the wishes of the neighbors. The advocacy group who are pushing the agenda appear to neighbors to be blatant liars in how they represent information neighbors have shared with them.

In faciliated sessions where the advocates are facilitators, neighbors will offer up a criticism of the project and the facilitator will record it on the flip chart as a positive comment. A neighbor will meet with an advocate and express opposition to the project and then the advocate will relay the conversation indicating that the neighbor was in support.

This comes across as blatant lying and misrepresentation.

A more charitable view is that the advocates are just so zealous that they suffer from confirmation bias. They are so convinced of the goodness of their project that they are incapable of comprehending alternate perspectives, a suspension of theory of mind. They hear only that which they expect or wish to hear.

What Inattentional Blindness and Inattentional Deafness suggest is that the problem might be even more deeply rooted. That the advocate is so focused on their own weltanschauung that they literally do not hear an alternate argument. It is not that they have heard the alternate argument and have cognitively screened out that which they did not wish to hear. Rather, they simply did not hear what they did not wish to hear.

An intriguing speculation. It goes a little bit against human nature to be quite that charitable but if we wish to think the best of our fellow man, that is one avenue to take.

Monday, July 23, 2012

Precise behavior can emerge from imprecise knowledge

From The Design of Everyday Things by Donald A. Norman, page 54.
It is easy to show the faulty nature of human knowledge and memory. A common classroom exercise in the United States demonstrates that students cannot recall the pairing of letters and numbers on their telephones. One of my graduate students found that when professional typists were given caps for typewriter keys, they could not arrange them in the proper configuration. American students dial telephones properly, and all those typists could type rapidly and accurately. Why the apparent discrepancy between the precision of behavior and the imprecision of knowledge? Because not all of the knowledge required for precise behavior has to be in the head. It can be distributed - partly in the head, partly in the world, and partly in the constraints of the world. Precise behavior can emerge from imprecise knowledge for four reasons.
1. Information is in the world. Much of the information a person needs to do a task can reside in the world. Behavior is determined by combining the information in memory (in the head) with that in the world.

2. Great precision is not required. Precision, accuracy, and completeness of knowledge are seldom required. Perfect behavior will result if the knowledge describes the information or behavior sufficiently to distinguish the correct choice from all others.

3. Natural constraints are present. The world restricts the allowed behaviors. The physical properties of objects constrain possible operations: the order in which parts can go together and the ways in which an object can be moved, picked up, or otherwise manipulated. Each object has physical features - projections, depressions, screwthreads, appendages - that limit its relationships to other objects, operations that can be performed to it, what can be attached to it, and so on.

4. Cultural constraints are present. In addition to natural, physical constraints, society has evolved numerous artificial conventions that govern acceptable social behavior. These cultural conventions have to be learned, but once learned they apply to a wide variety of circumstances.
Because of these natural and artificial constraints, the number of alternatives for any particular situation is reduced, as are the amount and specificity of knowledge required within human memory.
This seems to me linked in some fashion to the thoughts of Steven Johnson in his book Where Good Ideas Come From but also mentioned in his recent article, The Genius of the Tinkerer.
Evolution advances by taking available resources and cobbling them together to create new uses. The evolutionary theorist Francois Jacob captured this in his concept of evolution as a "tinkerer," not an engineer; our bodies are also works of bricolage, old parts strung together to form something radically new. "The tires-to-sandals principle works at all scales and times," Mr. Gould wrote, "permitting odd and unpredictable initiatives at any moment—to make nature as inventive as the cleverest person who ever pondered the potential of a junkyard in Nairobi."

You can see this process at work in the primordial innovation of life itself. Before life emerged on Earth, the planet was dominated by a handful of basic molecules: ammonia, methane, water, carbon dioxide, a smattering of amino acids and other simple organic compounds. Each of these molecules was capable of a finite series of transformations and exchanges with other molecules in the primordial soup: methane and oxygen recombining to form formaldehyde and water, for instance.

Think of all those initial molecules, and then imagine all the potential new combinations that they could form spontaneously, simply by colliding with each other (or perhaps prodded along by the extra energy of a propitious lightning strike). If you could play God and trigger all those combinations, you would end up with most of the building blocks of life: the proteins that form the boundaries of cells; sugar molecules crucial to the nucleic acids of our DNA. But you would not be able to trigger chemical reactions that would build a mosquito, or a sunflower, or a human brain. Formaldehyde is a first-order combination: You can create it directly from the molecules in the primordial soup. Creating a sunflower, however, relies on a whole series of subsequent innovations: chloroplasts to capture the sun's energy, vascular tissues to circulate resources through the plant, DNA molecules to pass on instructions to the next generation.

The scientist Stuart Kauffman has a suggestive name for the set of all those first-order combinations: "the adjacent possible." The phrase captures both the limits and the creative potential of change and innovation. In the case of prebiotic chemistry, the adjacent possible defines all those molecular reactions that were directly achievable in the primordial soup. Sunflowers and mosquitoes and brains exist outside that circle of possibility. The adjacent possible is a kind of shadow future, hovering on the edges of the present state of things, a map of all the ways in which the present can reinvent itself.

The strange and beautiful truth about the adjacent possible is that its boundaries grow as you explore them. Each new combination opens up the possibility of other new combinations. Think of it as a house that magically expands with each door you open. You begin in a room with four doors, each leading to a new room that you haven't visited yet. Once you open one of those doors and stroll into that room, three new doors appear, each leading to a brand-new room that you couldn't have reached from your original starting point. Keep opening new doors and eventually you'll have built a palace.

Basic fatty acids will naturally self-organize into spheres lined with a dual layer of molecules, very similar to the membranes that define the boundaries of modern cells. Once the fatty acids combine to form those bounded spheres, a new wing of the adjacent possible opens up, because those molecules implicitly create a fundamental division between the inside and outside of the sphere. This division is the very essence of a cell. Once you have an "inside," you can put things there: food, organelles, genetic code.

The march of cultural innovation follows the same combinatorial pattern: Johannes Gutenberg, for instance, took the older technology of the screw press, designed originally for making wine, and reconfigured it with metal type to invent the printing press.
And I would link these ideas with the idea that the structure and nature of a language can facilitate or retard the capacity to comprehend the world. I wonder whether the blossoming of innovation and productivity in the Classical Liberal world/Age of Enlightenment/Anglosphere was not in some way a function of the efficiency of the English language married to its amoeba-like tendency to absorb new words and concepts from other languages lending it not only efficiency and precision but also adjacent possibilities. The richer the population of disparate concepts, the greater the probability that there will be serendipitous leaps forward in productivity and conceptual discovery, precision, and exploitation.

Competence without comprehension (tomorrow) and precise behavior from imprecise knowledge. Paradoxes galore. Chesterton would have had something to say.

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Law of Fortuitous Reversals

Musings prompted by the serendipitous near simultaneous reading of How Moral Education Is Finding Its Way Back into America’s Schools by Christina Hoff Sommers, Dan Quayle Was Right by Barbara Dafoe Whitehead, and Two Classes, Divided by ‘I Do’ by Jason DeParle.

Most of our public speakers and pundits seem unable to keep two thoughts in their minds at a single time – that life can be understood both as a snapshot in time and as a process of continuity. Actions taken to further one’s goals in the here-and-now can work against one’s simultaneously held desires for the future. Likewise, all of the present can be sacrificed to the ends of some distant future that never arrives. Success is the wise balancing of those competing goals between present and future which occur in an environment rife with repeated and unexpected exogenous shocks; such shocks confounding our best laid plans.

Heuristics, knowledge and narrative structures feeding in to a sophisticated decision-making process helps us navigate the terrain of the present. Profound knowledge/wisdom helps us prioritize those present actions and goals so that they also support our future goals, all of which are contingent on productivity and which are based on survival and continuity.

Analytic knowledge, as a consequence of empiricism, the scientific method and the tradition of rationalism, has grown at an exponential rate. Narrative knowledge likewise, with the printing press, tradition of freedom and accelerating technology development (radio, telephone, internet, etc.), has also exploded. Yes there are still classics but there are literally hundreds of thousands of narratives new each year to which people can expose themselves. Heuristics, being knowledge accumulated through simple trial and error, is fairly static. Accumulated Profound knowledge (philosophy and religion) is, like heuristics, evolutionary in nature. An unexpected insight here, a variation there, slowly demonstrating their value by their capacity to help not just individuals but groups of individuals (cultures) to weather the constant and repeated exogenous shocks to win through survival and continuity.

So what are the elements of philosophy and religion which facilitate cultural survival and continuity? Ay, there’s the rub. And there’s the opportunity. We have spent two generations shying away from the brutal reality that some cultural constructs do a better job of facilitating productivity than others and some do a better job of integrating productivity with survival and continuity than others. It is no good simply getting richer, if in doing so, you lose your future.

Thoughts sparked by Christina Hoff Sommers in How Moral Education Is Finding Its Way Back into America’s Schools . Her argument has a greater tendency towards rhetoric over logic and evidence but I think she is addressing an important topic. What is overlooked is the challenge presented of trying to incorporate evidenced-based values (what values are associated with productivity, survival and continuity and what are the mechanisms by which those values achieve productivity, survival and continuity) into a heterogeneous society where some sub-cultures adhere to patterns of values and behavior which are deleterious to their long term well-being. It is not an easy question to answer, particularly when a disproportionate number of our intellectuals are wedded to overthrowing eternal varieties in pursuit of the bauble of cognitive celebrity for professing some untenable but novel proposition.

She ends on an optimistic note.
Social critics often refer to the Law of Unintended Consequences. According to this law, seemingly benign social or political changes often have unfortunate, even disastrous, side effects. Few romantic idealists of the 1920s and 1930s, for example, had any idea that applying utopian principles to real societies might cause their total degradation. Nor did anyone in the 1970s expect that applying Rousseau’s perspective to moral education would set children adrift, denying to them the essential guidance they need in life. Fortunately, a Law of Fortuitous Reversals
also operates in social life. According to this second law, when bad, unintended consequences seem irreparable, the situation suddenly improves dramatically. One fortuitous reversal was the rapid, unforeseen disintegration of the Soviet system a decade ago. Another, just under way, is the unexpected return of Aristotelian common sense in the moral education of American children.

Saturday, July 21, 2012

Five requirements for scientific rigor

From Why psychology isn't science by Alex B. Berezow, a nice succinct definition of the essential attributes of the scientific method.
That's right. Psychology isn't science.

Why can we definitively say that? Because psychology often does not meet the five basic requirements for a field to be considered scientifically rigorous: clearly defined terminology, quantifiability, highly controlled experimental conditions, reproducibility and, finally, predictability and testability.
Convert it to a checklist. When someone says something is real/true/scientific, then one is right to ask whether it has all these attributes:
Clear and unambiguous definitions of critical terms

Clear and comprehendible measurements

Clear, transparent and documented methodology of experimentation or data collection

Results replicated by independent and disinterested parties

Concrete, measurable predicitions of novel outcomes that can be tested as to their veracity

Friday, July 20, 2012

On the path of communication, truth fades away

From Science, health, medical news freaking you out? Do the Double X Double-Take first by Emily Willingham

There’s a recurring problem here. Valuable research is done. Research is disseminated. Information is reported. Articles are read. Findings are spread. What starts in a lab ends up in a Facebook status. What starts as truth ends up as mistruth in something like a child’s game of telephone. Along the way, piece by piece, truth fades away in favor of headlines and pageviews and gossip.

Here is the Double X Double Take, i.e. heuristics for interpreting popularly reported science.
1) Skip the headline
2) What is the basis for the article: original research, opinion, review of previous work?
3) What words does the article use? Link, correlation, risk, association don't mean "biological cause".
4) Look at the original source of the information. Is it from a journal, a conference presentation, a marketing tool?
5) Remember that everyone involved in what you're reading has some return they're seeking.
6) Ask a scientist for clarification. Don't be afraid. We like to talk about science.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Improve, mitigate, tolerate

The New York Times seems to be on a role with articles that highlight people's desire to avoid having to make trade-off decisions.

There was Friends of a Certain Age by Alex Williams highlighting the consequences of having a busy life which crowds out sustaining close friendships.

Then there was Two Classes, Divided by ‘I Do’ by Jason DeParle highlighting the consequences of poor choices.

Seems there have been others. They are of a piece with the recent controversial Atlantic article, Why Women Still Can’t Have It All by Anne-Marie Slaughter

It is as if there is a sudden dawning among the chattering classes that you can't have it all, life is a series of decisions that both open up some opportunities and close down others, decisions that oft-times we are ill-prepared to make and the consequences of which we are reluctant to accept when it emerges we chose poorly. Given that many decisions cannot be unmade, it seems as if there are really only three possible positive outcomes: 1) learn from the experience and determine how to avoid making similarly bad decisions in the future, 2) figure out how to mitigate the undesired consequences, 3) adopt a value system that permits you to put everything into a tolerable context.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Good storytelling and bad argument

Here is an article by Jason DeParle from the NYT that encapsulates many of the themes discussed on this blog in the past couple of years, principally what causes individual and social outcomes and what are the parameters of who benefits and what are the parameters of who bears an obligation to others. And finally the overarching theme of what are the critical elements of northwestern European culture of humanism, empiricism, age of enlightenment values that have rendered subsequent cultures (and individuals) so productive and which of those values remain critical moving forward. The article also serves as an illustration of what happens when someone nominally logical and rational, which I presume Jason DeParle to be, has to deal with both narrative and data that contradicts his own worldview.

In this case his story and the data says that there are many negative consequences to single parenthood, that those consequences are material and long lasting and that they are the result of both changing values and changing decision-making on the part of individuals. What DeParle appears to want to believe is that single parent families are the victims of changing economic circumstances and other factors such as racism. The article is filled with hidden assumptions which betray a particular cast of mind which can only survive on the sustenance of bad reasoning.

The article is an attempt to fuse a narrative (story of two contrasting lives) with data that underpins the contrasts between the two families. The article also, though, is a wonderful illustration of how a reporter can allow emotionalism or ideology to cloud his own argument. There are multiple instances through the article where the reporter renders data so that it seems to indicate the opposite of what it actually says. It becomes clear that the reporter wishes to believe that the two protagonists are subjects of impersonal forces acting on them, rather than (as Classical Liberalism would have) as agents who act on the randomness of the world to extract the best outcome they can achieve. Both protagonists are rather sympathetic but both of them seem to illustrate exactly the opposite of what the reporter wants readers to conclude. Schairer (the poor family) says it herself. ‘“I’m in this position because of decisions I made,” she said.’

Take this example.
Despite the egalitarian trappings of her youth, Ms. Schairer was born (in 1981) as a tidal surge of inequality was remaking American life. Incomes at the top soared, progress in the middle stalled and the paychecks of the poor fell sharply.
Notice the passive voice instead of the active in “a tidal surge of inequality was remaking American life.” But think about it. Take it out of the passive. Did inequality drive the changes in American life? Or did changes in American life change inequality? The data in the article as well as the life stories he is reporting suggest changes in values and decision-making behavior came first and drove the bad outcomes. Yet the reporter can’t help but take the burden of responsibility away from individuals. Stuff happens to them. They don’t cause what happens to them.

Here is another example of the reporter trying to distance decisions from consequences.
She got pregnant during her first year of college, left school and stayed in a troubled relationship that left her with three children when it finally collapsed six years ago.
Again, notice the passive writing. “A troubled relationship left her with three children.” Put it in the active voice and you have the hard fact that she had a prolonged troubled relationship and she had three children. The troubled relationship did not cause the three children. She chose them or chose actions that led to them.

Another example. Look at the first two pictures in the picture gallery. They are supposed to represent parallel boys, one in a family at the brink of poverty and one well ensconced in prosperity. But can you actually tell that looking at the materials in their respective rooms? I can’t. With just a quick glance, I see three contrasts between the two pictures, none of them having to do with material markers of prosperity. In one, the boy is listless staring off into space in the middle of a clean but chaotic, disorganized room. In the other, the boy is focused and engaged, sitting in the middle of a clean organized room. In the background there is a man doing laundry. If you only had those two pictures as data points, knew nothing else and were commanded to place a $1,000 bet on which boy would grow to be successful, which would you choose? I would wager 90% would pick boy two even if they were unconscious of reasons why they did so. In a high volume, high velocity, high churn, dynamic life environment, all of us make decisions on the barest of information. Each decision then has a compounding effect. Which of these two boys is more often going to get the benefit of the doubt by somebody making a split-second decision?

Some of the sentences are so mangled as to hardly make sense. You have to fill in a lot of unstated assumptions to really understand what the reporter is trying to say.
Economic woes speed marital decline, as women see fewer “marriageable men.”
Take the first element and recollect the discussion pyramid.


Economic woes speed marital decline – Really? Literally is that real? Break it further into two parts

Everyone is far more prosperous (both in terms of income and in terms of wealth) today than fifty years ago and yet there is a decline in marriage rates from 72% in 1960 to 51% in 2010. So if people are materially better off but are marrying less, is that consistent with “economic woes speed marital decline”? Doesn’t seem like it. The statistics would say that the wealthier you become over time, the less likely you are to marry. Even in the lowest quintiles real income and real wealth are up but that is where the decline in marriage is concentrated. So the statistical link between marriage and prosperity appears to be weak from a causative perspective. No doubt there are individuals where economic circumstances prevent marriage or exacerbate problems in a marriage leading to divorce. But policy is not made based on anecdotes and the exceptions. Again, it seems the reporter has gotten his own story backwards. In the bulk of the article he is showing that declining marriage speeds economic woes. It is nice to blame the economy but keep your story straight.

Interestingly, what the reporter’s data says, and which he omits to link together, is that 1) Over fifty years the US has become much wealthier and average real incomes have increased for everyone, for some faster than others. 2) Over those fifty years, marriage rates have declined by 30% (from 72 to 51) while everyone was becoming wealthier and richer (income). 3) Income inequality has risen in those decades from 5:1 to 10:1 between the richest and poorest 10% of the population. 4) Those among the richest whose incomes have increased the fastest have maintained or increased their traditional high rates of marriage. Those among the poorest whose real incomes have stagnated have seen their marriage rates plummet. The logical conclusion one would draw from this sequence of factual statements is that either marriage itself or the behaviors and values that sustain a marriage are directly correlated with large increases in individual and familial productivity. So what do you do if you want to decrease income inequality? Seems like marriage or the values and behaviors that sustain marriage have to be in the mix of solutions but that is not offered by the reporter.

The second part, ‘women see fewer “marriageable men.”’ – Really? Do women not marry because they see fewer marriageable men? Is it that men have become less attractive in some fashion, or that women have changed their expectations. Or is it men that are choosing not to marry? I don’t know without researching it. While the explanation is at least plausible it is extremely imprecise and therefore on the face of it improbable. I can come up with any number of potential reasons why men or women might be electing not to marry at the same rates as in the past. Data has to tell me which speculations have any grounding in reality. I doubt, once rendered into a rigorous proposition, that fewer “marriageable men” is a tenable root cause. Trade-offs and choices.

The Pew Charitable Trust had a recent report on this issue and which seems to be the basis of parts of this article and it indicates:
Fallout from the Great Recession may be a factor in the recent decrease in newlyweds, although the linkage between marriage rates and economic hard times is not entirely clear.
So the author is making a statement that removes the burden of responsibility from the unmarried parent but in a fashion that contradicts the rest of his article as well as the empirical research on which the article is based.

Here’s where we begin to get to the heart of the issue. What argument is the reporter making?
But for inequality more broadly, Mr. Western found that the growth in single parenthood in recent decades accounted for 15 percent to 25 percent of the widening income gaps. (Estimates depend on the time period, the income tiers and the definition of inequality.) Gary Burtless of the Brookings Institution found it to account for 21 percent. Robert Lerman of the Urban Institute, comparing lower-middle- and upper-middle-income families, found that single parenthood explained about 40 percent of inequality’s growth. “That’s not peanuts,” he said.

Across Middle America, single motherhood has moved from an anomaly to a norm with head-turning speed. (That change received a burst of attention this year with the publication of Charles Murray’s new book, “Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960-2010,” which attributed the decline of marriage to the erosion of values, rather than the decline of economic opportunity.)
From that last paragraph, the reporter appears to be making the argument that decline in economic opportunity is the driver rather than Murray’s argument of decline in values. But the reporter’s own reporting this far into the article has already demonstrated that change in values preceded change in personal economic decline.

The author’s straining to remove accountability from the individual is played out further down the article.
Scott Winship of the Brookings Institution examined the class trajectories of 2,400 Americans now in their mid-20s. Among those raised in the poorest third as teenagers, 58 percent living with two parents moved up to a higher level as adults, compared with just 44 percent of those with an absent parent.

A parallel story played out at the top: just 15 percent of teenagers living with two parents fell to the bottom third, compared with 27 percent of teenagers without both parents.

“You’re more likely to rise out of the bottom if you live with two parents, and you’re less likely to fall out of the top,” Mr. Winship said.

Mr. Winship interprets his own results cautiously, warning that other differences (like race, education or parenting styles) may also separate the two groups. And even if marriage helped the people who got married, he warns, it might hurt other families if it tied them to troubled men.
“Interprets his own results cautiously” really means “wants to avoid the obvious conclusion”. Charles Murray wrote his book focusing on whites because he wanted to remove the issue of race from the possible causes. Murray found identical results to Winship (in terms of mobility), so Winship’s explanation of race (in the last paragraph) as a possible cause of differences is disqualified. Yet the reporter allows it to be introduced though he must be aware that it is wrong.

Again, the reporter seems to be straining to make the participants in this morality play to be the victims of impersonal forces such as globalization, declining economic opportunity and racism and to similarly make the argument that rising income inequality is rooted in globalization, declining economic opportunity and racism. In fact the entire article, despite the reporter’s gloss, seems an endorsement of all the Classical Liberal/Age of Enlightenment bedrock beliefs such as agency, effort, family, etc.

Ms. Shairer seems a very sympathetic character. She was raised in comfortable circumstances, she had the full range of opportunities made available by the wealthiest country in the world. She made some bad decisions, each compounding the other, which cumulatively have had a very material impact on her prosperity. She continues to do the right things, seeks the best for her children, works hard, hopes for the best, takes responsibility for decisions rather than trying to ascribe her circumstances to the actions of others. I wish her the best.

But the reporter wants to make her a victim. By doing so he disrespects her and misdirects the reader.

In some ways this is similar to a news report three or four years ago as the foreclosure crisis appeared to be cresting. I think it was NPR rather than NYT but the report was intended to show a middle class victim of the foreclosure crisis suffering the travails imposed by an inequitable system. When you listened to the report though, all the problems seemed to be sourced to the quality (or lack thereof) of decision-making by the protagonist. My recollection is that it went something like this. She held a solid middle management salaried job in NYC. She was divorced and had a single adolescent daughter. She decided to move to Florida to be near family. She quit her job in NYC without first having found one in Florida (mistake one). She was enamored with the space in Florida and cheapness of real estate compared to NYC and ended up buying a four bedroom home for she and her daughter (mistake two). She took out a no money down balloon mortgage (mistake three). She did not read the contract or forecast her monthly payments (mistake four). Etc. All classic bad decisions likely to lead to trouble. So the report, which was intended to make out the financial institutions to be the cruel bad guys (and no doubt they also made bad decisions), ended up making the protagonist to appear the lead author in her own tragic downfall.

This article by DeParle is actually a pleasant read about a relevant and concerning issue but it illustrates how important it is to constantly read materials with a skeptical cast of mind to understand the difference between information that is being offered (which supports one conclusion) versus the narrative into which it is being forced to fit (which leads to a different conclusion).

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

“No,” said Grandfather Bear. “But I may be scared.”

Else Holmelund Minarik passed away on Thursday July 12th, aged 91.

I wrote an essay in August 2007 in the Featured Author series on Through the Magic Door which is worth resurrecting in commemoration. So few people in the headlines can anticipate having such a subtle but lasting influence as authors of children’s books.

* * * * * *

According to Else Holmelund Minarik, although she has degrees in psychology and education, her primary work has been done in her garden where she does her best thinking. In fact, her garden was the place where one of her most enduring ideas came to her: the idea of publishing some of the stories she had written for her daughter, Brooke, who had wanted to learn to read at a young age. Minarik (who was at the time a first grade teacher) recalls:
“I considered one day, while setting out the spring garden, that plants and children are alike in this respect – they flower beautifully if placed in the right setting, and subjected to no gaps of neglect, either by us, or by nature. I thought of my first graders, all as willing and marvelous as the plants I was tucking into the earth. They had learned the elementals of reading, and yet would, almost to a one, spend the summer without using this fine new skill, and would return in September to astonish their second grade teacher with a seemingly complete lack of memory. Here was a gap that needed mending! I submitted my books to Miss Ursula Nordstrom of Harper and Row, who said this was just what she had been looking for, and promptly began the I Can Read series with my first book Little Bear – so superbly illustrated by Maurice Sendak.”

- Third Book of Junior Authors, edited by Doris de Montreville and Donna Hill
Little Bear, published in 1957, was very successful and popular for a variety of reasons. The language was simple enough for a young reader to read and enjoy on his own, yet the stories were not overly simplified or full of repetition. Instead, they were interesting and offered a character (Little Bear) with whom young readers could identify as his experiences with his loving family and friends were similar to those of many young children: visiting grandparents, hearing stories about his parents when they were young, making new friends, going to birthday parties, playing and visiting with old friends, etc. The tone of the stories is gentle, yet humorous. For example, in Little Bear’s Visit, when Little Bear asks Grandfather to tell him a goblin story, the following exchange occurs:
“Yes, if you will hold my paw,” said Grandfather

“I will not be scared,” said Little Bear.

“No,” said Grandfather Bear. “But I may be scared.”

Else Holmelund Minarik ©
My mother read Little Bear to me before I learned to read for myself. The stories were particular favorites and I loved poring over every detail of the illustrations. I clearly remember coming home from school one day, picking up one of the Little Bear books just to look at it and finding that I could read it. What a thrill that was!

Minarik’s success with early readers for children did not stop with Little Bear and the subsequent books in the Little Bear series. She has over forty five books to her credit and has continued to write books for young readers with the most recent being published within the last couple of years. Some, but not all, of her more recent titles are extensions to the Little Bear series. It should be noted that there was a 30+ year hiatus in the Little Bear series. The last of the original Little Bear books (written by Minarik, illustrated by Maurice Sendak) was entitled A Kiss For Little Bear and was published in 1968. The Little Bear books published more recently (after the Little Bear television show came out in the late 1990’s) are still written by Minarik, but are not illustrated by Maurice Sendak, although there does appear to have been an attempt to make the characters look roughly similar to the way they do in Sendak’s drawings. They are often focused on a particular problem (Little Bear’s Loose Tooth, Little Bear’s Bad Day) and read more like a summary of a television show. Maybe it’s just me, but I prefer the originals.

No Fighting, No Biting! (another of my personal favorites) was published in 1958. Its appeal lies in Minarik’s ability to capture the little squabbles that young children have with their siblings in a very humorous way, comparing the children to little alligators. My mother frequently admonished my siblings and me with the phrase “no fighting, no biting!” when she wanted us to behave nicely and we knew just exactly what she meant.

Else Holmelund Minarik was born in Denmark in 1920, but immigrated to the United States at the age of four. She found learning English daunting and was rather put off by the language. In an autobiographical sketch done for the Third Book of Junior Authors, Minarik states “I hated the language immediately. Father coped by introducing me to cowboy movies. Mother took me almost daily to the park where she taught me to communicate with playmates. In time I became American.” Of course, anyone who reads her books will know that Minarik is particularly gifted in telling stories in simple, captivating language – a difficult feat for any writer.

Minarik went on to receive a degree in education New Paltz College of the State University of New York and a B.A. in psychology at Queens College (now Queens College of the City University of New York) in 1942. Both were no doubt useful during her brief career as a newspaper reporter during World War II and, later, as a first grade teacher on rural Long Island, NY. She married Walter Minarik in 1940 and they had one daughter, Brooke, for whom Minarik first began writing stories. She has moved south to North Carolina, but continues to write stories for children. I hope you and your children will enjoy her stories as much as we and our children have. Fortunately, there is a good selection of her work still in print.