Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Comkitsch Fusion

Well this is just wonderfully bizarre. A North Korean news clip of a performance for the new leader Kim Jong Un. An almost incomprehensible fusion of:
Communist dictatorship
Disney kitsch
Militarism
Hollywood theatrical showmanship
Confuscian culture
Western musical instruments
Hereditary autocracy
Manufactured enthusiasm
Stiff regimentation

Monday, July 16, 2012

Especially if you don't think too hard

From Ann Althouse, "Money the government is spending on old people means young people are free not to take care of them." Moral hazards and unintended consequences.
The government is taking over the role once provided by family. It was not so long ago that people believed that if they didn't save up money and provide for their own old age that they would be a burden on their children. And it was quite common to worry that your aging parents would need to move in with you and be economically dependent on you. Many families had a grandmother living in their home.

And now, the government has become the basis of our expectations. There's a feeling of security (especially if you don't think too hard). And there's a freedom from the bondage of family. The government is more your family than your family.

Sunday, July 15, 2012

I have found that no exertion of legs can bring two minds much nearer to one another

Thoreau in Walden
Men frequently say to me, "I should think you would feel lonesome down there, and want to be nearer to folks, rainy and snowy days and nights especially." I am tempted to reply to such, — This whole earth which we inhabit is but a point in space. How far apart, think you, dwell the two most distant inhabitants of yonder star, the breadth of whose disk cannot be appreciated by our instruments? Why should I feel lonely? is not our planet in the Milky Way? This which you put seems to me not to be the most important question. What sort of space is that which separates a man from his fellows and makes him solitary? I have found that no exertion of legs can bring two minds much nearer to one another.

Mysterious pattern of technology adoption

Consumption Spreads Faster Today from the New York Times

Makes the point discussed in Steve Johnson's Where Good Ideas Come From that for the past fifty years there has been a rather reliable but mysterious relationship for major technology adoption - ten years between idea and deployment and an additional ten years between technology introduction and mass adoption.


Proximity, Connectivity, Trust - The magical elixir

From Friends of a Certain Age by Alex Williams.

Discussing the making of new friends as one ages.
As external conditions change, it becomes tougher to meet the three conditions that sociologists since the 1950s have considered crucial to making close friends: proximity; repeated, unplanned interactions; and a setting that encourages people to let their guard down and confide in each other
Never heard of those as the three conditions before but it makes logical sense. Also sounds like the preconditions for meme exchange as well as creativity. Also would support the sense of history accelerating. If you are a hunter-gather society, hardly any of those conditions are ever met. As communal living becomes more dense through agriculture and then hamlets, villages, towns, all three conditions can be met more often. People may or may not end up with more friends but there is a greater and greater capacity for meme exchange and serendipitous insight leading to innovation.

The critical item is the last one. In hetergenous society where people increasingly have the opportunity to live self-constructed lives in the midst of high density (i.e. are able to effectively isolate themselves from that with which they do not wish to engage), how do you encourage the creation of trust. Trust seems to me to be the linchpin for experimentation.

Saturday, July 14, 2012

A lot of the rationality that goes into running a business sometimes doesn’t go into these projects

From We Built Way Too Many Cultural Institutions During the Good Years by Emily Badger.

Talking about the inclination of individuals and groups, when on a circumstantial rise (rising economy, improving education, etc.) to suspend rational thought and make decisions based on raw speculation and enthusiasm rather than measured empirical evidence and logical thought.
"These projects are very much emotional, they’re projects that have a lot of passion in them," Woronkowicz says. "A lot of the rationality that goes into running a business sometimes doesn’t go into these projects."

Friday, July 13, 2012

Mutable aspects of life that we tend to think of as settled and universal

From Vanishing Languages by Russ Rymer.

I have a profound yet largely ignorant fascination with language and languages. I regard them as one of the most critical facilities that distinguish humans from the majority of other life on planet earth.

In this article Rymer waxes melancholic about the risk of extinction among the smaller of the 7,000 languages currently spoken on earth. While I share the emotional attachment and regret, to some extent, I believe this to be one of those inexorable copybook headings, to wit, "If you don't work you die."

As populations reconnect after their long dispersal out of Africa 50,000 years ago (and which led to the diversity of languages in the first place), and after long periods of evolutionary diversity in terms of technology, governance, religious belief, cultural values, etc. it would seem inevitable that some configurations (and their attendant languages) work far better for ensuring security of life and propagation, than others. Those that don't work (and their languages) will fall by the wayside unless there is some sort of benefit. Pure Darwinism.
In an increasingly globalized, connected, homogenized age, languages spoken in remote places are no longer protected by national borders or natural boundaries from the languages that dominate world communication and commerce. The reach of Mandarin and English and Russian and Hindi and Spanish and Arabic extends seemingly to every hamlet, where they compete with Tuvan and Yanomami and Altaic in a house-to-house battle. Parents in tribal villages often encourage their children to move away from the insular language of their forebears and toward languages that will permit greater education and success.

Who can blame them? The arrival of television, with its glamorized global materialism, its luxury-consumption proselytizing, is even more irresistible. Prosperity, it seems, speaks English. One linguist, attempting to define what a language is, famously (and humorously) said that a language is a dialect with an army. He failed to note that some armies are better equipped than others. Today any language with a television station and a currency is in a position to obliterate those without, and so residents of Tuva must speak Russian and Chinese if they hope to engage with the surrounding world. The incursion of dominant Russian into Tuva is evident in the speaking competencies of the generation of Tuvans who grew up in the mid-20th century, when it was the fashion to speak, read, and write in Russian and not their native tongue.
On the pathos of linguistic passing.
Much of public life in Palizi is regulated through the repetition of mythological stories used as forceful fables to prescribe behavior. Thus a money dispute can draw a recitation about a spirit whose daughters are eaten by a crocodile, one by one, as they cross the river to bring him dinner in the field. He kills the crocodile, and a priest promises to bring the last daughter back to life but overcharges so egregiously that the spirit seeks revenge by becoming a piece of ginger that gets stuck in the greedy priest’s throat.

Such stories were traditionally told by the elders in a highly formal version of Aka that the young did not yet understand and according to certain rules, among them this: Once an elder begins telling a story, he cannot stop until the story is finished. As with linguistic literacy, disruption is disaster. Yet Aka’s young people no longer follow their elders in learning the formal version of the language and the stories that have governed daily life. Even in this remote region, young people are seduced away from their mother tongue by Hindi on the television and English in the schools. Today Aka’s speakers number fewer than 2,000, few enough to put it on the endangered list.

One night in Palizi, Harrison, Anderson, an Indian linguist named Ganesh Murmu, and I sat cross-legged around the cooking fire at the home of Pario Nimasow, a 25-year-old teacher at the Jesuit school. A Palizi native, Nimasow loved his Aka culture even as he longed to join the outside world. In his sleeping room in an adjacent hut was a television waiting for the return of electricity, which had been out for many months thanks to a series of landslides and transformer malfunctions. After dinner Nimasow disappeared for a moment and came back with a soiled white cotton cloth, which he unfolded by the flickering light of the cooking fire. Inside was a small collection of ritual items: a tiger’s jaw, a python’s jaw, the sharp-toothed mandible of a river fish, a quartz crystal, and other objects of a shaman’s sachet. This sachet had belonged to Nimasow’s father until his death in 1991.

“My father was a priest,” Nimasow said, “and his father was a priest.” And now? I asked. Was he next in line? Nimasow stared at the talismans and shook his head. He had the kit, but he didn’t know the chants; his father had died before passing them on. Without the words, there was no way to bring the artifacts’ power to life.
On the capacity of different languages to profile unexamined assumptions inherent in other languages.
Different languages highlight the varieties of human experience, revealing as mutable aspects of life that we tend to think of as settled and universal, such as our experience of time, number, or color. In Tuva, for example, the past is always spoken of as ahead of one, and the future is behind one’s back. “We could never say, I’m looking forward to doing something,” a Tuvan told me. Indeed, he might say, “I’m looking forward to the day before yesterday.” It makes total sense if you think of it in a Tuvan sort of way: If the future were ahead of you, wouldn’t it be in plain view?

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Stickiness

From At Last: A Gettysburg Address America Can Be Proud Of by Walter Russell Mead

Mead, tongue in cheek, renders famous American texts into modern politi-speak. His contrast of the Gettysburg Address as delivered by Lincoln versus what might be rendered by an academic would seem to highlight the six criteria identified by Chip and Dan Heath as to what are the attributes that make a book, idea, speech, product, song, poem, etc. perennial. Their book is Made to Stick and the six criteria are:
* Simplicity
* Unexpectedness
* Concreteness
* Credibility
* Emotional
* Stories
Lincoln's version meets most these criteria. The politi-speak version fails on most these criteria.



Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Who says meritocracy says oligarchy

Back to Why Elites Fail by Christopher Hayes and his thoughts on the challenges of meritocracy.
The dynamic Michels identifies applies, in an analogous way, to our own cherished system of meritocracy. In order for it to live up to its ideals, a meritocracy must comply with two principles. The first is the Principle of Difference, which holds that there is vast differentiation among people in their ability and that we should embrace this natural hierarchy and set ourselves the challenge of matching the hardest-working and most talented to the most difficult, important and remunerative tasks.

The second is the Principle of Mobility. Over time, there must be some continuous, competitive selection process that ensures performance is rewarded and failure punished. That is, the delegation of duties cannot simply be made once and then fixed in place over a career or between generations. People must be able to rise and fall along with their accomplishments and failures. When a slugger loses his swing, he should be benched; when a trader loses money, his bonus should be cut. At the broader social level, we hope that the talented children of the poor will ascend to positions of power and prestige while the mediocre sons of the wealthy will not be charged with life-and-death decisions. Over time, in other words, society will have mechanisms that act as a sort of pump, constantly ensuring that the talented and hard-working are propelled upward, while the mediocre trickle downward.

But this ideal, appealing as it may be, runs up against the reality of what I’ll call the Iron Law of Meritocracy. The Iron Law of Meritocracy states that eventually the inequality produced by a meritocratic system will grow large enough to subvert the mechanisms of mobility. Unequal outcomes make equal opportunity impossible. The Principle of Difference will come to overwhelm the Principle of Mobility. Those who are able to climb up the ladder will find ways to pull it up after them, or to selectively lower it down to allow their friends, allies and kin to scramble up. In other words: “Who says meritocracy says oligarchy.”
I think Hayes is on to something important though I think it more complex than he indicates.

A complicating factor is that the challenge is our comprehension of "matching the hardest-working and most talented to the most difficult, important and remunerative tasks." I suspect that on first read, most people would interpret this as matching the smartest and hardest working to the most productive work. However, productive work consists of two elements, maximizing a desired outcome AND minimizing risk. Measuring maximized outcome can be complicated but it is relatively straightforward compared to measuring the impact of minimizing/mitigating risk.

For a number of years I ran global consulting businesses and as part of that we had reasonably rigorous and measured performance reviews semi-annually. Individual consultants were measured based on their contributions to the culture of the organization, the stockpile of knowledge, sales, service delivery, and people management. It was very meretricious and in general it worked extremely well. The one structural challenge arose from the practical realities of major project management.

Periodically we would have a project begin to head off the rails. It might have arisen from some poor performance of key members of our team but usually the problems were sourced on the client side. Their people were not delivering critical path deliverables, there was conflict among their executives, etc. When these situations arose, you needed to put in someone who not only was good at project management and service delivery and billing and collecting, etc. You needed someone with diplomacy and negotiating skills and most critically a strong sense of risk management.

From a performance measurement perspective this created a paradox. You would tend to put your very best people on the most challenging projects with the worst prospective metrics. Projects where simply delivering a break-even outcome might be a huge achievement. So how do you build an objective performance measurement system that rewards people not only based on what they did achieve but also rewards them for what they were able to avoid? We never got to a good systematic solution on that and basically ended up making select executive decision interventions to ensure fairness; a work-around sufficient as long as all participants trust the judgment of the executives but one prone to abuse.

I raise this as an example of complexity in the meritocratic system. Success is as often about problems avoided as it is about opportunities realized but avoided problems are far more difficult to measure objectively. This is another aspect of the Bastiat's issue of the seen and unseen (The Broken Window)

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

The man of system . . . is apt to be very wise in his own conceit

Regarding the need for values/religion to serve as reins on the otherwise unbridled arrogance of the technocrat/meritocrat, Adam Smith spotted this problem long ago in that dawn of classical liberalism.
The man of system . . . is apt to be very wise in his own conceit; and is often so enamoured with the supposed beauty of his own ideal plan of government, that he cannot suffer the smallest deviation from any part of it. He goes on to establish it completely and in all its parts, without any regard either to the great interests or to the strong prejudices which may oppose it. He seems to imagine that he can arrange the different members of a great society with as much ease as the hand arranges the different pieces upon a chess-board.