Monday, July 9, 2012

Who says organization says oligarchy

Why Elites Fail by Christopher Hayes. Another interesting article on the challenges of meritocracy. There are several premises to Hayes' argument which I think are suspect however there is a lot of good material and some keen insights.

He references a German social theorist of whom I had never heard but who sounds interesting, Robert Michels. Hunter is the merit based competitive public high school which the author attended in the 1990s.
By 2009, Hunter’s demographics were radically different—just 3 percent black and 1 percent Hispanic, according to the New York Times. With the rise of a sophisticated and expensive test-preparation industry, the means of selecting entrants to Hunter has grown less independent of the social and economic hierarchies in New York at large. The pyramid of merit has come to mirror the pyramid of wealth and cultural capital.

How and why does this happen? I think the best answer comes from the work of a social theorist named Robert Michels, who was occupied with a somewhat parallel problem in the early years of the last century. Born to a wealthy German family, Michels came to adopt the radical socialist politics then sweeping through much of Europe. At first, he joined the Social Democratic Party, but he ultimately came to view it as too bureaucratic to achieve its stated aims. “Our workers’ organization has become an end in itself,” Michels declared, “a machine which is perfected for its own sake and not for the tasks which it could have performed.”

Michels then drifted toward the syndicalists, who eschewed parliamentary elections in favor of mass labor solidarity, general strikes and resistance to the dictatorship of the kaiser. But even among the more militant factions of the German left, Michels encountered the same bureaucratic pathologies that had soured him on the SDP. In his classic book Political Parties, he wondered why the parties of the left, so ideologically committed to democracy and participation, were as oligarchic in their functioning as the self-consciously elitist and aristocratic parties of the right.

Michels’s grim conclusion was that it was impossible for any party, no matter its belief system, to bring about democracy in practice. Oligarchy was inevitable. For any kind of institution with a democratic base to consolidate the legitimacy it needs to exist, it must have an organization that delegates tasks. The rank and file will not have the time, energy, wherewithal or inclination to participate in the many, often minute decisions necessary to keep the institution functioning. In fact, effectiveness, Michels argues convincingly, requires that these tasks be delegated to a small group of people with enough power to make decisions of consequence for the entire membership. Over time, this bureaucracy becomes a kind of permanent, full-time cadre of leadership. “Without wishing it,” Michels says, there grows up a great “gulf which divides the leaders from the masses.” The leaders now control the tools with which to manipulate the opinion of the masses and subvert the organization’s democratic process. “Thus the leaders, who were at first no more than the executive organs of the collective, will soon emancipate themselves from the mass and become independent of its control.”

All this flows inexorably from the nature of organization itself, Michels concludes, and he calls it “The Iron Law of Oligarchy”: “It is organization which gives birth to the dominion of the elected over the electors, of the mandataries over the mandators, of the delegates over the delegators. Who says organization says oligarchy.”

Sunday, July 8, 2012

Whatever the argument does not supply, the paradigm conveniently fills in

From To Predict Environmental Doom, Ignore the Past by Todd Myers.

While the essay is a critique of a poorly argued article on global warming, the author has a deeper insight which I think is significant.
The need to avoid perceived global catastrophe also encourages the authors to blow past warning signs that their analysis is not built on solid foundations – as if the poor history of such projections were not already warning enough. Even as they admit the interactions “between overlapping complex systems, however, are providing difficult to characterize mathematically,” they base their conclusions on the simplest linear mathematical estimate that assumes nothing will change except population over the next 40 years. They then draw a straight line, literally, from today to the environmental tipping point.

Why is such an unscientific approach allowed to pass for science in a respected international journal? Because whatever the argument does not supply, the paradigm conveniently fills in. Even if the math isn’t reliable and there are obvious counterarguments, “everyone” understands and believes in the underlying truth – we are nearing the limits of the planet’s ability to support life. In this way the conclusion is not proven but assumed, making the supporting argument an impenetrable tautology.
I have been arguing in my work on decision-making about how critical it is for a team of individuals to explicitly articulate what they understand about the context of the decision they are about to make, i.e. describe the environment and its characteristics in which this decision is to be made.

Myers' comment suggests that there is a more fundamental issue that needs to be explicilty brought to the fore - what is your paradigm? Somewhat challenging to do but probably not wrong that it ought to be done. I have often encountered individuals and teams who have an unshakeable conviction that what they are doing is the right thing without their being able to articulate why it is the right thing to do. Simply refuting them on a factual point by factual point basis is hard work and usually not all that productive. That is not the way to take down an "impenetrable tautology".

At this particular point I do not have a good answer as to how you do that but I recognize that in some circumstances that is what needs to be done.

Saturday, July 7, 2012

If, during the long course of ages and under varying conditions of life . . .

Charles Darwin in On The Origin of Species, describing in a single paragraph one of the most monumental cognitive leaps forward in all of human history. While dense, I suspect the meaning would be clear to virtually anyone.
If, during the long course of ages and under varying conditions of life, organic beings vary at all in the several parts of their organization, and I think this cannot be disputed; if there be, owing to the high geometric powers of increase of each species, at some age, season or year, a severe struggle for life, and this certainly cannot be disputed; then, considering the infinite complexity of the relations of all organic beings to each other and to their conditions of existence, causing an infinite variety in structure, constitution, and habits, to be advantageous to them, I think it would be a most extraordinary fact if no variation ever had occurred useful to each being’s own welfare, in the same way as so many variations have occurred useful to man. But if variations useful to any organic being do occur, assuredly individuals thus characterized will have the best chance of being preserved in the struggle for life; and from the strong principle of inheritance they will tend to produce offspring similarly characterized. This principle of preservation, I have called, for the sake of brevity, Natural Selection.


Friday, July 6, 2012

Attempt to close minds of people on the same side as the author

From Opening Minds, Closing Minds by Arnold Kling.
The following thought occurred to me recently. Suppose we look at writing on issues where people tend to hold strong opinions that fit with their ideology. Such writing can

(a) attempt to open the minds of people on the opposite side as the author

(b) attempt to open minds of people on the same side as the author

(c) attempt to close minds of people on the same side as the author

So, think about it. Wouldn't you classify most op-eds and blog posts as (c)? Isn't that sort of pathetic? Here are some more thoughts:

1. The default is (c). If you are not consciously trying to do (a) or (b), then you will almost surely do (c).

2. Most of us, most of the time, do (c).

3. Doing (c) 100 % of the time can earn you fame and fortune. Yes, you get criticized for it by people on the other side, but the positive reinforcement you get probably more than makes up for it.

4. Try to think of folks who try to have a high proportion of (a) and (b). The first ones that I think of are David Brooks and Tyler Cowen. I wish I could think of more.
I struggle to interpret Kling's nomenclature. My understanding would be that a is when you seek to change the belief of others who disagree by using facts and logic, b is when you try and reinforce the belief of people who already agree using facts and logic and c is when you try and reinforce the belief of those who already agree by using rhetoric. Which, by extension of the implied model means that there is a d when you try and change the belief of others who disagree by using rhetoric.

I agree with the fundamental point though that there is an awful lot of noise to signal, i.e. a lot of c and d compared to a and b. The challenge with c and d are that there is a short and slippery slope between rhetoric and demonization/ad hominem attacks. Also, there is a legitimate question as to which is more effective, rhetoric or logic and analysis. The answer, I suspect, being that it is the seamless integration of logic and analysis with good rhetoric that is the most effective.


Thursday, July 5, 2012

Reasons for failing, reasons for succeeding

Kind of flawed as I think is Acemoglu's over-reliance on institutional effectiveness as the total explanation for the varying degrees of economic development/productivity around the world. See Occam’s Butter Knife by Steve Sailer for a sharp take down of Acemoglu's theory. And to be clear, it is not that I think institutional effectiveness is unimportant. It is simply that I view it as one among several important conditions necessary to optimize personal and group prodictuivity.

But I am a sucker for lists and here is one on a topic near and dear. 10 Reasons Countries Fall Apart by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson.

Acemoglu and Robinson's list of ten reasons:
Lack of property rights
Reliance on coercion in production
Rent seeking
Monopolies
Rejection of innovation
Absence of law and order
Weak government
Poor services/infrastructure
Repression
Zero Sum orientation
I have renamed their ten items to better reflect the underlying principles. I think there is relative merit in most of these items, particularly recast as they are. I think they were running out of steam to get to ten because weak government doesn't seem to belong here or is a duplication of other items already on the list.

So these ten items (or nine) serve the function of a canary in a coal mine. The greater degree to which a country manifests any or all of these factors, the more likely they are to be a failure in terms of sustained productivity. What is interesting to me is that in many ways these seem to be the inverse elements of the attributes which have underpinned classical liberalism/age of enlightenment culture:
Agency
Freedom
Natural Rights
Pluralism
Rule of Law
Consent of the Governed
Property Rights
Competition
Trade
Trust
Empiricism
Logic
Scientific Method
Checks and Balances
Connectivity
Specialization
With these two lists, you have the opportunity of doing the wrong things as well as the opportunity to cultivate the right things. Ought to be able to make some progress on that basis.


Wednesday, July 4, 2012

The first problem is arrogance

I have long been trying to figure out exactly what type of role a religious belief system plays in the long term success of individuals and cultures. It seems indisputable to me that it does play a role but teasing out which are the key attributes that are the causative components to survival and productivity is extraordinarily difficult.

My suspicion is that certain religious traditions, by their stated value systems, encourage certain behaviors that contribute to productivity and discourage other behaviors more contributive of destructive outcomes. But which values and which behaviors, "ay, there's the rub!"

Walter Russell Mead has an interesting essay that contributes some thoughts on this issue, Is Meritocracy a Sham? Mead is discussing some of the weaknesses that undermine an otherwise generally positive picture of meritocracy as a useful model for social organization. Essentially Mead's answer is that there tends to be a correlation between meritocracy and atheism. This is important because, from Mead's perspective, meritocracy needs religion to serve as a restraint on megalomania; in this instance Mead is speaking specifically to some of the attributes of Christianity in general and Protestant Christianity in particular. I think he is on to something.
This has to do with another dimension of today’s American meritocracy that I think is deeply problematic: atheism.

Now before all the atheists out there ignite a new flame war in the comments pages, let me make some points. I’m not about to argue that all religious people are nicer or better than all atheists. And there are many atheists who avoid some or all of the pitfalls I’m about to explore. I am not writing this as a criticism of particular individuals; there are lots of atheistic meritocrats in America today who I consider friends and for whose achievements and character I have both admiration and respect. And before the foreign readers go incandescent in gibbering rage, let me also point out that I’m talking much more about atheism in an American context than in a European one. The dynamic Whiggish optimism that is such a deep element of American culture needs the kind of balance that, classically, comes from a theologically grounded sense both of Original Sin and of God’s transcendence of all human history and thought.

But caveats and cautions aside, there are certain consequences of success in a meritocracy that put people, and especially American people, without a strong religious faith at great risk, and I think we can see today in American life some of the consequences that come when a powerful but to some degree godless social elite lacks the spiritual resources and vocabulary that would better equip it for its role.

The first problem is arrogance. A practicing and committed as opposed to a theoretical or a birth Christian (and I talk about Christians rather than Jews, Muslims or Hindus or other people because this is what I know best, not because I’m trying to say that only Christians derive these kinds of benefits from their faith) who succeeds in a meritocratic structure has all kinds of inner convictions and reflections that can keep his or her arrogance within limits. This doesn’t always work; the case of Woodrow Wilson is one that we should all study.
Read the whole thing. Mead identifies humility, sanctity of life, equality of life, duty, obligation to serve, personal agency, necessary acceptance of variation in behavior (Original Sin) among other values as ones which Protestant Christianity inculcates and which in turn serve as necessary behavioral attributes to the succesful functioning of a system of meritocracy. He seems to be raising the valid concern that meritocracy absent certain critical values derived from religion might be as bad a system of governance and social organization as many others which we more readily recognize as flawed.

Then there is Doomsday Scenarios Make Better Fiction Than Science, Says Researcher Karl Butzer by David Ochsner in which Butxer comments vis-a-vis the historical record regarding societal collapses:
“There are cultural and psychological factors to consider that are grounded in human perceptions, values and solidarity, factors that cannot be measured through examination of physical evidence alone,” says Butzer, who notes that wars, foreign trade, internal power struggles, even personality quirks of certain leaders are all major factors in the success or failure of a society. He adds that the belief in a “cosmic order” — which gives power and legitimacy to a ruling elite — is a critical factor that is often overlooked in empirical, data-driven research.

For example, Butzer describes the immense complexity of collapse in Egypt after the long but unsteady reign of Pepi II (2278 to 2184 BCE) that was marked by internal power struggles and loss of foreign markets — both part of an intricate, downward spiral of cascading feedbacks. A semblance of order was eventually restored by the high priesthood, legitimized by their connection to the gods or the “cosmic order.”
So in one case we have religion serving as a necessary vehicle for cultivating the values and behaviors that enable systems of governance and societal interaction to work and in the second case we have religion serving essentially as a default system of governance when the primary system fails. I like A better than B but suspect both have a degree of truth.

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

The interesting question is not that a society may have failed, but that it avoided failure

From Doomsday Scenarios Make Better Fiction Than Science, Says Researcher Karl Butzer by David Ochsner.
Collapse becomes possible when people cannot collaborate to find solutions, and that is rare. In most situations, disasters are avoided because people succeed in pulling together to confront crises. The interesting question is not that a society may have failed, but that it avoided failure. That is the lesson.

Monday, July 2, 2012

Misquotations

An interesting discussion on a list_serv to which I belong regarding the misattribution of quotes. There is a fair amount of energy invested in the conversation for a topic that on the surface seems to be but a matter of marginal carelessness. Why?

It seems to me that this is a subset of the broader topic of what constitutes critical thinking. A couple of key characteristics of critical thinking, among many, is accuracy and precision.

When do we use a quote? Often for decoration or to extend a line of thought, similar to the function of a metaphor or an analogy. When used in this way, while it would be nice to have a quotation properly sourced, it is not critical given its function which is to be a spark to the tender of creativity as it were.

But often times a quotation is used as a form of argument, essentially an appeal to authority. In that instance, it becomes reasonably important for the quote to be both accurately relayed and properly sourced.

So when someone quotes something that does not have a good provenance, they are trying to harvest the authority of an individual (a logical fallacy but one that isn’t always wrong) without bothering to make sure that that authority is legitimate. The reader is either insulted by laziness or deceived by mendacity.

Additionally, when someone uses a quote in a lax and imprecise fashion it is, to use an economics concept, a form of signaling. If someone is unreliable in small details, can they be considered reliable on more important matters (falsus in unum, falsus in omnibus)?

Sunday, July 1, 2012

Redemption through reading

From Reading offers Brazilian prisoners quicker escape from Reuters. I love it.
Brazil will offer inmates in its crowded federal penitentiary system a novel way to shorten their sentences: four days less for every book they read.

Inmates in four federal prisons holding some of Brazil's most notorious criminals will be able to read up to 12 works of literature, philosophy, science or classics to trim a maximum 48 days off their sentence each year, the government announced.

Prisoners will have up to four weeks to read each book and write an essay which must "make correct use of paragraphs, be free of corrections, use margins and legible joined-up writing," said the notice published on Monday in the official gazette.

A special panel will decide which inmates are eligible to participate in the program dubbed "Redemption through Reading".

That's funny . . .

H/T Alan Hirshfeld in How Curiosity Killed Schrödinger's Cat
As Isaac Asimov said: "The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not 'Eureka!' [I found it!] but 'That's funny . . .'"