Last night I was reading The Cavalier Poets An Anthology by Thomas Crofts. It includes Herrick's To the Virginia, To Make Much of Time and as I am rereading it, I suddenly realize that both Herrick and Pink Floyd (Roger Waters) are treating both the same topic and even have some similar imagery. They have different motivations and different tones but similar material.
Robert Herrick's
Gather ye rose-buds while ye may,Old Time is still a-flying;And this same flower that smiles todayTomorrow will be dying.
Is matched with Pink Floyd's
Ticking away the momentsThat make up a dull dayFritter and waste the hoursIn an off-hand way
Robert Herrick's
The glorious lamp of heaven, the sun,The higher he’s a-getting,The sooner will his race be run,And nearer he’s to setting.
with Pink Floyd's
And you run and you run
To catch up with the sunBut it's sinkingRacing aroundTo come up behind you again
Robert Herrick's
That age is best which is the first,When youth and blood are warmer;But being spent, the worse, and worstTimes still succeed the former.Then be not coy, but use your time,And while ye may, go marry;For having lost but once your prime,You may forever tarry.
with Pink Floyd's
The sun is the sameIn a relative wayBut you're olderShorter of breathAnd one day closer to deathEvery year is getting shorterNever seem to find the timePlans that either come to naught
Or half a page of scribbled lines
Obviously Herrick's is the more hopeful, life affirming, the more hungering. Roger Waters' version is darker and more resigned and . . . desperate.
They are both wonderful poems but Waters' is deeper, more of an elegy. It has a note of Arnold's Dover Beach which gives it added weight.
Regardless, they are both to be enjoyed in their different ways. I am just struck to only now recognize their parallels.
UPDATE: Ok, now this is just Frequency Illusion. I come across an Auden poem with which I am unfamiliar which contains the same plaint, this time in Get There if You Can and See the Land You Once Were Proud to Own by W.H. Auden. He ends with:
Shut up talking, charming in the best suits to be had in town, Lecturing on navigation while the ship is going down.Drop those priggish ways for ever, stop behaving like a stone: Throw the bath-chairs right away, and learn to leave ourselves alone.If we really want to live, we'd better start at once to try; If we don't, it doesn't matter, but we'd better start to die.
Get There if You Can is darker as with Roger Waters but has the same message along with Herrick.
Carpe Diem - Live now!
No comments:
Post a Comment