Thursday, July 1, 2021

But this was all knavery and collusion

From A Journal of the Plague Year by Daniel Defoe.  

This was the beginning of May, yet the weather was temperate, variable, and cool enough, and people had still some hopes. That which encouraged them was that the city was healthy: the whole ninety-seven parishes buried but fifty-four, and we began to hope that, as it was chiefly among the people at that end of the town, it might go no farther; and the rather, because the next week, which was from the 9th of May to the 16th, there died but three, of which not one within the whole city or liberties; and St Andrew’s buried but fifteen, which was very low. ’Tis true St Giles’s buried two-and-thirty, but still, as there was but one of the plague, people began to be easy. The whole bill also was very low, for the week before the bill was but 347, and the week above mentioned but 343. We continued in these hopes for a few days, but it was but for a few, for the people were no more to be deceived thus; they searched the houses and found that the plague was really spread every way, and that many died of it every day. So that now all our extenuations abated, and it was no more to be concealed; nay, it quickly appeared that the infection had spread itself beyond all hopes of abatement. That in the parish of St Giles it was gotten into several streets, and several families lay all sick together; and, accordingly, in the weekly bill for the next week the thing began to show itself. There was indeed but fourteen set down of the plague, but this was all knavery and collusion, for in St Giles’s parish they buried forty in all, whereof it was certain most of them died of the plague, though they were set down of other distempers; and though the number of all the burials were not increased above thirty-two, and the whole bill being but 385, yet there was fourteen of the spotted-fever, as well as fourteen of the plague; and we took it for granted upon the whole that there were fifty died that week of the plague.  

Parallels with today:

Tipping points where the public (and/or State) recognize that there is no containing the spread.  We hoped that travel restrictions would help and there is evidence that they may have slowed the spread.  But absent a vaccine or natural immunity, the spread proved uncontainable through the proposed maskings and isolations.  A pattern which has held true for virtually all plagues through the years which is why the actions plans for a global pandemic explicitly rejected masking and isolation.  

It appears to me that the public recognized that Covid-19 spread was inevitable much sooner than did the public health authorities. 


No comments:

Post a Comment